Article Text

PDF

Unilateral electronegative ERG of non-vascular aetiology
  1. A G Robson1,
  2. E C Richardson2,
  3. A H C Koh1,
  4. C E Pavesio2,
  5. P G Hykin2,
  6. A Calcagni1,
  7. E M Graham3,
  8. G E Holder1
  1. 1Electrophysiology, Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, UK
  2. 2Medical Retina Service, Moorfields Eye Hospital, London, UK
  3. 3Ophthalmology, St Thomas’s Hospital, Lambeth Palace Road, London, UK
  1. Correspondence to: Dr G E Holder Electrophysiology, Moorfields Eye Hospital, 162 City Road, London EC1V 2PD, UK; graham.holdermoorfields.nhs.uk

Abstract

Background: Full field and pattern electroretinograms (ERG, PERG) are performed to assess generalised retinal function and macular function, respectively. An (electro) negative full field ERG usually describes an ISCEV standard maximal response in which the b-wave is smaller than a normal or minimally reduced a-wave and indicates dysfunction that is post-phototransduction. The most common cause of a unilateral negative ERG is central retinal artery occlusion (CRAO) or birdshot chorioretinopathy (BCR). This study examines the clinical and electrophysiological features of patients with unilateral negative ERG who do not have CRAO or BCR.

Methods: 12 patients were ascertained with a unilateral negative ERG in whom a vascular aetiology and BCR were excluded. Most presented with symptoms of central retinal dysfunction. In 11 of the 12 patients additional long duration photopic stimuli were used to test cone system ON and OFF responses.

Results: All 12 patients had unilateral electronegative bright flash full field ERGs indicating total or relative preservation of rod photoreceptor function, but dysfunction post-phototransduction. Seven of these patients had non-specific inflammatory changes in the eye with the negative ERG. Six patients, including five with inflammatory signs, had involvement of the cone ON response with complete preservation of cone OFF responses. A further three patients showed evidence of cone ON response abnormality with less severe OFF response involvement.

Conclusion: The ERGs in this heterogeneous group of patients predominantly showed post-phototransduction involvement of the ON pathways. Sparing of the cone OFF response was often observed. The majority of patients had signs of previous inflammation and it is speculated that these highly unusual unilateral changes may be mediated via an autoimmune mechanism.

  • ANA, antinuclear antibody
  • BCR, birdshot chorioretinopathy
  • CAR, carcinoma associated retinopathy
  • CSNB, congenital stationary night blindness
  • CRAO, central retinal artery occlusion
  • EOG, electro-oculogram
  • ERG, electroretinograms
  • FFA, fluorescein angiography
  • ISCEV, International Society for Clinical Electrophysiology of Vision
  • MAR, melanoma associated retinopathy
  • PERG, pattern electroretinogram
  • RAPD, relative afferent pupillary defect
  • electrophysiology
  • inflammation
  • autoimmune response
  • nyctalopia
  • electroretinography
  • ANA, antinuclear antibody
  • BCR, birdshot chorioretinopathy
  • CAR, carcinoma associated retinopathy
  • CSNB, congenital stationary night blindness
  • CRAO, central retinal artery occlusion
  • EOG, electro-oculogram
  • ERG, electroretinograms
  • FFA, fluorescein angiography
  • ISCEV, International Society for Clinical Electrophysiology of Vision
  • MAR, melanoma associated retinopathy
  • PERG, pattern electroretinogram
  • RAPD, relative afferent pupillary defect
  • electrophysiology
  • inflammation
  • autoimmune response
  • nyctalopia
  • electroretinography

Statistics from Altmetric.com

An electronegative electroretinogram (ERG) describes a full field ERG in which the b-wave is smaller than the normal or minimally attenuated a-wave. It is usually best seen in the rod dominated maximal ERG following stimulation with a bright flash under scotopic conditions,1–3 although sometimes manifest in cone derived ERGs recorded under photopic conditions as a reduced b:a ratio.4,5 A selectively reduced b-wave indicates impaired retinal function which is post-phototransduction, usually post-receptoral, and may be associated with a number of congenital and acquired conditions such as X linked juvenile retinoschisis,6,7 Congenital stationary night blindness (CSNB),3,8,9 central retinal artery occlusion (CRAO),10–12 birdshot chorioretinopathy (BCR),13–15 melanoma associated retinopathy (MAR),16,17 retinal toxicity,2,18,19 and a number of other less common disorders (see table 1).

