Article Text


Ultrastructural morphology and expression of proteoglycans, βig-h3, tenascin-C, fibrillin-1, and fibronectin in bullous keratopathy
  1. Saeed Akhtara,
  2. Anthony J Bronb,
  3. Nicholas R Hawksworthc,
  4. Richard E Bonshekd,
  5. Keith M Meeka
  1. aDepartment of Optometry and Vision Sciences, Cardiff University, Cardiff, UK, bNuffield Department of Ophthalmology, University of Oxford, Oxford, UK, cRoyal Glamorgan Hospital, Llantrisant, UK, dAcademic Department of Ophthalmology, Manchester Royal Eye Hospital and University of Manchester, Manchester, UK
  1. Dr Saeed Akhtar, Department Optometry and Vision Sciences, Cardiff University, Redwood Building, Kings Edward VII Avenue, PO Box 905, Cardiff CF10 3NB, UKAkhtarS{at}


AIMS To investigate the ultrastructural localisation of proteoglycans (PG), βig-h3 (keratoepithelin), tenascin-C (TN-C)), fibrillin, and fibronectin in bullous keratopathy (BK) corneas.

METHODS Five corneas from cases of pseudophakic bullous keratopathy (BK) were examined by electron microscopy. PG were demonstrated using cuprolinic blue, and the proteins βig-h3, TN-C, fibrillin, and fibronectin were immunolocalised with rabbit anti-βig-h3, mouse anti–TN-C (BC10 and TN2), mouse anti-fibrillin-1 (MAB2502), mouse anti-fibrillin (MAB1919), and rabbit anti-fibronectin by using a standard immunogold technique.

RESULTS Epithelial cells contained numerous vacuoles. Epithelial folds and large, electron lucent subepithelial bullae were present. Basal lamina was thickened and traversed by disrupted anchoring filaments. In the stroma, interfibrillar collagen spacing was increased and abnormally large PG were present. Descemet's membrane (DM) contained lucent spaces in which there were small filaments. Keratocyte and endothelial cells contained melanin granules. A posterior collagenous layer (PCL) contained numerous microfilaments and wide spacing collagen fibres with a periodicity of 100 nm. Large quantities of abnormal PG were observed at the endothelial face of the PCL. Very strong labelling with βig-h3 antibody was observed in the basement membrane, Bowman's layer, stroma, DM, and PCL, but not in keratocytes and endothelial cells. Strong labelling with BC10 and TN2 was seen below the epithelium, in electron lucent spaces where the hemidesmosomes were absent, in the fibrotic pannus, in parts of Bowman's layer, the stroma, and Descemet's membrane. Labelling with BC10 was stronger and more evenly distributed than with TN2. Fibrillin-1 (MAB2502) and fibrillin (MAB1919) labelling was similar to TN-C labelling. Fibrillin (MAB1919) labelling was stronger than fibrillin-1 (MAB2502) labelling.

CONCLUSIONS Immunoelectron microscopy showed precise labelling of proteins at both the cellular and the subcellular level. Expression of proteins βig-h3, TN-C, fibrillin, and fibronectin was highly increased compared with normal cornea. In the oedematous stroma, increased collagen fibril separation may facilitate a wider distribution of some soluble proteins, such as βig-h3, throughout stroma. The modified expression of the proteins studied in these cases of BK may be regarded as part of an injury response.

  • proteoglycans
  • βig-h3
  • tenascin-C
  • fibrillin-1
  • fibronectin
  • bullous keratopathy

Statistics from

Post-surgical bullous keratopathy is a leading indication for keratoplasty. Both aphakic and phakic BK are due to endothelial dysfunction, giving rise to epithelial bullae and stromal oedema resulting in loss of transparency. Ultrastructural changes in BK have been reported by various authors.1-3Immunohistochemically, it has been shown that BK is associated with the expression of TN-C,4 ,5 fibronectin, fibrillin,4 ,6 and βig-h3.7

βig-h3 is an extracellular matrix protein that was first detected in a human lung adenocarcinoma cell line after stimulation by TGF-β.8 Recently, specific missense mutations have been reported in the βig-h3 gene (transforming growth factor β induced gene) in four autosomal dominant corneal dystrophies—that is, lattice type I, granular, Avellino, and Reis-Bückler's corneal stromal dystrophies.9 βig-h3 has been immunohistochemically localised to numerous body tissues, particularly within the basement membrane of skin and interstitial tissue.10 ,11

