Article Text

PDF

Retinal vessel wall signs and the 5 year incidence of age related maculopathy: the Blue Mountains Eye Study
  1. J J Wang1,
  2. P Mitchell1,
  3. E Rochtchina1,
  4. A G Tan1,
  5. T Y Wong2,
  6. R Klein3
  1. 1Centre for Vision Research, Department of Ophthalmology and the Westmead Millennium, the University of Sydney, Australia
  2. 2Singapore Eye Research Institute and National University of Singapore, Singapore
  3. 3Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Sciences, University of Wisconsin-Madison, WI, USA
  1. Correspondence to: Jie Jin Wang, PhD Centre for Vision Research, Department of Ophthalmology, University of Sydney, Westmead Hospital, Hawkesbury Road, Westmead, NSW Australia, 2145; jiejinwangwmi.usyd.edu.au

Abstract

Aims: To assess whether retinal arteriolar wall changes (focal narrowing and arteriovenous nicking) are associated with an increased 5 year risk of age related maculopathy (ARM).

Methods: The Blue Mountains Eye Study examined 3654 residents aged 49+ years living in a defined area, during 1992–4 (82.4% participation). After 5 years, 2335 surviving participants (75.1%) were re-examined during 1997–9. Retinal photographs were graded using the Wisconsin ARM grading system. Incident late (neovascular or atrophic) or early stage ARM was defined using a side by side grading method. Focal arteriolar narrowing (localised constricted arteriolar segments causing a sausage-like appearance), and arteriovenous (AV) nicking (constriction on both sides of the venule where crossed by an arteriole), were graded by comparison with standard photographs. All retinal vessels passing through a circumferential zone 0.5–1.0 disc diameters from the optic disc margin were measured from digitised images. Summarised estimates for central retinal arteriolar equivalent (CRAE) represent an average diameter of arterioles for that eye. Associations were assessed after adjusting for age, sex, smoking, mean arterial blood pressure, and other vascular risk factors.

Results: Of 2314 baseline participants at risk of late stage ARM, either late stage lesion developed in 34 participants (1.5%). Of 2203 at risk of early stage ARM, this sign developed in 197 participants (8.9%). Focal arteriolar narrowing was present at baseline in at least one eye of 162 survivors (6.9%) and severe AV nicking was present in 187 people (8.1%). Over 5 years, 4.9% of subjects with and 1.2% of those without focal narrowing developed either late stage ARM lesion, age adjusted relative risk (RR) 2.3, 95% confidence interval (CI) 1.0 to 5.1, multivariate adjusted odds ratios (OR) 2.1 (95% CI 0.9 to 4.9). Similarly, 3.7% of subjects with and 1.3% of those without severe AV nicking developed late ARM lesions, age adjusted RR 2.1 (95% CI 0.9 to 5.1), multivariate adjusted OR 2.2 (95% CI 0.9 to 5.6). Corresponding age adjusted RR and multivariate adjusted OR for development of early stage ARM were 1.4 (95% CI 0.9 to 2.0) and 1.3 (95% CI 0.8 to 2.1) for focal arteriolar narrowing, and 1.6 (95% CI 1.0 to 2.3) and 1.8 (95% CI 1.1 to 2.9) for severe AV nicking, respectively. No associations between baseline CRAE and 5 year incident late or early stage ARM were found.

Conclusions: Although of borderline statistical significance, the consistent associations found in this study suggest that structural retinal arteriolar changes may either contribute to ARM progression or may share common pathological pathways with ARM.

  • age related maculopathy
  • population based cohort
  • Blue Mountains Eye Study

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Evidence from epidemiological studies has suggested associations between atherosclerosis, cardiovascular risk factors, and age related maculopathy (ARM).1,2 Relevant risk factors include current smoking,3,4 systemic hypertension,5,6 history of coronary, carotid, and peripheral vascular disease,1 serum cholesterol,7 dietary fat intake,8,9 and body mass index.10 However, among these potential risk factors, only smoking has consistently been associated with ARM.