Table 1

 Causes of electronegative ERG (after Koh et al21)

Unilateral electronegative ERGs are commonly associated with CRAO10–12 and may occur in some patients with BCR.3,15,20 A previous retrospective review of 2640 patients from this unit21 revealed 128 with negative ERGs (table 1). There were 25 undiagnosed cases, of which seven had unilateral electronegative ERGs. As an extension of that audit, the present study examines in detail the clinical and electrophysiological features of 12 patients with unilateral electronegative ERG in whom a vascular aetiology and BCR have been excluded. These patients have been reviewed in an attempt to ascertain common features and elucidate underlying mechanisms.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twelve patients form the basis of this report. Seven had previously been identified as having unilateral electronegative ERGs as part of an earlier study.21 The clinical notes were examined and any relevant follow up data and investigation results were reviewed. A vascular aetiology and birdshot chorioretinopathy were excluded in all patients on this basis.

Full field ERGs were performed using extended testing protocols incorporating the ISCEV (International Society for Clinical Electrophysiology of Vision) minimum standard22 in order to assess generalised retinal function.1,2 The minimum protocol incorporates the rod specific and standard bright flash ERGs, both recorded after a minimum of 20 minutes dark adaptation, and the photopic 30 Hz flicker and transient photopic ERGs, both recorded after a standard period and intensity of light adaptation. A stimulus 0.6 log units greater than the ISCEV standard flash was also used, better to demonstrate the a-wave, as suggested in the recent revision of the ISCEV standard for ERG.22 Pupils were dilated before full field ERG testing using tropicamide (1%) and phenylephrine hydrochloride (2.5%). ISCEV standard pattern ERG (PERG) was performed23 before mydriasis and the P50 component, partly originating in structures anterior to the retinal ganglion cells and driven by the macular photoreceptors, was used to assess macular function.3 In most cases, ISCEV standard electro-oculogram (EOG) was also performed24 in order to assess the function of the retinal pigment epithelium/photoreceptor interface.2,25 Long duration ON-OFF ERGs were used to assess post-receptoral cone ON and OFF pathways, predominantly arising in relation to depolarising and hyperpolarising bipolar cell function.17,26 The LED stimulator has been previously described.27 In brief, the duration of the amber stimulus was 150 ms or 200 ms. Stimulus luminance was 560 cd/m2 with a green background of 160 cd/m2, suitable to suppress rod function.28

Colour contrast thresholds along isoluminant protan, deutan, and tritan axes were determined psychophysically in all patients using the Arden colour contrast sensitivity system.29

RESULTS

Group findings

The clinical and electrophysiological findings in the 12 patients are summarised in tables 2, 3, and 4. Within this group, seven had clinical signs of inflammation. These signs ranged from fundus scarring in the absence of vitritis (case 9) to panuveitis (case 8). Abnormality of visual fields was also a common finding, seen in 10/12 cases. This was, however, variable in its extent.

Table 2

 Summary of clinical findings in all patients

Table 3

 Summary of electrophysiology and colour vision testing

Table 4

 ERG and clinical follow up

Maximal scotopic ERGs from all patients showed an electronegative ERG in one eye, consistent with post-phototransduction dysfunction affecting the rod system. Full field ERGs were additionally abnormal in the other eye of three cases, indicating dysfunction at the level of the photoreceptors (cases 9 and 10) or confined to the cone system (case 12, see below). Fellow eyes of nine patients had normal full field ERGs. The cone ON responses were affected more than the OFF responses in 9/11 patients, including 6/7 patients with signs of inflammatory disease. Inflammatory signs were confined to the eye with an electronegative ERG in three patients (cases 4, 7, and 8) or occurred bilaterally but more severely in the eye with an electronegative ERG (cases 9 and 12). In one case there was evidence of bilateral inflammatory eye disease associated with bilateral but asymmetric ERG abnormalities (case 10).