TN-C is a large hexameric glycoprotein composed of multiple domains.12-14 It is one of a family of four proteins, tenascin-cytotactin (TN-C), tenascin-restrictin (TN-R), tenascin-X (TN-X), and tenascin-Y (TN-Y) derived from different gene products.14-17 They play an important part in many dynamic cellular activities. In humans, TN-R is restricted to the central nervous system and TN-Y has been described only in the chicken.12 ,14 ,18 TN-C is the product of a single gene localised within region q32-q34 of chromosome 9.19 ,20However, alternative mRNA splicing gives rise to a number of variants which are associated with the mediation of a wide range of cellular properties, such as adhesion, anti-adhesion, migration, proliferation, and differentiation.21-23 TN-C is expressed in the human cornea in development, healing and repair, and inflammation and scarring.24-27 In addition, a number of studies have documented expression of TN-C and its variants in bullous keratopathy.4 ,5

Fibrillin-1 (FBN1) is a high molecular weight glycoprotein found in virtually all extracellular matrices.28-30 Mutation in the FBN1 gene that encodes fibrillin is responsible for Marfan syndrome, an autosomal dominant, connective tissue disorder, that affects the cardiovascular and musculoskeletal system, as well as the eye.

In the present paper, we report for the first time the immunoelectron localisation of the proteins βig-h3, tenascin-C (clone TN-2 and BC10), fibrillin-1, and fibronectin with reference to the detailed ultrastructural morphology of bullous keratopathy corneas.


A normal corneal button was obtained 24 hours post mortem and three BK corneal buttons were obtained within 30 minutes of penetrating keratoplasty and were fixed immediately. Two more buttons were obtained from archived material (2 years old) by processing wax blocks through xylene and a graded series of ethanol (see Table 1).

Table 1

Clinical data of pseudophakic/aphakic bullous keratopathy (PBK/ABK) patients

All the corneas were divided into three parts. The first part was immersed in 3% glutaraldehyde in 0.1M phosphate buffer for 2 hours and post-fixed in 1% osmium tetroxide in 0.1M phosphate buffer for a further hour. The second part was fixed in 3% glutaraldehyde containing 0.05% cuprolinic blue (BDH Ltd, Dorset) using a critical electrolyte concentration mode. The tissue was then dehydrated through a graded ethanol series and embedded in Spurr resin. Semithin (1 μm) sections were stained with toluidine blue for light microscopy. Ultrathin sections were stained with uranyl acetate and lead citrate, and observed by transmission electron microscopy (Jeol 1010; Jeol Ltd, Akishima, Japan).

The third part (less than 1 mm3) was fixed in freshly prepared 4% paraformaldehyde (PFA) in 0.1M phosphate for 2 hours at 4°C. Tissue was washed three times (15 minutes) in 0.1M PBS, and dehydrated in 30%, 50% (4°C), and in 70%–100% ethanol (−20°C) (1 hour in each). Tissues were infiltrated at −20°C in two 1 hour changes of a mixture of 100% ethanol and LR white (−20°C) and three 8 hour changes of LR white (−20°C). They were finally polymerised in LR white at −20°C for 48 hours under ultraviolet light. Ultrathin sections were cut from the blocks and collected on 200 mesh formvar-carbon nickel grids.


Polyclonal, rabbit, anti-human βig-h3 antibody was a gift from Dr K Bennett, Bristol Myers Squibb, USA. The monoclonal antibodies: mouse anti-human tenascin, BC10, (MAB 1918), mouse anti-human fibrillin-1 (MAB 2502), and mouse anti-human-fibrillin (MAB 1919), were obtained from Chemicon, International, UK. Monoclonal mouse anti-human tenascin, TN2, (MO636) and polyclonal rabbit anti-human fibronectin were obtained from Dako Ltd, UK. The specificity of the antibody to human antigens was tested and confirmed by the supplier with immunological assays. Antibodies were visualised with 10 nm goat anti-mouse and goat anti-rabbit immunogold conjugate. The immunogold conjugates, goat serum, bovine serum, and Tween-20 were supplied by Biocell, Cardiff, UK.

