BACKGROUND The protozoan disease giardiasis can cause ocular complications, including “salt and pepper” retinal changes.
METHODS Ophthalmic examinations were performed in 141 children (mean age 4.7 (SD 2.0) years) with active or past giardiasis diagnosed on the basis of microscopic examination of stool specimens or duodenal secretions—53 were newly diagnosed and untreated (group A), 50 had active infections in spite of metronidazole therapy (group B), and 38 had been successfully treated, with negative stool specimens for 1–3 years (group C). 300 children with no evidence of giardiasis were used as controls.
RESULTS Salt and pepper retinal changes (with normal electroretinographic findings) were diagnosed in 28 (19.9%) of the patients with giardiasis (11 from group A, 10 from group B, and seven from group C), including five pairs of siblings. In all subgroups, the children with retinal changes were consistently younger than those with normal retinas. In eight cases, the lesions could be visualised only with direct ophthalmoscopy.
CONCLUSION Our findings indicate that asymptomatic, non-progressive retinal lesions are particularly common in younger children with giardiasis. This risk does not seem to be related to the severity of the infection, its duration, or the use of metronidazole but may reflect a genetic predisposition.
- gastrointestinal disease
- Giardia lamblia
Statistics from Altmetric.com
The parasitic disease known as giardiasis is considered to be one of the most common causes of gastroenteritis in the world today.1 The disease is caused by Giardia lamblia, a binucleate protozoan of the Mastigophorasubphylum that has four pairs of flagella.2 The prevalence of giardiasis varies depending on the population being examined, but the highest rates are found in developing countries and crowded urban areas.3
The infective cysts are transmitted oro-faecally or in food and water that have been contaminated with faeces.4 The protozoan colonises the duodenum and upper third of the jejunum, where it is believed to cause direct damage to the microvilli that leads to an accelerated turnover of the mucosal epithelium and, as a result, changes in intestinal transit and absorption.2-5
The infection is often asymptomatic in adults, but symptoms are much more common in children, in part due to the oro-faecal transmission and in part because of the immaturity of their immunological systems.1-6 The primary gastrointestinal symptoms consist of recurrent abdominal pain, diarrhoea, vomiting, and signs of malabsorption. Patients with giardiasis also present extraintestinal symptoms such as fever, maculopapular rashes, geographic tongue, pulmonary infiltrates, lymphadenopathy, polyarthritis, aphthous ulcers, and urticaria.6
The first description of ocular complications in patients with giardiasis was published by Barraquer in 1938.7 This report included cases of iridocyclitis, choroiditis, and retinal haemorrhages. Cases of anterior and posterior uveitis and retinal vasculitis have subsequently been associated with the infection,8-12 and in 1990 Pettoello-Mantovani et al 13 described a “salt and pepper” form of degeneration involving the retinal pigmented epithelium in children suffering from giardiasis.
In the present study, we evaluated the frequency of ocular manifestations in a group of Italian children with current or past giardiasis. To determine whether the course of the disease might be related to the appearance and/or severity of these complications, this frequency was analysed in light of the time of diagnosis, the duration of treatment, and the time interval that had elapsed since the infections had been cured.
Patients and methods
The study population comprised 141 children seen between January 1994 and March 1995 in the paediatric gastroenterology outpatient clinic of the Tor Vergata University Medical Centre in Rome. All had been diagnosed as having Giardia lamblia infections between 1991 and 1994. The children (64 males, 77 females) ranged in age from 9 months to 13 years (mean age 4.7 (SD 2.0) years). All had presented gastrointestinal symptoms. None of the children included in the study had current or past histories of other infections or metabolic diseases, and none had ever been treated with chloroquine, thioridazine, or chlorpromazine, which are known to cause ocular toxicity.
In children less than 3 years of age, the diagnosis of giardiasis was made after the parasite had been isolated from at least three fresh stool specimens (collected 3 hours or less before examination). In older children (that is, 3 years or older), diagnoses were based on examination of duodenal secretions collected with the Enterotest system (HDC Corporation, Mountain View, CA, USA).14 All patients underwent microbiological screening for the following pathogens:Salmonella, Shigella,Campylobacter, Yersinia, Escherichia coli, rotavirus, and adenovirus,15 If any pathogenic micro-organisms, different from Giardia lamblia, were found the patient was excluded from the study.
