Article Text

PDF

Role of impression cytology during hypovitaminosis A
  1. A Polizzia,
  2. M Schenonea,
  3. S C Saccàa,
  4. S Burlandoa,
  5. D Freedmanb,
  6. G Marinarib,
  7. S Cuneob,
  8. S Rovidac,
  9. F Formellid,
  10. G Camerinib
  1. aIstituto Di Clinica Oculistica dell’ Universita’ Di Genova, Italy, bClinica Chirurgica dell’ Universita’ di Genova, Italy, cIstituto Di Statistica Medica E Biometria, Italy, dIstituto Tumori Di Milano, Italy
  1. Dr A Polizzi, Clinica Oculistica Universita, Largo Rosanna Benzi, 10, 16132 Genova, Italy.

Abstract

AIMS Evaluation of the morphological damage to the ocular surface of patients operated for biliopancreatic diversion for pathological obesity and the correlation of impression cytology with vitamin A plasma levels, adaptometry, and other general variables.

METHODS 48 patients (15 males, 33 females, age range 21–73) and 34 normal subjects were examined with fluorescein and rose bengal, a plasma dose of vitamin A, and adaptometry. The results of the various tests were subdivided into three levels (0 = normal, 1 = moderately altered, 2 = seriously altered). The impression cytology and adaptometry results were correlated with vitamin A levels and other patient data (age, nutritional condition, time since operation, percentage weight loss). All the examinations were repeated after intramuscular therapy with vitamin A.

RESULTS Corneoconjunctival alterations visible with fluorescein and rose bengal staining were present in 67.7% of cases, impression cytology alterations in 93.7%, adaptometric alterations in 82.2%; vitamin A plasma levels were below normal in 95.8% of cases. After the therapy with vitamin A a significant reduction was found for every examination. The correlation between impression cytology and adaptometry and vitamin A plasma levels and between corneoconjunctival alterations and vitamin A plasma levels was significant. There was no significant correlation between impression cytology and nutritional condition, age time since operation, and percentage weight loss.

CONCLUSION These results show impression cytology is a specific indicator for hypovitaminosis A because it is not influenced by other factors related to the general condition of the patient. Many patients with hypovitaminosis A not demonstrating ocular symptoms of changes visible with fluorescein and rose bengal showed alterations with impression cytology.

  • hypovitaminosis A
  • vitamin A
  • impression cytology

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Biliopancreatic diversion (BPD) is performed in patients suffering from morbid obesity.1 This technique causes a delay of contact between biliopancreatic juices and fat starch which results in a reduction of absorption of high caloric food.1 2 One of the complications observed after BPD is a lack of the fat soluble vitamin A, accompanied by an alteration of the ocular surface associated with night blindness.3 In fact, it has been noted that vitamin A influences both the integrity of conjunctival cells and the ability to see in the dark.3 4In this study we evaluated quantitatively the morphological damage affecting the ocular surface, correlating the data with plasma vitamin A levels, adaptometry, and patient data.

Materials and methods

Table 1 gives patient characteristics for subjects who underwent BPD (operated patients) and for those who did not receive (control group) any treatment. Forty eight patients undergoing BPD were referred to us because of ocular symptoms specific for hypovitaminosis A.

Table 1

Patient characteristics

All patients received a visual examination which included refractive assessment, fundus examination, tonometric reading, examination of the ocular surface using fluorescein and rose bengal, and impression cytology.

Blood samples were collected from each patient and the level of plasma vitamin A assessed by using HPLC (high pressure liquid chromatography).5 Goldmann–Weeker adaptometry was performed on all patients. A control group of 34 subjects, comparable in age with those undergoing BPD, was subjected to the examinations as described above. All operated patients were re-examined 60 days after a therapy which consisted of one phial of Arovit IM (300 000 IU) per day.

The alterations that were revealed by impression cytology, biomicroscopic examination of the ocular surface, plasma vitamin A levels, and adaptometry were subdivided into three grades of severity: 0=no alteration/normal, 1=minor alterations, 2=major alterations.

Corneoconjunctival alterations, as revealed by biomicroscopic examination using fluorescein and rose bengal, were subdivided into the following grades: grade 0=absence of significant alterations; grade 1=translucent appearance of the conjunctiva (pre-Bitot spots) with or without slight keratoconjunctivitis punctata which was more evident in the inferior portion of the cornea, fluorescein, and rose bengal coloured zones; grade 2=foamy formations in the conjunctiva (Bitot spots) and keratoconjunctivitis punctata with large coloured areas.

The results of impression cytology were subdivided into the following grades: grade 0=numerous mucous cells (200 per field/mm2), epithelial cells with regular borders (Fig 1) (nucleus/cytoplasm (N/C) ratio 1:1, 1:2); grade 1: few goblet cells (50–200 per field), drops of mucus, epithelial cells some undergoing desquamation (Fig 2); grade 2: goblet cells less than 50 per field/mm2; epithelial cells with irregular borders undergoing desquamation (N/C ratio 1:4, 1:5 (squamous metaplasia) (Fig 3).6

Figure 1

Impression cytology (grade 0) performed in the upper temporal bulbar conjunctiva, of a 44 year old man, 6 months after BPD surgery: numerous epithelial normal cells and mucous cells positive for periodic acid Schiff, Papanicolaou staining (goblet cells) (original magnification ×25).

