BACKGROUND The influence of diabetes mellitus on ocular pulse amplitude (OPA), an indirect measure of choroidal perfusion, is unclear.
METHODS OPA, using the Langham ocular blood flow (OBF) system, applanation intraocular pressure (IOP), systemic blood pressure (BP), heart rate, and haemoglobin (Hb) A1c were measured in patients with insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) with no (DR-0, n = 22) non-proliferative (DR-1, n = 24), and proliferative (DR-2, n = 18) diabetic retinopathy.
RESULTS Neither local (OPA, IOP) nor systemic perfusion parameters (BPs, HR) nor HbA1c were significantly altered in DR-0, DR-1, or DR-2 IDDM patients.
CONCLUSION Choroidal circulation remains unaffected as diabetic retinopathy advances.
- ocular pulse amplitude
- diabetes mellitus
- diabetic retinopathy
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Diabetic retinopathy (DR) is the major cause of blindness in adults aged 25–74 years.1 With increasing duration of this disease, the inner retina is progressively affected by microvascular occlusions leading to reduced oxygen supply and eventually retinal neo- vascularisation.2
Although the underlying cause of DR is related to chronic hyperglycaemia, the exact sequence of events and the relative contributions of abnormalities within the vessel3-5 and the vessel wall are undetermined.6 7
Changes in retinal perfusion, its regulation, and the factors that mediate them have been studied in diabetes mellitus (DM) by many investigators.8-12
A review of the literature also suggests a pathogenetic role for the choroid in the initiation and propagation of DR. Using scanning electron microscopy in necropsy eyes from patients with long standing insulin dependent DM (IDDM), Fryczkowsky et al 13 noted increased tortuosity, focal vascular dilatations and narrowings, vascular loops and microaneurysm formation, dropout of choriocapillaries, and sinus-like structure formation between choroidal lobules in the equatorial area. They concluded that changes in the choroid, especially in the choriocapillaris, may be a contributing factor in DR, resulting in decreased oxygenation of the outer layers of the retina.
High resolution histological analysis of the human choroidal vasculature revealed capillary dropout, beaded capillaries, and neo- vascularisation,14 fluorescein angiography showed delayed choroidal perfusion, and electroretinograms with abnormal oscillatory potentials in the same DM patients.15
Reduced blood flow can result in tissue hypoxia, leading in extreme situations to cell/tissue death—for example, in myocardial or cerebral tissue infarctions. Results from clinical studies showed reduced choroidal perfusion in DR,19 retinitis pigmentosa,20 and normal tension glaucoma.21-23 associated with functional (visual field defects) and morphological (nerve fibre layer loss) damage.22 23
This study was designed to evaluate ocular pulse amplitude (OPA), in IDDM patients with different stages of DR.
OPA is an indirect measure of choroidal perfusion. A bolus of blood entering the eye corresponding to the cardiac pulse represents a change of intraocular pressure (IOP) as a function of time reflecting the pulsatile component (approximately 70%)29 of intraocular blood flow,30 31 85% of which is choroidal.32
Materials and methods
Sixty four patients with type 1 insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM) taking intensified insulin therapy were investigated. Patients with systemic hypertension, hypercholesterolaemia, neurological deficits, typical migraine headache, and ocular or systemic disease, other than the category selected for, were excluded from the study. The IDDM patients selected had a history of IOP < 21 mm Hg, typical fundus appearance (DR-0: normal fundus, DR-1: background diabetic retinopathy characterised by microaneurysms, haemorrhages, exudates, oedema, nerve fibre layer infarcts, venous beading, and/or intraretinal microvascular abnormalities; DR-2: proliferative diabetic retinopathy characterised by an area of epipapillary neovascularisation larger than a quarter of disc diameter and/or areas of epiretinal neovascularisation larger than a diameter of half a disc). None of the patients or controls had received ocular surgery or laser treatment of any kind and were taking no ocular therapy.
Patients with DR-0 (n = 22, male: 12, age: 23.3 (SD 2.2) years, duration of diabetes: 5.5 (1.8) years, HBA1c: 6.1 (0.5)); DR-1 (n = 24, male: 11, age: 28.4 (2.6) years, duration of diabetes: 11.3 (2.6) years, HBA1c: 5.8 (0.4)); and DR-2 (n = 18, male: 9, age: 33.1 (2.5) years, duration of diabetes: 16.1 (3.2) years, HBA1c: 6.3 (0.7)) were compared with respective matched control subgroups (MCTL) selected from a pool of 72 healthy volunteers with no known ocular or systemic disease, who showed no visual field defects and/or disc alterations and had IOPs < 21 mm Hg matched for age (SD 3 years), sex, IOP (2) mm Hg), and refraction (1.5 dioptres spherical equivalent).
The study has been approved by the institutional review board and informed consent was obtained from each patient/volunteer following complete explanation of the procedure.
The ocular blood flow (OBF) system (OBF Labs Ltd, Wiltshire) has been described in detail elsewhere.31
In addition to pneumotonometric values, IOP was measured by Goldmann applanation tonometry. Brachial artery pressures were measured non-invasively (Riva-Rocci) using a blood pressure cuff and a stethoscope after 5 minutes resting. Heart rate (HR) was measured manually using a stopwatch. Applanation IOP, blood pressure (BP), and HR were taken before OPA measurements. All measurements were performed in a seated position, respective measurements were taken by the same examiner.
All data represent arithmetic mean (SD); Student's unpaired two tailed t test was used for statistical analysis. Measurements were performed on both eyes of each subject. The level of significance was 5%. IDDM patient groups (DR-0, DR-1, DR-2) were compared with matched subgroups (MCTL) of healthy volunteers (CTL), and with each other.
When compared with respective subgroups from a pool of healthy controls (n = 72), IOP, OPA (Fig 1), systolic and diastolic blood pressures, and heart rate (Table 1) were not significantly (p>0.1) altered in any of the three IDDM groups investigated.
Also, when IDDM patient groups were compared with each other IOP, OPA (Fig 1), systolic and diastolic blood pressures, heart rate, and HBA1c were not significantly (p>0.1) altered in any of the three IDDM groups (Table 1).
OPA, a haemodynamic parameter reflecting overall choroidal perfusion is unchanged in IDDM patients independent of the degree of retinopathy which is in contrast with another study reporting a reduction of OPA with the severity of the retinopathy.19
The functional integrity of the choroid in DR even in advanced stages, as demonstrated by our data, is confirmed by clinical evidence that the function of the photoreceptors as measured by visual field examination is unaltered in DR.32
In parallel with the anatomy and the physiological function of both vascular systems, DR is confined to the inner parts of the retina,33 the outer plexiform layer, the watershed zone between retinal and choroidal vascular system, being the most outer zone affected,33 whereas the outer retina beginning at the outer plexiform layer, supplied by the choroid,18 remains mostly unaltered.33
Despite similar metabolic changes affecting both retinal and choroidal vascular beds,34 one interesting finding is that pericyte dropout, a hallmark of early diabetic retinopathy does not occur in choroidal capillaries.35 The primary surplus of choroidal vessels and blood flow, responsible for the nutrition and waste removal of the crucial outer retinal parts, may in part explain the relative resistance to degenerative influences from disease such as diabetic retinopathy.
Proprietary interest: none.