Optic nerve sheath diameter in normal-tension glaucoma patients
- Gregor Peter Jaggi1,
- Neil Richard Miller2,
- Josef Flammer3,
- Robert N Weinreb4,
- Luca Remonda5,
- Hanspeter Esriel Killer1,3
- 1Department of Ophthalmology, Kantonsspital Aarau, Switzerland
- 2Wilmer Ophthalmological Institute, Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, Maryland, USA
- 3University of Basel, Eye Institute, Switzerland
- 4Department of Ophthalmology, Hamilton Glaucoma Center, University of California, San Diego, California, USA
- 5Department of Neuroradiology, Kantonsspital Aarau, Switzerland
- Correspondence to Professor Dr.med. Hanspeter Esriel Killer, Kantonsspital Aarau, Buchserstrasse, CH-5001 Aarau, Switzerland;
- Accepted 30 January 2011
- Published Online First 11 March 2011
Background To report on the optic nerve sheath diameter (ONSD) in patients with normal-tension glaucoma (NTG) compared with controls without known optic nerve (ON) or intracranial disease.
Methods In 18 patients with NTG (mean age 64.9±8.9 years; 7 women and 11 men), CT of the orbit was performed. 17 age- and gender-matched patients without ON or intracranial disease, who underwent CT of the orbits for non-ophthalmological reasons, served as controls. The widest intraorbital ONSD in axial sections was measured using a standardised technique. Study design: unmasked. Statistical analysis was performed using an independent two-tailed t Test and the non-parametric Spearman correlation test.
Results ONSD was significantly (p<0.001) increased in NTG patients (right side: mean 7.9±0.9 mm SD; left: 8.0±1.1 mm) compared with controls (right: 6.3±0.5 mm; left: 6.1±0.6 mm). Neither the NTG nor the control group had a significant difference in ONSD between males and females or between right and left sides.
Conclusions An increased ONSD is generally associated with increased intracranial pressure; however, ONSDs in a group of NTG patients also were significantly increased compared with controls. ON sheath compartmentation and thinning of the ON sheath are two possible explanations for an increase in the ONSD in patients with NTG.
The pathophysiology of normal-tension glaucoma (NTG), a condition characterised by visual field loss and optic disc excavation consistent with primary open-angle glaucoma (POAG) despite apparently normal intraocular pressure (IOP), remains poorly understood. Impaired blood flow to the optic nerve (ON) and vascular dysregulation are two of the most common mechanisms that have been suggested as predisposing factors in the development of NTG.1 2 Furthermore, there is some evidence that NTG is more common in migraineurs and that patients with NTG have a variety of serologic vascular-related abnormalities, such as elevated levels of endothelin.1 3
In addition to vascular risk factors, cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) pressure has been suggested as another possible contributing factor to the development of NTG. For example, Berdahl et al reported reduced intracranial pressure (ICP) in NTG patients.4 This raised the possibility that axon death in patients with NTG could be due, at least in part, to an imbalance of translaminar pressure (the difference between IOP and pressure in the subarachnoid space (SAS) of the ON). In this regard, a recent study by Ren et al reported that translaminar pressure was significantly higher in both POAG and NTG patients, compared with controls.5
In the current study, we performed CT of ON sheath diameter (ONSD) in 18 patients with NTG and compared the findings with those from a control group of 17 patients without ON or intracranial disease.