Figure 2

Impression cytology (grade 1) performed in the upper temporal bulbar conjunctiva, of a 40 year old woman, 36 months after BPD surgery. A single layer of polygonal epithelial cells with cytoplasmic edges well defined. Rare goblet cells (compared with grade 0), marked reduction of “goblet cells” (original magnification ×25).

Figure 3

Impression cytology (grade 2) performed in the lower temporal bulbar conjunctiva, of a 48 year old woman, 58 months after BPD surgery. Epithelial cells with evident squamous features, less cohesivity, folded cytoplasmic edges (squamous metaplasia), absence of “goblet cells” (original magnification ×40).

Adaptometric alterations were also subdivided into three grades: grade 0=absolute threshold 3.5 LU picostilb, grade 1=absolute threshold 3.5–5.5 LU picostilb; grade 2=absolute threshold 5.5 LU picostilb.

Finally, plasma vitamin A levels were divided into three grades: grade 0, ⩾500 ng/ml; grade 1, 150–500 ng/ml; grade 2, ⩽ 150 ng/ml.

We subsequently correlated statistically the results of impression cytology with those of adaptometry, vitamin A plasma levels, and other patient data such as protein nutrition status (serum total protein, albumin, transferrin) number of days since operation, weight loss, and ocular symptoms. The independent ANOVA data test was used for statistical analysis.

Results

Patients who underwent BPD had ocular surface alterations as evidenced by biomicroscope observation (Table 2), abnormal impression cytology (Table 3), pathological adaptometric curves (Table 4), and low levels of plasma vitamin A (Table 5). These alterations were more evident before Arovit therapy, although they persisted to a certain degree even after therapy.

Table 2

Corneal conjunctival alterations (biomicroscopic observations by staining with fluorescein and bengal rose)

Table 3

Impression cytology

Table 4

Adaptometry

Table 5

Plasma vitamin A levels (ng/ml)

The plasma vitamin A level of BPD patients were correlated in statistically significant way with the results of impression cytology, staining of the corneoconjunctival surface, and adaptometry results (Table 6). The percentage weight loss, nutritional protein status, number of days since operation, and patient age did not appear to be statistically correlated with the results of impression cytology (Table7).

Table 6

Comparison of results before and after therapy with vitamin A (Wilcoxon test)

Table 7

Statistical correlation

Discussion

The alterations of the ocular surface observed in our study are similar to those described as symptoms of nutritional polydeficiency syndromes. Such symptoms during malnutrition are today only found in Third World countries.7-9 Since 1925,10vitamin A has been considered essential for cellular differentiation and for the maintenance of the epithelial cells of mucous membranes. Vitamin A deficiency and, therefore, the consequences of squamous metaplasia have been ascribed as the cause of the majority of lesions observed on the ocular surface. The sample population examined in our study revealed a deficiency syndrome which was clearly due to the lack of vitamin A, as demonstrated according to observation at various times.10 11 Furthermore, it was noted that the level of deficiencies was not related to patient age.12 The findings of this study which concerns adult patients, were found to be similar to those reported in children of the Third World. Moreover, the relation between aging and impression cytology does not allow the prediction of keratinisation or the absence of mucous cells. On the other hand, plasma vitamin A levels and adaptometric results are strictly correlated. Such a correlation does not exist between the results of impression cytology, nutritional protein status, and the amount of time elapsed since the operation. This may indicate the presence of an individual compensatory mechanism during cellular membrane vitamin A deficiency (individual capacity to draw upon vitamin A deposits, most of which are available as retinol binding protein) or may suggest that other fat soluble vitamins are drawn upon as a response to vitamin A deficiency. Vitamin E, for example, acts as an antioxidant and is very important in the prevention of epithelial damage by free radicals. This study did not take into consideration the role of vitamin E. In every case, plasma vitamin A levels were more strictly correlated with impression cytology than they were with the appearance of the corneoconjunctival surface biomicroscopic observations. On the other hand, it has been noted that the corneal epithelium undergoes modifications which precede the development of keratoconjunctivitis punctata. This observation explains why the results of impression cytology in many of our patients revealed severe alterations, even though the patients did not complain of any symptoms. Our study confirms the role of impression cytology during follow up examinations in patients affected with vitamin A deficiency as a valuable means of providing a more sensitive index in comparison with biomicroscopic examination using fluorescein or rose bengal. Impression cytology is easy and cheap. Furthermore, impression cytology is not influenced by factors related to general patient health, and provides an effective mean of demonstrating alterations which precede the symptoms of corneoconjunctivitis.

References

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.