Sections were treated at room temperature by floating on a 50 μl drop of phosphate buffered saline (PBS) containing 0.1% bovine serum albumin (PBS-BSA) for 15 minutes, followed by PBS-BSA containing 5% normal goat serum for 30 minutes. They were incubated overnight in primary antibody, rabbit anti-human βig-h3 (1:50 to 1:500), mouse anti-human tenascin, BC10, (MAB 1918) (1:50 to 1:500), mouse anti-human tenascin, TN2, (MO636) (1:25), mouse anti-human fibrillin-1 (MAB 2502), anti-human fibrillin MAB 1919 (1:50 to 1:500), and rabbit anti-human fibronectin (1:50). To remove unbound antibody, sections were washed with 0.05 M TRIS buffered saline (TBS) pH 7.4 (three washes, 5 minutes each), TBS pH 7.4 containing 0.2% BSA (three washes, 5 minutes each) and TBS pH 8.4 containing 1% BSA for 3 × 5 minutes. Sections were then incubated in secondary antibody-10 nm immunogold conjugate diluted 1:25 in TBS pH 8.4 containing 1% BSA for 50 minutes. The unbound secondary antibody was removed by washing in TBS-BSA (three washes, 5 minutes each), PBS, and distilled water (three washes, 5 minutes each). In all experiments, immunochemical controls were performed by substituting normal goat serum for the primary antibody. The immunoreaction was repeated three times with three replicates for each antibody used. Normal tissue was processed in parallel as a control. Sections were stained with 2% aqueous uranyl acetate and lead citrate and examined in a Jeol 1010 transmission electron microscope.


Ultrastructural findings and immunolocalisation of proteins in all BK corneas were similar.


Epithelial cells were degenerate and had numerous large vacuoles, especially around the nucleus (Fig 1A). There were large lucent spaces inside most basal epithelial cells, above Bowman's layer (Fig 1B), many of which coalesced to form extensive subepithelial bullae. Hemidesmosomes were often absent or degenerate. The subepithelial basal lamina (1.5–2 μm thick) was thickened, showing a grid-shaped structure with disrupted anchoring filaments (40–120 nm long) ((Figs1C, D). In some places, the subepithelial region was infiltrated by thick fibrotic tissue (1 μm thick) containing microfilaments, basement membrane material, and remnants of keratocytes (Fig 1E), below which was either a normal looking Bowman's layer (7 μm) or a degenerate Bowman's layer containing rounded electron dense material.

Figure 1

Electron micrographs showing ultrastructural alteration in a bullous keratopathy cornea. (A) Electron lucent vacuole (V) in a degenerate basal epithelial cell (E) and vacuoles in the subepithelial region. (B) Subepithelial vacuole (V) between an epithelial cell (E) and Bowman's layer (B). (C) Thick basement membrane (BM) between epithelial cells (E) and Bowman's layer (B). (D) Basement membrane (BM) containing anchoring filaments (AC) above Bowman's layer (B). (E) Subepithelial pannus (P) containing microfilaments (MF) and rounded keratocytes (KR).

Small folds of epithelium were present, which contained basal laminar material with numerous disrupted anchoring filaments (Fig 2A–C). Occasionally, below an electron dense basal lamina, degenerate keratocytes lined up in a single layer within fibrotic tissue (Fig 2A). The degenerate keratocytes appeared to be migrating into the base of each fold (Fig 2B).

Figure 2

Light and electron micrograph of bullous keratopathy cornea. (A) Epithelial fold containing basement membrane material (BM). Keratocytes (KR) are arranged in a line above Bowman's layer (B) and the anterior stroma. (B) High magnification of the epithelial fold shown in (A). Keratocytes (KR) are present in the epithelial fold which contains basement membrane material (BM). (C) Part of an epithelial fold showing disrupted anchoring filaments (AC) in basement membrane material (BM). (D) Electron lucent lake (L) between the stroma (S) and Descemet's membrane (DM).


In some regions of the stroma, the separation of collagen fibrils was greater than normal and the interfibrillar space contained a network of very fine filaments. There were electron lucent lakes throughout the stroma. Wavy collagen lamellae were prominent in the pre-Descemet's stroma and around the pre-Descemet's spaces (Fig 2D). Wavy lamellae were also seen in other parts of stroma. Wide spacing collagen fibrils were observed just below the epithelium in a degenerate fibrotic pannus and in the posterior stroma. Groups of microfilaments were seen in some parts of the stroma, especially adjacent to Descemet's membrane (DM) (Fig 3C).