The study group was divided into three subgroups. Group A comprised 53 children (mean age 4.1 (SD 0.3) years) who were studied immediately after diagnosis before any treatment had been started. Group B included 50 children (mean age 4.0 (0.5) years) who had been diagnosed as having giardiasis 12 months or more before our study. In spite of two or more cycles of treatment (metronidazole 5 mg/kg three times a day for 7–10 days), all of these children presented positive stool specimens at the time of our evaluation. Group C consisted of 38 children (mean age 5.8 (0.8) years) with previous Giardia lamblia infections that had been successfully treated with one or more cycles of metronidazole therapy. In follow ups that ranged from 1 to 3 years, periodic examination of stool specimens had failed to reveal any signs of the protozoan.
The study also included a control group comprised 300 children selected between the ones who attended our outpatient clinic in the same period as the study group. They all came from the same geographical area and had socioeconomic, nutritional characteristics16 17similar to those in the study group. We excluded from the control group all the children who had a positive medical history for infectious diseases (apart for upper respiratory tract infections) and metabolic diseases. They also had never been treated with chloroquine, thioridazine, or chlorpromazine which, as stated earlier, are known to cause ocular toxicity. One hundred and fifty of these children (77 males, 73 females aged 11 months to 14 years; mean age 4.7 (2.1) years) had no gastrointestinal symptoms whatsoever; the remaining 150 (76 males, 74 females aged 9 months to 14 years; mean age 4.7 (1.9) years) were suffering from food allergy, or coeliac disease, or gastro-oesophageal reflux, or toddler diarrhoea and had symptoms such as diarrhoea, vomiting, and/or abdominal pain. All of the control subjects were negative for giardiasis based on microscopic examination of stool specimens (three specimens) and/or duodenal secretions examined at least three times in a period of 3 months.
All the children in both the study and control groups underwent an ophthalmic examination that included measurement of visual acuity, studies of ocular motility, slit lamp examination of the anterior chamber, and direct and indirect ophthalmoscopic examination of the fundus after induction of mydriasis with cyclopentolate.
All the children in both the study and control groups were examined independently by two ophthalmologists. The first (AC) was aware of the child’s enrolment in the study but not his/her group origin (that is, case or control). They were then examined by a second ophthalmologist (CN) who was unaware of the nature of our study or the case/control status of the child. Ocular changes were diagnosed only when detected by both examiners. Electroretinography (ERG) was also performed whenever fundus changes were observed.
The visual acuity examination of the giardiasis group revealed a mean refractive error of −1.0 (SD 0.5) D. Studies of ocular motility and anterior chamber examinations were unremarkable in all 141 children. Changes in the retinal epithelium compatible with a salt and pepper appearance (Fig 1A and 1B) were confirmed by both ophthalmologists in 28/141 (19.9%) children (15 males, 13 females; mean age 3.5 (0.4) years) (Table 1). Three other cases were excluded from analysis because the finding was recorded by only one of the examiners. These lesions presented as punctate areas of hyperpigmentation against a lighter coloured fundus. The changes were more prevalent in the mid periphery of the upper and lower retinal quadrants. Involvement was bilateral in 25/28 cases. In 20 of these children, the lesions could be visualised with both indirect and direct ophthalmoscopy. In the remaining eight, the retinal changes were revealed only with the latter examination. Electroretinograms were normal in all of these 28 children. In one case, both examiners noted additional retinal damage that could be attributed to previous chorioretinitis.
Eleven (39.2%) of the 28 children with retinal lesions were from group A, 10 (35.7%) were from group B, and seven (25%) belonged to group C (Table 1). The group with retinal changes also included five pairs of siblings. In some cases from the latter group, the infection had been diagnosed 3 years before our study. Table 1 shows the ages of the 28 children with positive findings and those of children whose fundus examinations were normal. In all three of the subgroups, the children with retinal lesions were significantly younger than those without lesions (p<0.05, Student’s t test), and the prevalence of positive findings was directly proportional to the mean age of the subgroup. There were no differences among the three subgroups as far as the clinical features or extension of the retinal involvement were concerned. In patients with active infections (groups A and B), there was no correlation between the faecal parasite count and the presence of retinal lesions.
