BACKGROUND/AIMS Posterior capsular opacification (PCO) is caused by proliferation and migration of lens epithelial cells (LECs) across the posterior capsule and is the commonest cause of reduced vision after cataract surgery. The influence of intraocular lens (IOL) material on the process of LEC migration was studied.
METHODS 90 eyes underwent standardised extracapsular surgery, with capsulorhexis and “in the bag” IOL placement. They were randomised to receive a three piece 6 mm lens of PMMA, silicone, or polyacrylic (AcrySof, Alcon, Fort Worth, TX, USA). On days 7, 30, 90, 180, and years 1 and 2 high resolution digitised retroillumination images were taken of the posterior capsule. The presence of LECs was determined at 90 days and 2 years, and their progression or regression was established by serial examination of images.
RESULTS LECs were seen in 93% of silicone and 97% of PMMA IOLs at 90 days, compared with 46% of polyacrylic (p<0.001). At year 2 LECs were present in all patients with silicone or PMMA lenses, whereas 62% of patients with polyacrylic IOLs had LECs (p<0.001). Of those patients with LECs at day 90 LEC regression occurred in 8% with silicone IOLs and 15% of PMMA cases, compared with 83% of patients with polyacrylic IOLs (p<0.0001).
CONCLUSION The presence of LECs on the posterior capsule was considerably lower with polyacrylic than PMMA or silicone IOLs and LEC regression occurred more frequently. The lower incidence of LECs and the higher rate of regression may explain why PCO formation appears to be reduced with polyacrylic lenses. This has important clinical implications for the prevention of PCO.
- posterior capsular opacification
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Posterior capsular opacification (PCO) is the commonest complication of cataract surgery with an incidence of between 10% and 50% by 2 years postoperatively.1 Residual lens epithelial cells (LECs), which remain in the capsular bag after cataract surgery, proliferate and transform. Opacification of the posterior capsule results from their migration and proliferation to produce Elschnig’s pearls or fibroblastic transformation causing capsular fibrosis.2-4 In the peripheral capsular bag these processes cause no symptoms, but when cells encroach onto the visual axis they cause light scatter and visual deterioration.
PCO has important medical, social, and economic adverse effects and consequently there is considerable interest in its prevention. Biconvex and plano convex polymethyl methacrylate (PMMA) intraocular lenses (IOLs),5-7 as well as silicone plate haptic IOLs,8 have been reported to have a beneficial effect on PCO. However, other modifications of IOL design or surgical technique have had little influence on PCO rates.9 Attention has therefore focused on pharmacological agents to reduce the number of residual LECs left at the end of a cataract operation,10 11 to inhibit the proliferation of LECs after surgery,12 13 or to alter their migration into the visual axis.14 Evidence of their efficacy comes largely from cell culture or animal studies, and their role in human cataract surgery remains unknown.
We have developed an imaging system that produces high resolution digitised retroillumination images of the posterior capsule15 and report for the first time that LEC behaviour is differentially influenced by the IOL material.
Patients were recruited in a continuous cohort following approval from the hospital ethics committee. All surgery was performed between September 1993 and July 1994 by a single surgeon. Tight inclusion criteria were used to define the presence of senile cataract in an otherwise normal eye in patients over 55 years of age. Exclusion criteria were a history of previous intraocular surgery or laser treatment, diabetes mellitus requiring medical control, glaucoma, previous uveitis, or any posterior segment pathology precluding a postoperative vision of 20/40 or better. Patients using topical medications (apart from lubricants) and any patients taking systemic steroids were excluded, in addition to those who had contralateral cataract surgery in the previous 4 months. All patients were assessed preoperatively by the same person.
Surgical technique and medication were standardised. Extracapsular cataract extraction with continuous curvilinear capsulorhexis was performed by a single surgeon using peribulbar anaesthesia.16 Preoperatively the pupil was dilated. A 10 mm superior corneal section was made and the anterior chamber was reformed with Healon (Pharmacia). The nucleus was hydroexpressed through a 5.5–6.5 mm capsulorhexis using balanced salt solution (BSS). Soft lens material was removed by manual irrigation aspiration with BSS; no attempt was made to reduce LECs by polishing the anterior capsule. The bag was reformed with Healon and the IOL inserted. Patients were randomised to receive one of three IOLs. These all had PMMA haptics with 6 mm optics of PMMA (Alcon MC60BM), silicone (Iolab L141U), or polyacrylic (AcrySof, Alcon MA60BM, Fort Worth, TX, USA). AcrySof is a proprietary copolymer of phenylethyl acrylate and phenylethyl methacrylate cross linked with 1.4 butanediol diacrylate. The angle of flexion of the haptics was 10 degrees with the PMMA and polyacrylic lenses and 5 degrees for silicone. The corneal wound was sutured with a continuous bootlace suture of 10/0 nylon and the Healon was thoroughly removed by irrigation with BSS. Subconjunctival cefuroxime 125 mg was given at the end of the operation. Any surgical complications such as capsulorhexis rim tear, zonular dehiscence, failure to place the IOL into the capsular bag, posterior capsular rupture, or vitreous loss led to patient exclusion. Postoperatively all patients used Maxitrol, drops (neomycin, polymyxin, and dexamethasone 0.1%) four times a day for 1 month. No non-steroidal anti-inflammatory preparation was used pre-, peri-, or postoperatively.