A recent report from the Beaver Dam Eye Study has provided evidence of an association between blood pressure and the risk of developing early or late stage ARM.6 Higher systolic blood pressure and higher pulse pressure at baseline were associated with an increased 10 year incidence of retinal pigment abnormalities and of neovascular ARM. Controlled or uncontrolled hypertension under medication at baseline was associated with a twofold to threefold risk of neovascular ARM in 10 years (multivariate adjusted risk ratios were 2.3 and 3.3, respectively). People whose systolic blood pressure had increased more than 5 mm Hg from baseline to the 5 year follow up examination were found to have a threefold risk of incident late stage ARM over the next 5 years, compared with people who had stable systolic blood pressure during the same period.6

Overwhelming evidence from recent population based studies has documented a strong relation between elevated blood pressure and retinal microvascular changes.11–16 This relation has also been demonstrated in our study population.17,18

We previously observed a twofold increased prevalence of late stage ARM lesions in persons with focal retinal arteriolar narrowing or arteriovenous (AV) nicking, after adjusting for age, sex, and smoking (unpublished data). Such findings, particularly retinal vessel narrowing, in eyes presenting with late stage ARM, would not be surprising, as these signs could be expected to occur secondary to retinal atrophy involving the posterior pole. The finding of occasional retinal haemorrhages or microaneurysms could also be expected in the presence of neovascular ARM. With such cross sectional observations, it would not be possible, with any certainty, to know whether the retinal vascular changes preceded or were the result of the late stage ARM.

In view of reported associations between cardiovascular function and subsequent development of ARM, together with limited evidence linking microvascular structural changes to this outcome, we aimed to investigate longitudinal associations between structural arteriolar changes present at baseline and the subsequent development of early and late stage ARM.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The Blue Mountains Eye Study (BMES) is a population based, longitudinal study of vision and eye disease in an urban population aged 49 years or older, resident in two postcode areas in the Blue Mountains region, west of Sydney, Australia. At baseline, 3654 (82.4%) of the 4433 eligible residents were examined during 1992–4. Five years later, 543 had died and 2335 of the 3111 surviving participants (75.1%) were re-examined during 1997–9.

All participants who attended both baseline and 5 year follow up examinations had a face to face interview conducted and comprehensive eye examinations after pupil dilatation, including stereoscopic retinal photographs (30 degree) taken of the macula and other retinal fields of both eyes,19 using a Zeiss FF3 fundus camera (Carl Zeiss, Oberkochen, Germany). Stereoscopic retinal photographs of at least one eye were obtained in 98% of participants at baseline, and in 99% of those attending the 5 year follow up examinations. Grading for late and early ARM lesions, including neovascular ARM, geographic atrophy, indistinct soft or reticular drusen and retinal pigmentary abnormalities, followed the Wisconsin Age Related Maculopathy Grading System.20 Assessment of incident ARM lesions was described in our 5 year ARM incidence report.21 All incident cases were confirmed using a side by side grading method.22

Definitions

Late stage ARM lesions were defined to include geographic atrophy at the macula (regardless of foveal involvement) and neovascular ARM, as described in the International ARM Classification.23 Lesions classified as neovascular ARM included serous or haemorrhagic detachment of the RPE or sensory retina, presence of subretinal or sub-RPE haemorrhages or subretinal fibrosis and photocoagulation scars in cases previously documented as having neovascular ARM. Geographic atrophy was defined as a discrete area, at least 175 μm in diameter, of retinal depigmentation characterised by a sharp border and presence of visible choroidal vessels. In this report, cases with signs of neovascular ARM and widespread geographic atrophy were classified as positive for both subtypes. All cases with late stage ARM lesions at either examination were adjudicated by two retinal specialists (PM, RK). The incidence of either type of late stage ARM lesion was defined as the appearance at follow up of neovascular AMD or geographic atrophy in eyes without either lesion at baseline.

Early stage ARM was defined as the absence of late stage ARM and presence of either: (1) large (>125 μm diameter) indistinct soft or reticular drusen or (2) both large distinct soft drusen and retinal pigmentary abnormalities (hyperpigmentation or hypopigmentation)23 within the macular area.20 Incident early stage ARM was defined as the appearance at follow up of either indistinct soft or reticular drusen or the co-presence of both distinct soft drusen and retinal pigmentary abnormalities in either eye of those in whom no late or early stage ARM was present at baseline and no late stage ARM was present at follow up. Definitions for incident ARM lesions closely followed the definitions developed by Klein et al for the Beaver Dam Eye Study,22 modified to use fewer categories for drusen size.21