Eighteen patients (mean age 64.9±8.9 years; 7 women (62.4±8.2 years) and 11 men (66.5±9.4 years)), with bilateral NTG characterised by progressive visual field loss and optic disc appearance consistent with POAG but with IOPs always <21 mm Hg by Goldmann applanation tonometry, who were subjects included in a controlled study (Normal Tension and Chronic Open Angle Glaucoma and Cerebrospinal Fluid Composition; NIH Clinical trial—identifier: NCT00306657), underwent CT of brain and orbits combined with cisternography (in prone position, using 10 ml iopamidol) at the same time. At the beginning of cisternography, a lumbar puncture was performed that included measurement of the ICP (in order to rule out CSF pressure above 20 cm H2O), with the patient in the lateral decubitus position. At the time of lumbar puncture, 10 ml of CSF was sampled for chemical analysis and then 10 ml iopamidol was injected intrathecally. The patient was then shifted to the prone position. None of the patients was on a medication that would influence the CSF production or resorption. A 64-detector scanner (Aquillion 64, Toshiba, Tokyo, Japan) providing 0.5 mm ×32 section collimation was used. Scanning parameters 25 cm field of view, 512×512 matrix and a soft tissue and a bone reconstruction algorithm were employed. The field of view included the foramen magnum and the nose. Multiplanar reconstruction images were obtained in the axial, coronal and sagittal planes with a 1 mm slice thickness. CT images were analysed on a workstation using the Advantage Workstation (AW) 4.1 software (General Electric, Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA). Axial sections were used and the diameter of the portion of the ON adjacent to the globe was measured at its widest site to standardise the measurement of the ONSD (figure 1). All patients had at least six IOP measurements at different times during the day (between 08:00 and 20:00) in a seated position as well as at night (between 21:00 and 06:00) in a recumbent position (using a Perkins tonometer).
Seventeen age- and gender-matched individuals (mean age 66.2±15.1 years; 4 women (61.3±22.5 years) and 13 men (67.7±12.9 years)) without known intracranial or ON disease, who underwent CT scanning for maxillary and ethmoid sinus disease, served as controls, and they were recruited in a retrospective manner. Measurements of ONSD were obtained as described above (table 1).
For analysis of ONSD in NTG patients and controls, the independent two-tailed t test was used. For analysis of correlations between ONSD and age, the non-parametric Spearman rank order correlation Coefficient was used (SPSS 14.0; SPSS Inc).
This study was designed and performed according to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki and was approved by the local ethics committee.
The subjects in the NTG and control groups did not differ significantly in either age or gender (p>0.283) (figure 2). In the 18 NTG patients, right ONSDs ranged from 5.3 to 9.2 mm (mean value 7.92±0.91 mm SD). ONSDs in female subjects (n=7) ranged from 5.3 to 8.6 mm (7.5±1.10), whereas in males (n=11), it ranged from 7.2 to 9.2 mm (8.2±0.65). Left ONSDs in NTG patients ranged from 6.1 to 10.3 mm (8.0±1.06): 6.2 to 9.1 mm (7.7 ±1.02) in females and 6.1 to 10.3 (8.1±1.09) in males. In the 17 control subjects, right ONSDs ranged from 5.3 to 7.1 mm (6.3±0.49): 5.9 to 7.0 mm (6.5±0.45) in females (n=4) and 5.3 to 7.1 mm (6.3±0.51) in males (n=13). Left ONSDs in the control subjects ranged from 5.0 to 6.9 mm (6.1±0.62): 5.3 to 6.4 mm (6.0±0.49) in females and 5.0 to 7.0 mm (6.2±0.66) in males (table 1 and figure 3). In all NTG patients, the pressure (ICP) measured during lumbar puncture was less than 20 cm H2O.
Overall, the maximal intraorbital ONSD measured by CT differed significantly between the NTG patients and the control subjects (t test: p<0.001 for both right and left ONSDs). The difference in ONSDs in the subgroup of right ONs in female NTG patients (n=7) compared with right ONs in female controls (n=4) did not quite reach statistical significance (p=0.073); however, all other subgroup analyses comparing ONSDs of NTG patients and controls showed p values ranging from <0.001 to 0.029 (figure 2).
There was no significant difference in ONSDs between female and male NTG patients, neither for the right side (p=0.13) nor for the left side (p=0.44), or between female and male control subjects (right side p=0.45; left side p=0.54). There was also no statistically significant difference between right and left ONSDs in either the NTG patient group (female p=0.64; male p=0.82) or the control group (female p=0.17; male p=0.63) (figure 2). There was no significant correlation between age and ONSDs for the right (Spearman's correlation; ρ=0.087, p=0.618) or left (ρ=0.256, p=0.137) sides (figure 4).