Figure 3

Electron micrographs of the posterior part of bullous keratopathy corneas. (A) Part of Descemet's membrane (DM) with a break (BR). (B) Collagen fibres (CF) and electron dense material in a break (BR) present in Descemet's membrane (DM). (C) Posterior collagenous layer (PCL) containing wide spacing collagen (LC) and microfilaments (MF). (D) Below the PCL, an endothelial cell (EN) containing melanin granules (ML). (E) A degenerate keratocyte (KR) containing melanin granules (ML). (F) Part of anterior stroma containing abnormal proteoglycans (PG).


Descemet's membrane (DM) was 8–10 μm thick and was differentiated into banded and non-banded zones. The non-banded zone had numerous lucent spaces which contained small filaments. A prominent banding pattern similar to banded DM, was occasionally seen in the middle of the homogeneous DM. In the DM of all corneas, there were electron lucent cracks or breaks, scrolls of Descemet's material, and nodule formation with the appearance of Hassal-Henle warts. These contained degenerate collagen fibrils (Fig 3A, B). The posterior collagenous layer (PCL) contained numerous groups of microfilaments and very prominent wide spacing fibres with a periodicity of 100 nm (Fig3C) embedded in basement membrane-like material. The bands of wide spacing fibrils were connected by very thin microfibrils. Collagen fibrils were degenerate and sparse, and were distributed between large, lucent spaces. Some endothelial cells were present on the posterior surface of the posterior collagenous layer, but in most regions, no cells were present. Where endothelial cells were observed, the cytoplasm was dense, with prominent rough endoplasmic reticulum and melanin granules (Fig 3D). Other cell organelles were not well differentiated.


Degenerate keratocytes were observed in the fibrotic pannus and in the PCL, and they were also scattered throughout the stroma. Some of the keratocytes in the fibrotic pannus were rounded in shape (Fig 1F). In degenerate keratocytes, the cytoplasm was either disintegrated or had become a homogeneous mass, containing large vacuoles and melanin granules (Fig 3E). Nuclei were often apoptotic.


Proteoglycans (PG) in the basement membranes and anterior stroma were abnormally large (200–300 nm) (Fig 3F). Some aggregates of these large PG filaments were observed just below the basal epithelial cells where hemidesmosomes were absent. In some regions of the posterior stroma, PG were also very large (180 nm). Large PG filaments were also present around electron lucent lacunae throughout the stroma. In the middle and, posterior stroma and the PCL, PG filaments were found in large quantities, but their size was smaller (100 nm). A large quantity of abnormal PG was observed at the endothelial face of the PCL.


In normal corneal samples, moderate labelling was observed in the subepithelial basement membrane, Bowman's layer, and stroma. Labelling was strong in patches of fibrillar material near keratocytes but scanty around the keratocytes themselves. Dense labelling was seen in Descemet's membrane, but not in or close to the endothelium. Labelling was absent from the epithelial cells and keratocytes.

In the BK specimens, a small amount of labelling for βIG-H3 was observed in the epithelial cells (Fig 4B), in the degenerate Bowman's layer, and in the normal looking Bowman's layer (Fig 4C). In some parts of Bowman's layer, labelling was dense. Labelling was strong in the thick basement membrane, especially around the disrupted anchoring filaments (Fig 4D) and also within epithelial folds. Below the basement membrane, fibrotic pannus tissue was heavily labelled, while keratocytes were not (Fig 4E, F) Labelling was moderate in the anterior, middle, and posterior stroma but there were also some more strongly labelled patches. The electron dense material around degenerate collagen fibrils (Fig 5A) and the fibrillar material distributed throughout the stroma was very strongly labelled with the antibody (Fig 5B). Fibroblasts, keratocytes, and lucent areas around keratocytes were not labelled, but the fibrillar (or fibrous) material (described earlier) adjacent to the keratocytes was very strongly labelled with the antibody (Fig 5C). Banded DM was heavily labelled whereas homogeneous, non-banded DM was only moderately labelled (Fig5D). In the PCL, microfilaments, and basement membrane material were heavily labelled (Fig 5E, F). Wide spacing collagen and lucent spaces in the PCL were not labelled. Endothelial cells, when present, were not labelled, but the endothelial face of the PCL had moderate labelling.

Figure 4

Electron micrograph showing labelling of βig-h3 in BK corneas. (A) Control for immunoreaction. (B) Clumped labelling in epithelial cell (E). (C) Moderate clumped labelling in normal looking Bowman's layer (B). (D) Heavy labelling in basement membrane (BM) and around disrupted anchoring filaments. (E) Diffuse labelling on fibrotic pannus tissue (P) but not in the keratocyte (KR). (F) No labelling in the keratocyte but heavy labelling close to the keratocyte (KR) in the anterior stroma (S).