Focal arteriolar narrowing and arteriovenous (AV) nicking were graded from 35 mm retinal slides of both eyes taken at baseline using a light box (Kelvin rating approximately 6200°) and a Donaldson viewer. Only arterioles located at least ½ disc diameter away from the optic disc margin were assessed for focal arteriolar narrowing. Standard photographs for retinal vascular changes were selected by a retinal specialist (PM) from the standard photographic set developed for the Modified Airlie House Classification of Diabetic Retinopathy24 (Standards 2A, 8A, 10A, and 14) and the Wisconsin Age-related Maculopathy Grading System.20 Focal arteriolar narrowing, localised sausage-like constrictions along the course of arterioles, was identified and graded as absent/questionable (none or less severe than the standard photograph) or present (equal to or more severe than the standard). AV nicking (nipping) was graded as present when constriction was evident on both sides of a venule where crossed by an arteriole. AV nicking was graded as absent/questionable, mild (less than the standard), or severe (equal to or greater than the standard). One grader performed this type of grading. A retinal specialist (PM) provided training and adjudication. Intragrader reliability was assessed; kappa statistics for detecting focal arteriolar narrowing and AV nicking were 0.80 and 0.87, respectively. Both focal arteriolar narrowing and AV nicking were defined using findings from the worse eye.

A computer assisted grading method with high reproducibility was used to measure retinal vessel width (diameter).25 In brief, digitised retinal images of one eye (mainly right eyes) of each participant were displayed using Optimate image library software (version 6.51; Media Cybernetics, Silver Spring, MD, USA) and “RetinalAnalysis” software (Department of Ophthalmology and Visual Science, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WI, USA). A digital grid consisting of three concentric circles centred on the optic disc was placed over the image. All vessels greater than 25 μm in diameter and completely passing through the region 0.5–1.0 disc diameters from the optic disc margin were measured. The grader identified the arterioles and venules, with reference to the original photographs, and selected a section of the vessel for measurement. Average arteriolar or venular width (diameter) was calculated using the Parr-Hubbard formula14,26 and presented as central retinal arteriolar equivalent (CRAE) or central retinal venular equivalent (CRVE). Generalised retinal arteriolar narrowing was defined as CRAE within the lowest quintile for the population. The Parr-Hubbard formula is:

Math

and

Math

where Wc was calculated as the trunk calibre, and includes calibres from the smallest (Wa) to largest branches (Wb).14

Eyes were only considered gradable if all vessels, of width greater than 45 μm could be measured accurately. Intragrader and intergrader grading reliability of this method was assessed previously,25 with quadratic weighted kappa 0.85 (CRAE) and 0.90 (CRVE) for intergrader reliability and between 0.80–0.93 and 0.80–0.92 for intragrader reliability in grader 1 and 2 respectively. Good correlation in measurement between right and left eyes was also found.27

At baseline, blood pressure (BP) was measured after participants had been comfortably seated for at least 5 minutes. A single measure of systolic and diastolic blood pressures (SBP, DBP) using a mercury sphygmomanometer was recorded from the first and fifth Korotkoff sounds. Mean arterial blood pressure (MABP) was calculated as 0.33 (SBP) + 0.67 (DBP).

Statistical Analysis System (SAS, SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA), was used for statistical analyses, which were performed using each of the following incident ARM lesions as a dependent variable: neovascular ARM, geographic atrophy, late stage ARM lesion, early stage ARM, retinal pigmentary abnormality and indistinct soft/reticular drusen. Age adjusted relative risks (RR) were calculated using the Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel method, over 10 year age group strata. The relation between incident ARM stages or lesions and each type of retinal arteriolar change at baseline was further assessed using logistic regression models controlling for potential confounders, including age (continuous), sex (dichotomous), smoking (trichotomous: never, past and current) and mean arteriolar blood pressure (continuous) measured at baseline. Generalised estimating equation (GEE) models28–30 were used to assess eye specific associations between focal retinal arteriolar narrowing, AV nicking, and incident late or early stage ARM. Adjusted relative risks (RR), odds ratios (OR), and 95% confidence intervals (CI) are presented.

RESULTS

In this older cohort of 2335 participants, 21 were found to have late stage ARM at baseline, thus were not considered as at risk of developing late stage ARM. Among the 2314 at risk, 23 participants (1.0%) developed incident neovascular ARM, 17 (0.7%) developed incident GA, and 34 (1.5%) developed either late stage ARM lesions over 5 years (six developed both incident neovascular ARM and GA). After excluding those with late or early stage ARM at baseline or with late stage ARM at 5 year follow up, 2203 those were considered at risk of developing early stage ARM. Among this group, 197 (8.9%) developed early stage ARM over 5 years; 177 of 2005 participants (8.8%) developed incident retinal pigmentary abnormalities, and 114 of 2148 (5.3%) developed incident soft indistinct or reticular drusen.

Table 1 shows the relation between focal arteriolar narrowing, AV nicking and ARM risk factors collected at baseline in the 2335 participants. Age and blood pressure were significantly associated with both focal narrowing and AV nicking. Body mass index was significantly associated with AV nicking but not with focal narrowing.