LENS EPITHELIAL CELL ASSESSMENT
Patients had standardised digital retroillumination imaging of the posterior capsule through dilated pupils at days 7, 30, 90, 180, and years 1 and 2 postoperatively, using a purpose built digitised retroillumination camera system. LECs can be easily visualised on the posterior capsule by 90 days. Their presence or absence on the posterior capsule was determined at day 90 and 2 years postoperatively for each IOL type (disregarding their extent). In those patients where they were present the changes in the migration and growth of these cells was determined by analysing consecutive images, comparing one image with the next, so that three observations made for each patient comparing changes between 90 and 180 days, 180 days and 1 year, and 1–2 years. LECs were determined to have progressed, be stable, or have regressed, between each image and the next in the chronological order. Any patient who missed the 90 day appointment or more than two follow up images was excluded.
In addition, the relation of the anterior capsulorhexis margin to the IOL optic at 90 days postoperatively was assessed and graded as either completely on the IOL optic for 360 degrees, partly on, or completely off the optic for 360 degrees. This was correlated with the presence of LECs on the posterior capsule at 90 days and, if LECs were present, we assessed whether the degree of capsulorhexis-optic contact had any influence on their progression, regression or stability.
The difference between the three lens groups was analysed using a χ2 test.
Ninety eyes of 81 patients were enrolled and allocated randomly by computer code to each lens group of 30. The average age was 73 years, with a range of 55–89 years. There was no difference in age and sex distribution between the three groups.
The number of patients with images available for analysis at day 90 was 28 in the PMMA group, 27 for silicone, and 26 for polyacrylic. At 2 years 25 patients were available in the PMMA group, 21 for silicone, and 16 for polyacrylic.
PRESENCE OF LENS EPITHELIAL CELLS
Table 1 shows that in the PMMA group 96% of patients had LECs present on the posterior capsule at 90 days, 93% with silicone, and 46% with polyacrylic. At 2 years all patients with PMMA and silicone IOLs had LECs on their posterior capsule, whereas 62% with polyacrylic had LECs on their capsules. Patients with polyacrylic lenses were significantly less likely to have LECs on their posterior capsules than those with PMMA or silicone at both day 90 (p<0.001) and 2 years (p<0.001).
FATE OF LENS EPITHELIAL CELLS
If LECs were present at day 90 their fate was assessed to determine whether they progressed, remained stable, or regressed (Table 2). In 81% of these patients with PMMA IOLs the LEC growth progressed between day 90 and 2 years (Figs 1A, B, C), in 4% LEC growth was stable, and in 15% there was minor regression on some areas of the capsule (Figs 2A, B, C). In patients with silicone IOLs and LECs at 90 days LEC progression was seen in 84% (Figs 3A, B, C), with 8% staying stable, and 8% showing evidence of regression (Figs4A, B, C). There was no statistically significant difference between the PMMA and silicone groups (p=0.33). Of the patients in the polyacrylic group with LECs at day 90 none showed LEC progression, 17% remained stable, and 83% demonstrated marked LEC regression (Figs 5A, B, C and 6A, B, C). Delayed LEC migration onto the posterior capsule was seen at 2 years in 16% patients with polyacrylic IOLs who had no LECs at 90 days. There is a statistically significant relation between lens type and whether the LECs in the posterior capsule regress, remain stable, or progress (p<0.0001), with more progression being seen with PMMA and silicone and regression with polyacrylic.
A higher number of patients in the polyacrylic group did not attend for follow up at 2 years in comparison with those in the PMMA and silicone groups; this may have been because the patients with polyacrylic IOLs had less PCO and better vision.
CAPSULORHEXIS MARGIN CONTACT
The correlation of capsulorhexis contact with the IOL optic for each lens type with the presence of LECs at day 90 is shown in Table 3. It can be seen for all lens materials that if the capsulorhexis edge is completely on the IOL optic the likelihood of LECs growing onto the posterior capsule at 90 days is less than if the capsulorhexis is partly or completely off the optic (p<0.0001). There was no statistically significant association between lens type and capsulorhexis position (p=2.3). Consequently the decreased LEC growth seen with polyacrylic lenses cannot be explained by a difference in capsulorhexis position.
This study shows that the material from which an IOL is made influences whether lens epithelial cells are present on the posterior capsule after cataract surgery and can affect the behaviour of these cells. The presence of LECs on the posterior capsule at 90 days and 2 years was considerably lower with polyacrylic lenses than PMMA or silicone (p<0.001). Polyacrylic IOLs have been reported to be associated with a low incidence of PCO17 18 and the observation that the cells causing PCO are significantly less likely to be present on the posterior capsule with this lens supports these studies.