Figure 5

Electron micrograph showing labelling of βig-h3 in BK corneas. (A) Labelling on electron dense material present among collagen fibrils in the anterior stroma (S). (B) Labelling on fibrous (or fibrillar) material (FB) in the posterior stroma (S). (C) Labelling on fine fibrous (or fibrillar) material (FB) close to degenerate keratocyte (KR) but not in the keratocyte in the middle stroma (S). (D) Heavy labelling on banded Descemet's membrane (BDM). (E) Labelling on microfilaments (MF) in the PCL. (F) Labelling on electron dense material but not wide spacing collagen in the PCL.


Labelling of BC10 was seen in the squamous (Fig 6A), wing, and basal epithelial cells. Strong labelling was seen in electron lucent spaces where the hemidesmosomes were absent and in the fibrotic pannus tissue, especially in the region where degenerate anchoring filaments were seen (Fig 6B). Diffuse labelling was observed in Bowman's layer (Fig 6C) and throughout the stroma (Fig 6D). Labelling was very strong in the pre-Descemet's stroma and in the banded DM, especially close to the slit-like lucent spaces (Fig 6E). The labelling was also seen in the PCL (Fig 6F) and on the endothelial face of the PCL.

Figure 6

Electron micrographs of BK corneas showing labelling of BC10, in (A) epithelium (E), (B) Basement membrane (BM) and around anchoring filaments (AC), (C) Bowman's layer (B), (D) stroma (S), (E) banded Descemet's membrane (BDM), (F) posterior collagenous layer (PCL).

A small amount of labelling TN2 of tenascin was observed on the surface of the epithelium and in epithelial cells. Some staining was seen around degenerate keratocytes in the anterior stroma. Clumped labelling was seen in the fibrotic pannus tissue below the epithelium, in the anterior stroma beneath Bowman's layer, and in the posterior stroma close to Descemet's membrane. No staining was seen in the middle stroma or in the banded Descemet's membrane. Labelling was particularly high in the homogeneous middle and lower parts of the non-banded DM and in the PCL.


The labelling with fibrillin-1 clone MAB 2502 was observed on the very fine electron dense fibrillar material both on the surface and within the epithelial cells (Fig 7A). The labelling was prominent in the pannus on fine microfilaments close to degenerate keratocytes (Fig7B) and in the anterior stroma (Fig 7C). Labelling was also seen in DM and the PCL on very fine microfibrils close to the endothelium. Labelling with fibrillin clone MAB 1919 was similar to that with fibrillin-1 clone MAB 2502, but was more intense, especially in DM (Fig7D). It was also observed in the middle and posterior stroma.

Figure 7

Electron micrograph of BK corneas showing labelling of fibrillin-1-MAB2502, fibrillin-MAB1919, and fibronectin. (A) Fibrillin-1-MAB2502 labelling in epithelial cell (E), (B) diffuse labelling of fibrillin-1-MAB2502 on microfibrils (F) near a degenerate keratocyte (KR) in the pannus (P). (C) fibrillin-MAB1919 labelling on collagen fibrils in stroma (S), (D) Fibrillin-MAB1919 labelling on banded Descemet's membrane (BDM). (E) Labelling of fibronectin on the surface of the epithelium (E), and (F) in the stroma (S).


Labelling for fibronectin was observed on the surface of epithelial cells (Fig 7E) and within the epithelial cells, close to the lucent spaces. The labelling was also observed in the nucleus and close to the nucleus and on the nuclear membrane of the epithelial cells. The part of the basement membrane that was attached to the epithelial face was labelled with antibody, and there was also some labelling in Bowman's layer. In the anterior, middle, and posterior stroma, large portions of the longitudinally running collagen fibrils were labelled with the antibody (Fig 7F). The cytoplasm and nucleus of the keratocytes in the stroma had prominent labelling. The middle and endothelial faces of DM and the fibrocellular layer also had electron dense patches labelled with the antibody.