Table 1

Retinal vascular wall signs and age related maculopathy (ARM) risk factors in the Blue Mountains Eye Study population

At baseline, 162 participants (7.0%) in the surviving cohort were found to have focal arteriolar narrowing in at least one eye, of whom eight (4.9%) developed either neovascular ARM or geographic atrophy over 5 years, compared to 26 participants (1.2 %) without focal narrowing. The age adjusted relative risk for development of late stage ARM lesions was 2.3 (95% CI 1.0 to 5.1) for those with compared to those without focal arteriolar narrowing (table 2). The age adjusted relative risk for development of early stage ARM in persons with focal arteriolar narrowing was 1.4 (95% CI 0.9 to 2.0). Further adjustment for sex, smoking, and mean arterial blood pressure did not alter these associations appreciably (OR 2.1, 95% CI 0.9 to 4.9 for late stage ARM lesions and OR 1.3, 95% CI 0.8 to 2.1 for early stage ARM).

Table 2

Five year incidence of age related maculopathy (ARM) lesions by presence of focal arteriolar narrowing at baseline

At baseline, 902 (39.0%) and 187 (8.1%) participants had mild and severe AV nicking, respectively. Of those with severe AV nicking, seven (3.7%) developed either late stage ARM lesion over 5 years, compared with 16 (1.3%) without AV nicking, age adjusted relative risk 2.1 (95% CI 0.9 to 5.1), as shown in table 3. The age adjusted relative risk of developing early stage ARM was 1.6 (95% CI 1.0 to 2.3). Further adjustment for sex, smoking, and mean arterial blood pressure did not alter the association appreciably (OR 2.2, 95% CI 0.9 to 5.7 for late stage ARM lesions and OR 1.8, 95% CI 1.1 to 3.0 for early stage ARM).

Table 3

Five year incidence of age related maculopathy (ARM) lesions by presence of arteriovenous nicking at baseline

Eye specific findings on the relation between focal arteriolar narrowing, AV nicking, and incident ARM support the subject specific (worse eye) findings reported above. Table 4 demonstrates associations between incident early or late stage ARM and structural arteriolar signs based on analysis of data from two eyes using a GEE model, showing significantly increased odds for incident early stage ARM in eyes with these retinal vessel wall changes.

Table 4

Eye specific assessment of the relation between retinal vessel signs and incident late stage age related maculopathy (ARM) lesions or early stage ARM

No significant association nor trend of association, was found between baseline CRAE and the 5 year incidence of late or early stage ARM (table 5).

Table 5

Five year incidence of age related maculopathy (ARM) lesions by presence of generalised arteriolar narrowing (lower quintiles of central retinal arteriolar equivalent, CRAE) at baseline

Adjusting for current or ever use at baseline of antihypertensive medication, or β blockers specifically, or hypertension status, instead of mean arterial blood pressure in the models did not alter these associations substantially (data not shown). Additional adjustment for body mass index and serum lipids (cholesterol or triglyceride) in the multivariate model containing age, sex, smoking, and MBP did not substantially alter the association (data not shown).

DISCUSSION

Findings from our study suggest a possible association between retinal vessel changes (focal arteriolar narrowing and AV nicking) and the subsequent development of either late or early stage ARM. Incident late stage ARM lesions were seen twice as frequently in those with than without retinal vessel signs, while incident early stage ARM was 60% more likely, after adjusting for age, sex, smoking, and mean arterial blood pressure. Although only a few estimates were of borderline statistical significance, the majority were non-significant. Our findings were generally consistent within the study and are broadly in keeping with findings from the Rotterdam Study,1 the Beaver Dam Eye Study,6,31 and the Atherosclerosis Risk in Communities (ARIC) Study.32

In a nested case-control study within the Rotterdam Study baseline survey, people aged younger than 85 years with carotid plaques were substantially more likely to have ARM.1 In the ARIC study population, retinal arteriolar focal narrowing was significantly associated with prevalent retinal pigment epithelial depigmentation.32 In the 5 year follow up examination of the Beaver Dam Eye Study, baseline high pulse pressure, but not hypertension, was found to be significantly associated with 5 year incident retinal pigmentary abnormality and neovascular ARM.31 However, at the 10 year follow up examination of the same cohort, in addition to systolic blood pressure and pulse pressure, baseline hypertension was found to be significantly associated with the 10 year incidence of neovascular ARM.6