Pattern ERG P50 components were reduced unilaterally in all eyes with an electronegative ERG and were reduced bilaterally in three cases, consistent with macular dysfunction. Colour contrast thresholds were elevated in the affected eye of 9/10 patients, bilaterally in one (case 6).

Retinal function was monitored in eight patients over periods of between 10 months and 69 months, using serial ERGs. There was mild but progressive photopic ERG deterioration in case 4 (see below) and mild non-specific worsening of full field ERGs in cases 5 and 10 (table 4 and below). Five patients showed no significant electrophysiological change between recordings. In total, 7/10 patients showed evidence of clinical or subjective deterioration since ERGs were initially performed (table 4): in three of these cases abnormalities related to the development of cataract (case 8) or mild to moderate inflammatory changes (cases 6 and 7, see below). One patient with a history of bilateral chronic uveitis developed unilateral night blindness following a recurrence of inflammation in the affected eye (case 12, see detailed history below).

Four illustrative cases are presented in more detail.

Case 4

A 33 year old man presented with sudden painless loss of left visual acuity. His VA was 6/60 and he had some very mild peripheral inferior chorioretinal atrophy with a few vitreous cells. There was a left relative afferent pupillary defect (RAPD). Fields showed a dense left central scotoma. Colour contrast thresholds were profoundly elevated on the left, normal on the right. Antinuclear antibody (ANA) was weakly positive but all other tests for lupus were negative. Oral immunosuppression with steroids and azathioprine had no effect. Fluorescein angiography (FFA) showed mild leakage from one inferonasal vessel. Autofluorescence imaging showed no definite abnormality but 2 years later showed central hypofluorescence (fig 1).

Figure 1

 Fundus autofluorescence images of case 4 were initially normal bilaterally (A) but 2 years later revealed a low density area in the left eye (B).

ERGs were normal on the right (not shown). On the left, the scotopic rod ERG was subnormal and the maximal ERG was mildly electronegative, indicating post-phototransduction or post-receptoral rod system dysfunction (fig 2). Photopic ERG a-wave and b-wave amplitudes and 30 Hz flicker ERGs were severely reduced and showed mild to moderate delay and the ON b-wave and OFF d-waves were reduced in keeping with generalised cone system dysfunction. The PERG on the left was undetectable, consistent with severe macular dysfunction. Serial electrophysiological studies revealed mild but progressive deterioration of photopic full field ERGs on the left over a 5 year period. The patient remained clinically stable.

Figure 2

 Electrophysiological findings in the left eye of case 4 and right eye of case 7 (see text for details). ON-OFF ERGs were elicited using stimulus duration 120 ms (case 4) and 200 ms (case 7 and normal). For clarity, blink artefacts occurring after the ERGs have been replaced by broken lines.

Case 7

A 30 year old woman presented with right acuity loss and floaters. Right VA was 6/9. There was cystoid macular oedema and vitreous snowballs on the right, and a diagnosis of intermediate uveitis was made. There was tritan threshold elevation on colour contrast sensitivity testing. Investigations, including HLA-A29, were negative. She developed photopsia 2 years later, with right visual field constriction, and was re-referred. FFA added no new information. There was no RAPD. She developed nyctalopia on the right 5 months later.

The right eye ERGs (fig 2) showed an electronegative maximal response indicating dysfunction at a level that is post-phototransduction or post-receptoral. The 30 Hz flicker ERG was reduced and delayed with a flattened trough between adjacent peaks; single flash photopic ERG shows a broadened, bifid a-wave with a sharply rising b-wave. This photopic ERG appearance is often associated with loss of ON pathway function, but preservation of OFF pathway function, and this was confirmed by the use of photopic ON and OFF response recording. There was significant macular involvement shown by the reduced PERG. There was no evidence of dysfunction on the left (not shown). Repeat testing 10 months later revealed no significant change. There has been a recurrence of low grade uveitis since electrophysiology was last performed.