In post-surgical bullous keratopathy,injury causes a focal or diffuse disturbance of the endothelium. Cell loss, where it occurs, is followed by spreading of cells from the adjacent areas of the endothelium. Where endothelial loss is extreme, or where further losses occur with the passage of time, the resulting endothelial sheet may no longer be able to perform its normal function of deturgescing the cornea, and corneal oedema results, with or without the formation of epithelial bullae. Where the rate of endothelial cell loss is so high that the remaining endothelial cells are unable to cover the whole area of the posterior cornea, the remaining endothelial cells lose their normal appearance and function, and become flat or attenuated.6 This was confirmed in the present study by LM and TEM. The disordered endothelial sheet, perhaps containing cells of fibroblastic origin, lays down a posterior collagenous layer which may be banded, fibrillar, or fibrocellular.

We have confirmed earlier observations that endothelial damage causes nodulation, breaks, and scroll formation in DM.6 Abnormal endothelial function probably including fibroblastic activity, produces a posterior collagenous layer containing wide spacing collagen, microfilaments and basement membrane-like material.7 The functional failure of the endothelial cells leads to corneal oedema and formation of bullae in the epithelium and subepithelial region.

Endothelial decompensation leads to an increase in stromal thickness and to subepithelial fibrosis with an accumulation of abnormal PG31 and degenerate collagen fibrils. It is believed that the degenerate pannus is formed when fibroblast-like cells, derived from the corneal stroma, insinuate themselves into the space between Bowman's membrane and the epithelial basement membrane.32Keratocyte numbers are reported to be reduced in bullous keratopathy.6 Since the nutrition of keratocytes would be anticipated to be relatively uninfluenced by the swelling, another mechanism must be sought their loss. One suggested mechanism is an involvement of the epithelium in an IL-1, Fas/Fas ligand induced mechanism of apoptotic death.33

Kenny et al 5 believe that the fibrotic pannus is a response to the formation of epithelial bullae. This is thought to lead to epithelial degeneration, reduplication, and the synthesis of an intraepithelial basal lamina-like material, within epithelial folds. Eagle et al 32suggested that folded epithelial bullae are probably caused by buckling of the basement membrane due to a shift or dislocation of the loosened or shallowly detached corneal epithelium. The abnormal function of the epithelium produces a multilayered basal lamina, and loss of hemidesmosomes results in disruption of the anchoring filaments.

  Immunoelectron microscopy has shown for the first time the precise labelling of proteins at the cellular and subcellular level which could not be shown by light microscopy or by any other technique. This ultrastructural localisation of the proteins has provided us with a better understanding of their involvement in BK corneas:


In our normal corneal samples, labelling was observed in the subepithelial basement membrane, Bowman's layer, stroma, and Descemet's membrane, but not in or close to the endothelium. Similar labelling of βig-h3 was observed by Streeten et al.34 Takács et al 11 reported that, in normal cornea, labelling was strong in the basal epithelial cell layer and endothelium, faint in the stroma and keratocytes, and absent in Bowman's layer and DM. This differs from our findings in BK, where labelling was scanty in the epithelial cells, and heavy in the thick basement membrane, on the anchoring filaments, in some parts of the stroma and on the very fine fibrous material around keratocytes. Labelling was not seen within keratocytes. Absence of labelling in keratocytes suggests that most of the βig-h3 protein has been secreted from the epithelium and deposited on the fibrous material. Labelling was also strong on fibrous material in the stroma, in DM, and on microfilaments in the PCL but it was not seen in the endothelium. Most of the stroma had moderate labelling. Takács et al 11reported that in PBK, there was positive labelling of the basal epithelial layer, under the epithelium, in and above the endothelium, and in the keratocytes, contrary to our observations. They also found staining in the fibrotic area—that is, the pannus and PCL, similar to our findings.

The association of βig-h3 with extracellular matrix macromolecules, such as fibrillin in microfibrils,35 type II collagen in cartilage,36 and type VI collagen in cornea37 ,38 has suggested that βig-h3 functions as an extracellular matrix molecule, perhaps facilitating cell-matrix interactions during morphogenesis.14 ,37 βig-h3 is found in rabbit corneal epithelial cells,39 and both in the corneal epithelium and endothelium, as well as in the newly formed extracellular matrix of Fuchs' dystrophy cornea.40 It is likely that in the oedematous stroma of BK, the distribution of βig-h3 across the stroma is facilitated by the widening of intercollagenous fibrillar spaces41.