In contrast with previous studies of the relation between hypertension/atherosclerosis and ARM, the current study was conducted to assess the relation between ARM and structural changes in retinal arterioles that are likely to reflect microvascular damage from long standing hypertension. One strength of this study is that the retinal vessel changes were documented from baseline retinal photographs, before the development of either early or late stage ARM. Blood pressure levels may fluctuate over time, often in relation to current treatment, whereas structural arteriolar signs may be a more stable indication of the severity of hypertensive damage. Findings from this and three other study populations1,6,32 consistently suggest a possibility of an association between vascular disease and ARM. Data from the Beaver Dam Study also suggest that there could be a relatively long term time lapse between the occurrence of vascular diseases and the development of ARM.6,31

In our study, the grading of focal arteriolar narrowing and AV nicking was masked to participants’ identity and to their blood pressure status, but required subjective judgment from graders using reference to standard retinal photographs. In our study population, we have observed a significant association between blood pressure and either focal arteriolar narrowing or AV nicking, after adjusting for age, sex, smoking, body mass index, blood glucose, and serum lipids (unpublished data). Such retinal vessel changes could have been indicators of microvascular damage resulting from long term elevated blood pressure.14

Prolonged filling of the choroidal capillaries has been demonstrated in ARM33 so it is possible that the retinal vasculature also shares perfusion problems in late stage ARM cases. A model has proposed that choroidal haemodynamic factors could increase resistance of the choroidal circulation, a state that could be mirrored in the retinal circulation.34 Snow and Seddon recently reviewed epidemiological research regarding ARM risk factors associated with cardiovascular disease and concluded that the evidence overall suggested a mild to moderate association between elevated blood pressure and late stage ARM.2 This relation was confirmed in a later report of a large case-control study5 and, more strongly, in the 10 year Beaver Dam Eye Study data.6

We used a computer assisted, semiautomatic method to assess generalised narrowing of retinal arterioles, which was shown to have a high intergrader and intragrader reproducibility.25 We also observed a significant negative trend between increasing mean arterial blood pressure and decreasing CRAE (an estimate of the average retinal arteriolar diameter), after adjusting for age, sex, smoking, body mass index, and blood glucose.18 However, we found no trend of association between CRAE quintiles and 5 year incident early or late stage ARM. Focal narrowing may represent a more severe vascular lesion than the lowest CRAE (or arteriole to venule ratio) quintile, representing generalised narrowing. In the ARIC study, AV nicking and focal narrowing were stronger predictors of incident stroke than measures of generalised narrowing.35 Alternatively, as we used data from the worse eye to define focal arteriolar narrowing or AV nicking, but used data from one eye for the CRAE measures, it is possible that data from two eyes would better reflect microvascular damage to an individual. However, given the high correlations (0.75 to 0.80) found between the two eyes in this population,27 this seems unlikely as the average retinal arteriolar diameter (CRAE) estimated from one eye is very similar to that from the average of two eyes.

A major limitation of our study is the relatively small number of incident late stage ARM cases, with insufficient study power to examine these associations in detail. However, we found consistently increased odds, with lower confidence limits at or close to 1.0 for focal narrowing and AV nicking. Both retinal arteriolar changes and ARM are strongly age related. It is possible that we could not fully adjust for the effects of age, by the inclusion of age as a continuous variable in the statistical models. As we were able to re-examine only 75% of the surviving cohort, selection or survival bias could have been introduced. Given that participants who had died or who did not return for the 5 year follow up examination could have been more likely to develop ARM,21 any bias arising from this would most likely be towards the null. The finding of a positive association between retinal vessel wall signs and incident ARM is not necessarily causal, as it could be due to sharing of similar risk factors (such as hypertension), or common antecedents in the pathological pathways for these two conditions.2

In conclusion, the associations found between structural retinal vessel wall signs (focal arteriolar narrowing and AV nipping) and incident late or early stage ARM in the Blue Mountains Eye Study provide support for the concept that vascular factors may contribute to the pathogenesis of ARM. Many associations, however, were either borderline or not statistically significant after adjusting for other known ARM risk factors, including smoking and mean arterial blood pressure, possibly because of insufficient study power. Although we cannot exclude the possibility of incomplete adjustment for potential confounders, our findings are consistent with findings from a number of other population based studies. Longer term follow up of our population and data pooling from other studies may help to clarify this relation.

Acknowledgments

Supported by the Australian National Health and Medical Research Council, Canberra Australia (grants 153948, 211069) and US grants to Klein and co-workers (NIH EY06594 and HL 59259).

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • This paper was presented at the 1st SERI-ARVO Meeting in Singapore 2003.

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.