In this study, measurements of the maximum ONSD using thin-section axial CT scans revealed that the ONSDs in patients with NTG were significantly larger than those in control subjects without ON or intracranial disease. Although the ONSDs in control subjects in this study were somewhat larger than the ONSDs described for normal subjects in a previous study using ultrasonography performed by Lam et al,6 our study nevertheless demonstrates clear-cut ONSD enlargement in patients diagnosed with NTG, a feature previously recognised only in patients with increased ICP associated with papilloedema and in patients with certain rare disorders of the ON sheath.7–10
We believe there are three potential explanations for our findings. First, the enlarged ONSDs in patients with NTG may be due to higher tissue elasticity in such patients. The dura of the ON sheath has a thickness of 0.35–0.5 mm, with its thickest part close to the sclera.11 12 Ultrasound measurements of ON sheath thickness during changes in CSF pressure show large variations among individuals, possibly related to interindividual sheath elasticity.13 But why should sheath elasticity differ between normal subjects and patients with NTG? One possible explanation could be a difference in tissue composition mediated by metalloproteinases. These highly interactive and complex inflammatory mediators are thought to play a role in corneal thinning,14 which in different concentrations could also affect the ON sheath elasticity. Indeed, metalloproteinase expression has been found to be elevated in the white blood cells of NTG patients.15
Watanabe et al described a correlation between ONSD and ICP based on measurements performed using MRI.16 Using the sigmoid curve described by Watanabe et al, our patients would be expected to have increased ICP on lumbar puncture as well. This, however, was not the case, as in all NTG patients, the CSF pressure during lumbar puncture was less than 20 cm H2O. Obviously, it would be best to measure directly the perioptic pressure in NTG patients and in normal subjects; however, such measurements are technically difficult and carry substantial risks to vision.
As the enlargement of the ONSD is a classical feature of papilloedema and therefore associated with elevated ICP, the normal or rather low ICP in our patients, as described previously in patients with NTG,4 5 is only in conflict with our ONSD measurement when we believe in a freely communicating CSF pathway. This belief however has been challenged by the finding of a vast concentration gradient of contrast-loaded CSF between the basal cisterns and the perioptic space. Indeed, using contrast-loaded cisternography, our group has demonstrated disturbances in CSF flow dynamics in a small sample of NTG patients.17 The anatomy of the SAS is of a dynamic character and can be modified by compartmentation of the SAS, as recently demonstrated in an animal model that showed impressive swelling of the meningothelial cells, thus leading to a change in the architecture of the CSF flow-modifying structures, such as the trabeculae and septae, thereby narrowing the small SAS even more.18 19 Although our study seems to be conflicting with the ONSD finding in patients with elevated ICP, compartmentation of the SAS maintained by a valve-like process during Valsalva manoeuvre could still explain the findings.
In addition to the elevated pressure in the SAS of the ON and thinning of the ON sheath, a third mechanism needs to be considered. The ON is located in the intraconal portion of the orbit that is confined by the extraocular muscles. Given this location, the intraconal pressure might influence the ONSD. Patients with thyroid disease are at risk for ON compression and the diameter of the ON sheath in this population might give a hint concerning the validity of this hypothesis.
There are several limitations to our study. First, the number of patients in both the NTG and the control groups is small. Second, the controls were recruited in a retrospective manner. Although the control subjects were not known to have either ON or intracranial disease, none had undergone a complete ophthalmological assessment. Given the low incidence of NTG, the chance that there is more than one patient in the control group with NTG is virtually minimal. It would also be interesting to perform a large prospective study of ONSD, which included patients with clear-cut POAG having both normal and elevated IOP. Nevertheless, our findings indicate that regardless of the mechanism, patients with NTG have an abnormality of their ON sheaths that may be the cause or the effect of their condition.
The authors would like to thank Andreas Schoetzau, University of Basel, for helpful support in statistics.
Competing interests None.
Ethics approval This study was conducted with the approval of the Kantonale Ethikkommission Aargau—this study is part of the ‘Normal Tension and Chronic Open Angle Glaucoma and Cerebrospinal Fluid Composition’.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.