Case 10

A 31 year old man presented with a 2 year history of decreased acuity in his right eye. VA was 6/60 right, 6/5 left. There was bilateral disc swelling with occasional vitreous cells on the right, and chorioretinal scars (fig 3). There was no RAPD. Fields showed marked enlargement of the blind spot bilaterally. Magnetic resonance imaging scan was normal. Colour vision testing with Ishihara plates gave scores of 1/17 and 17/17 (right and left); colour contrast thresholds were profoundly elevated on the right along protan, deutan and tritan axes; thresholds along protan and deutan axes were normal on the left with mild elevation along the tritan axis.

Figure 3

 Fundus photographs of case 10 showing chorioretinal scarring in the periphery.

ERG studies on the right initially revealed rod ERG and maximal ERG a-wave reduction, delayed 30 Hz ERGs and delayed and reduced photopic transient ERGs. The findings indicate generalised retinal dysfunction affecting the rod and cone systems, primarily at the level of the photoreceptors with involvement of cone ON and OFF responses (fig 4). The PERG was initially present but of markedly reduced amplitude, suggesting moderately severe right macular dysfunction.

Figure 4

 Electrophysiological findings in case 10 (see text for details). ON-OFF ERGs were elicited using stimulus duration 200 ms. For clarity, blink artefacts occurring after the ERGs have been replaced by broken lines.

Full field ERGs from the left eye (fig 4) showed ON pathway involvement in both rod and cone systems (electronegative maximal response and cone ON b-wave loss). The PERG was consistent with macular dysfunction, less severe than on the right. The EOG revealed generalised dysfunction affecting the photoreceptor/RPE interface bilaterally, worse on the right (not shown).

Four years after presentation there were vitreous cells and vessel sheathing bilaterally. The right eye developed an epiretinal membrane, the left eye developed mild macular oedema. There were increasing areas of peripapillary atrophy bilaterally. Photopsia was reported on the left, without significant acuity reduction. Over this period there was slight deterioration in full field ERGs; PERG also deteriorated but left visual acuity remained normal. Following treatment with prednisolone and Diamox, full field ERGs remained stable and the left PERG normalised.

Case 12

A 54 year old woman presented with a 3 month history of unilateral night blindness. There was a 10 year history of chronic bilateral intermediate uveitis. There had been a recent flare up of uveitis with right CMO, successfully treated with post-sub-Tenon’s injection of steroids. Visual acuities were 6/6 bilaterally. There were inactive chorioretinal lesions and snowballs scattered across the inferior periphery of both eyes. In addition, the left eye showed significant vitritis, vascular sheathing, and a peripapillary chorioretinal scar as a result of a choroidal neovascular membrane.

The 30 Hz flicker ERGs were reasonably symmetrical, markedly delayed but without significant amplitude reduction, in keeping with non-specific bilateral inflammatory disease (Holder 2001), but only the night blind right eye had an electronegative ERG and selective reduction in the ON b-wave (fig 5). Reduced PERGs were consistent with bilateral macular dysfunction.

Figure 5

 Electrophysiological findings in case 12 (see text for details). ON-OFF ERGs were elicited using stimulus duration 200 ms. For clarity, blink artefacts occurring after the ERGs have been replaced by broken lines.