The presence of TGF-β1, TGF-β2, and cytokines (IFN-r, IL-2, IL-4, IL-10, IL-12) was shown in bullous keratopathy corneas, and scarring often accompanies this disease.42 Furthermore, TGF-β, which has an important role in wound healing, is considered to be the major factor for enhancing the secretion of βig-h3.11 It is believed that TGF-β promotes the secretion of βig-h3 in BK corneas. Since it has been found in several cell types,14 ,42 it is believed that this protein (βig-h3) could also play an important part in cellular adhesion and/or signalling11 ,21 like other proteins such as TN-C and fibrillin.8 ,9 ,11


From our observations, labelling of TNC by TN-2 and BC10 was found in the fibrotic pannus and PCL, anterior stroma and pre-Descemet's posterior stroma, and in non-banded DM, similar to the observation of Ljubimov et al.8 In addition, however, BC10 labelling was also found within epithelial cells, in the basement membrane around disrupted anchoring filaments, in Bowman's layer, and in banded DM close to electron lucent spaces.

Ljubimov et al 8 have suggested that following injury, mechanical stress on myofibroblasts induced by stromal swelling, causes contraction which acts on the surrounding collagen fibrils, and tends to compress the normal structure of the stroma, which results in the production and deposition of TNC.8 In cultures, contraction of myofibroblasts induces the production and deposition of TNC.16 Maserukaet al 25 have also demonstrated persistent TNC expression in corneas at sites of tension in malapposed corneal grafts. TNC variants have adhesive, as well as anti-adhesive properties. Using the monoclonal antibody BC2, which recognises high Mr TNC variants associated (in vitro) with anti-adhesion and proliferation, Maseruka et al 9 demonstrated the presence of anti-adhesive variants along the borders of subepithelial bullae in pseudophakic bullous keratopathy corneas. BC2 is ineffective as an immunoreagent under the conditions of our ultrastructural study (data not presented) presumably because of failure of penetration of antibody into the LR white resin embedded tissue. However, we have shown BC10 and TN2, which recognise all TNC variants, to be present in areas of loss of intercellular contacts and downregulation of focal adhesion, suggesting a role in weakening cell-substrate attachment and promotion of cell detachment by loss of intercellular contacts and downregulation of focal adhesion.16 ,19 ,43 ,44 Thus subepithelial TN-C weakens the subepithelial adhesion contributing to the formation of bullae.41 Small pH variations can modify the TN-C splicing pattern.45 In addition, TNC expression can also be induced by fibrogenic cytokines46-48 such as TGF-β, fibroblast growth factor and, platelet derived growth-BB, all of which also induce the formation of βig-h3.8


In normal adult cornea, peripheral epithelial basement membrane showed positive staining for fibrillin-1, but little or no fibrillin-1 staining was detected in the central basement membrane.10 ,28 ,29 We found no staining for fibrillin in our normal cornea.

In an earlier study of BK, fibrillin-1 was expressed in the epithelial basement membrane, the stroma, DM, the area of subepithelial fibrosis and in the PCL.10 We confirmed these results and found similar fibrillin-1 staining on very fine fibrils in BK cornea. But we also found staining on the epithelial surface and inside the epithelial cells.

Fibrillin-1 accumulation has been observed during corneal wound healing.49 It was also found with fibrotic extracellular matrix at Bowman's layer breaks in keratoconus corneas.5 ,50 It is believed that fibrillin-1 accumulation in BK cornea may be part of a fibrotic, healing process occurring in these corneas, related to the altered fluid balance and corneal swelling.10 It is possible that growth factors and cytokines, which are expressed during wound healing, may contribute to the appearance of fibrillin-1. An increased level of interleukins 1α (IL-1α) and 8 (IL-α8) in BK cornea42 might be responsible for the expression of fibrillin-1 as was observed in UVB damaged skin.51

With endothelial failure, fluid accumulates in the stroma and epithelium. This results in the formation of stromal lakes or subepithelial and intraepithelial bullae and causes mechanical stress to cells in the neighbourhood of the fluid accumulation. We suggest that this, in turn, may induce epithelial cells, keratocytes, and fibroblasts in these affected areas to produce TNC, βig-h3, and fibrillin as part of an injury response. It is likely that this occurs in response to the release of growth factors and cytokines, which enhance the production of the above proteins.6 ,25 The induction of the production of anti-adhesive TNC variants,5 together with βig-h3 and fibrillin, contributes to the poor adhesive and growth properties of the epithelium.


We thank Dr K Bennett for the gift of βig-h3 antibody. We acknowledge the financial support of the Wellcome Trust and Medical Research Council (to KMM).


View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.