In the 300 children in the control group, neither of the examiners found any retinal lesions of the type observed in the giardiasis group.
The association between Giardia lambliainfection and ocular changes has been described by a number of authors.7-12 In 1990 Pettoello-Mantovani et al described eight cases of salt and pepper retinal degeneration in a group of 90 children with active giardiasis (8.8%).13 In our study, conducted on an even larger population of paediatric giardiasis patients, the percentage of children with these retinal findings was even higher (19.9%), which may reflect the younger age of the children we studied (mean 4.7 yearsv 6.9 years in the previously cited study). The higher frequency that emerges from our study may also be related to our use of both indirect and direct ophthalmoscopy. The higher magnification that can be achieved with the latter approach is often necessary to detect the subtle changes that characterise this type of retinal alteration. In fact, over one fourth of the children with salt and pepper lesions presented normal findings on indirect ophthalmoscopy.
The typical salt and pepper lesion is represented by punctate areas of normal or hyperpigmentation on a lighter, yellow-pink retina.18 In the children we examined, the lesions were more visible at the posterior pole, where there were distributed along the paths of the major blood vessels. These lesions differ from those of the more severe disease known as retinitis pigmentosa, in which the pigment granules are generally distributed in an osteoblast pattern around blood vessels.18 Salt and pepper lesions are thought to be caused by damage to or necrosis of the cells of the retinal pigment epithelium (represented clinically by the paler areas of the retina) with the release of pigment granules that migrate to the deeper retinal layers, where they can be seen as blackish dots.18
Similar findings have been described in other diseases as well, including cystinosis and various types of infection (for example, congenital syphilis, rubella, toxoplasmosis, and onchocerciasis).18 It has also been reported following the use of antimalarial drugs, phenothiazine, iodinated substances, and oral contraceptives.19
The mechanisms underlying the ocular lesions associated with giardiasis are currently obscure. Although microscopic studies on ocular tissues have never been performed, most authors exclude the possibility of direct invasion by the parasite. Indeed, the protozoan has never been isolated from any of the lesions caused by this disease, including urticaria, which is the manifestation that most strongly resembles the retinal arteritis and ocular inflammation seen in patients with ocular involvement. The retinal changes associated with giardiasis are more than likely caused by immune mechanisms. Wania reported that circulating immune complexes were found in all of the patients with ocular complications he examined.20 In addition, histological examination of urticarial lesions caused by giardiasis have demonstrated the presence of infiltrates composed of polymorphonuclear cells, lymphocytes, and eosinophils.10It is possible that small children are more susceptible to this type of damage because of the immaturity of the retinal epithelium cells. This hypothesis is compatible with our observation of a higher frequency of ocular complications among the younger children of all three subgroups in the present study.
The group of patients with retinal manifestations included five pairs of siblings. Recent reports have linked giardiasis to certain HLA istotypes21 ; since retinal pigmented epithelium degenerations are often genetically transmitted,18 it is therefore possible that the appearance of retinal complications depends, in part, on a genetic predisposition.
An analysis of the data from subgroups A (untreated, recently diagnosed infections) and B (long standing infections resistant to therapy) failed to reveal any significant differences in terms of either the prevalence or the severity of the retinal lesions found. This finding suggests that the development of this type of retinal change does not depend on either the severity or the evolution of the infection. Moreover, the observation of retinal lesions in group A (children who had not been treated at all) confirms previous reports that metronidazole does not influence the appearance or the evolution of these lesions. The retinal changes were found with a similar frequency among the children of group C, whose infections had been successfully eliminated 1–3 years before our study, indicating that the retinal lesions do not progress (or regress) with time.
These lesions do not appear to cause functional changes in the retina, since electroretinographic findings were normal in all of the children with retinal lesions although this conclusion will have to be confirmed in long term follow up. However, the absence of ERG changes is also important from a diagnostic point of view, since it distinguishes the salt and pepper changes from progressive forms of retinal epitheliopathy that carry a poorer prognosis.
The results of this study demonstrate that structural alterations of the retinal pigment epithelium are the most common ocular findings in paediatric patients with current or past giardiasis. Both ophthalmologists and paediatricians should be aware of this link when interpreting retinal findings in children, especially those from areas in which the infection is endemic.