DISCUSSION

A unilateral “negative” ERG, not related to occlusive vascular disease or birdshot chorioretinopathy, is uncommon. Twelve such patients are described who were ascertained as an extension of a large retrospective study into electronegative ERGs, in which seven such cases were identified.21 The patients presented with a variety of signs and symptoms. Posterior segment inflammatory changes were evident in seven of the 12 cases and in six of these cases inflammatory signs or symptoms were either confined to the eye with an electronegative ERG or were more severe in this eye. In one patient (case 10) there were bilateral inflammatory changes associated with an electronegative ERG in one eye. There were ERG abnormalities in the other eye indicating generalised retinal dysfunction affecting rod and cone systems (fig 4), primarily at the level of the photoreceptors, associated with a longer history, and chorioretinal scarring (fig 3). Selective involvement of the retinal ON bipolar pathway was present in the majority of cases.

The clinical presentation of the patients in our series was diverse. Most presented with loss of acuity, blurred or distorted vision, or altered colour vision. Although difficulty in dim lighting was admitted by some patients on direct questioning, it was not usually a presenting symptom. However, one patient with a 10 year history of recurrent intermediate uveitis developed unilateral problems with night vision 3 months before ERG testing (case 12).

Previous reports have appeared of patients with acquired unilateral night blindness, normal fundi, raised rod thresholds and unilateral negative ERGs,30 including one case in which ON-OFF ERGs were additionally performed.31,32 Similar findings were present in case 7, who also developed unilateral night blindness. The negative ERG, reduced ON b-wave and other unilateral electrophysiological abnormalities in these patients are qualitatively identical to those seen (bilaterally) in “complete” X linked CSNB3,8 and MAR.3,16,17,31 Similar bilateral changes can occasionally occur in association with carcinoma associated retinopathy (CAR; Holder, unpublished observations), although CAR more commonly affects photoreceptor function and rarely gives a negative ERG. Both CAR and MAR are paraneoplastic retinopathies in which antibodies produced in response to a tumour antigen cross react with elements in the retina. The characteristic ON-OFF ERG abnormalities of MAR can be induced in monkeys by intravitreal injection of IgG from a patient with MAR.33 Immunohistochemistry using sera from MAR patients shows selective labelling of rod bipolar cells in human retina34 and there is reduced density of the bipolar cell layer in postmortem specimens from MAR patients.35 It is of interest that although one patient in the present series had a history of cutaneous melanoma, the findings in that patient involved both ON and OFF pathways and were not in keeping with MAR (case 2).

Autoimmune retinopathy has been postulated as a cause for severe visual loss and photopsia in two patients with no signs of ocular inflammation or systemic malignancy.36 Both patients had evidence of a familial immune regulation defect and in one of these cases ERGs were bilaterally electronegative but more severely abnormal in one eye. Both patients’ sera had antiretinal antibodies that localised to the inner plexiform layer. The progression of the visual loss was much slower than that in CAR and was asymmetrical. Anterior segment inflammation has been previously described in a patient with acquired unilateral nyctalopia, photopsia, and visual loss with no history of malignancy.37 That patient also had a unilateral negative ERG with selective involvement of the ON response (similar to our cases 7 and 12).

The mechanisms underlying the functional changes in these patients are not established but the high incidence of previous inflammatory disease in affected eyes is noted, as is the predilection for ON response b-wave loss and OFF response sparing. Five of seven patients with evidence of inflammatory disease had selective or predominant dysfunction of the cone ON response. This association between functional disruption of the ON response and a history of unilateral or asymmetrical ocular inflammation possibly involves an autoimmune reaction. The target site of the autoimmune reaction in the retina remains unclear but, as in MAR, is post-transduction and may be the bipolar cell or its connections. Antibodies may be directed towards antigens, disrupting signalling through the bipolar cell layer, or inflammatory changes may cause damage with subsequent exposure of antigens leading to secondary antibody production.37

In summary, a unilateral negative ERG in the absence of an occlusive vascular aetiology or BCR is an unusual finding and often associated with sparing of inner retinal OFF response function. Patients present with diverse symptoms and signs but the high incidence of previous inflammatory disease raises the possibility that the electrophysiological changes are mediated by autoimmune mechanisms. Additional studies, testing serum against retinal tissue, may assist in confirming a possible autoimmune aetiology.

Acknowledgments

The Foundation Fighting Blindness (AGR).

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Request permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.