We find that in all eyes, regardless of implant material, LEC migration onto the posterior capsule starts within days of surgery so that patterns of LECs are easily identifiable when present on the posterior capsule at 90 days postoperatively. In eyes with PMMA or silicone IOLs this process is usually progressive with only minor degrees of LEC regression being found many months later. In contrast, eyes with polyacrylic IOLs which had LECs at 90 days showed substantial LEC regression between 30 and 90 days postoperatively which then stabilises or continues to slowly regress further with time (Figs 5 and 6). If LECs were present at 90 days regression occurred significantly more frequently with polyacrylic lenses than PMMA or silicone (p<0.0001). Conversely, LECs are significantly more likely to progress with PMMA and silicone lenses than polyacrylic (p<0.0001).
The mechanism by which IOL material influences LEC behaviour is unknown but could be explained by either mechanical or material related effects. The higher refractive index of polyacrylic (1.55) compared with silicone (1.41–1.46) and PMMA (1.49) allows these IOLs to have much thinner optics, suggesting that physical bulk cannot be the explanation for the reduced LEC migration. Polyacrylic IOLs have a more defined and squarer optic edge than the other two implants and a recent study has shown a significant decrease in PCO with sharp optic edges.19 The authors propose that the sharp edge acts as a mechanical barrier to lens epithelial cell migration onto the posterior capsule. This could be of importance in decreasing the number of cells on the posterior capsules with polyacrylic IOLs but would not explain the phenomenon of LEC regression and the stability of the anterior capsule on the IOL.20
Preclinical studies on AcrySof showed no evidence that it was toxic to LECs.21 Macrophages can readily be seen on the anterior surface of some IOLs postoperatively, particularly in diabetic or uveitic patients, and are thought to be an indication of a foreign body reaction.22 In our study no macrophages were seen when LEC regression occurs, suggesting that regression was not a necrotic process.
IOLs made of this polyacrylic have a tacky surface. Indirect evidence for an adhesive relation between polyacrylic IOLs and the capsule has been provided by measuring anterior capsular movement on the lens optic. We have shown that the anterior capsule is much more stable on the anterior surface of a polyacrylic lens than PMMA or silicone and only minor capsule movement occurs with time, possibly as it is stuck to the anterior IOL surface.20 Furthermore there are a number of anecdotal accounts from surgeons which suggest that if polyacrylic IOLs have to be explanted for anisometropia they become adherent to the capsule soon after surgery and are relatively difficult to explant in comparison with PMMA or silicone lenses (T Neuhann, Foldable IOLs: different materials and different designs. Presentation at the XIVth Congress of the European Society of Cataract and Refractive Surgeons, Gothenburg, Sweden, 1996).
This postulated bioadhesion between the capsule and the IOL would mean that there is no space for the LECs to migrate in between the IOL and the posterior capsule. This is analogous to the “no space, no cells” theory which is supported by histological studies on other IOL types showing that cell migration behind the optic can be prevented by a posterior convex or biconvex optic if it is in contact with the adjacent posterior capsule.6 7 A tight adhesive relation between the polyacrylic IOL and the capsular bag could exert compression on the LECs that were present, causing them to regress and atrophy. Alternatively, this adhesion might restrict the access of nutrients and growth factors to the migrated LECs resulting in their regression. Our studies would suggest that the adhesion between a polyacrylic IOL and the capsule takes some weeks to establish during which time some LEC migration can occur, and that the explanation is likely to be due to a material rather than a mechanical effect of the lens implant.
The ideal diameter of the capsulorhexis has yet to be elucidated. Many surgeons believe that the LECs at the equator of the capsular bag are the most important in the pathogenesis of PCO and postulate that a capsulorhexis diameter larger than the IOL optic allows fusion of the anterior capsular flap to the posterior capsule setting up a mechanical barrier to LEC migration from the equator.23 24 An alternative view is that LECs originating from the anterior capsule are important in the production of PCO.2 A retrospective study on 107 patients who had undergone capsulorhexis and extracapsular cataract surgery with in the bag IOL implantation suggested that capsular opacification was less in the group where the anterior capsule was on the optic for 360 degrees.25 The large capsulorhexis in our study meant that nearly all were eccentricity placed, with the IOL optic edge exposed in some quadrants. Our results suggest that in all IOL types more LECs migrate behind the IOL optic if the capsulorhexis edge is partly or completely off the IOL optic, compared with when the capsulorhexis edge is on the optic for 360 degrees (p<0.0001).
The observation that LECs are found less frequently on the posterior capsule and are more likely to regress with polyacrylic lenses corroborates the clinical observation of less posterior capsular opacification in these patients17 18 and this has important clinical implications for implant surgery.
We thank K Tilling of the Department of Public Health, United and Dental Medical Schools, London, for statistical advice. This study was supported by the Iris Fund for the Prevention of Blindness and an unrestricted research grant from Alcon Laboratories.
The authors have no proprietary interest in any of the materials or equipment discussed in this study.
Presented at ASCRS Boston 1997. Awarded best paper of session.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.