Aims To investigate the relationship between idiopathic choroidal neovascularisation (CNV) and choroidal watershed zones (CWZs) using indocyanine green angiography (ICGA).
Design Multicentre, retrospective, interventional case series.
Methods The medical records and ICGA findings of 44 patients (44 eyes) diagnosed with idiopathic CNV were reviewed. CWZs, defined as hypofluorescence that disappeared during the early phase of ICGA, were classified, and the findings were compared with those of a control group of 30 eyes. The topographical relationship between CWZs and CNV was evaluated. Visual acuity and recurrence were analysed according to the CWZ classification.
Results The CNV lesion was subfoveal in 16 eyes, juxtafoveal in 12 eyes and extrafoveal in 16 eyes. The most common types of CWZs were stellate (23 eyes, 52.3%) and vertical (19 eyes, 43.2%). CWZs involving the fovea were seen in more patients with idiopathic CNV (37 eyes, 84.1%) than in the control group (11 eyes, 36.7%, p<0.001). The topographical relationship between CWZs and CNV was determined in 42 eyes (95.5%), with the CNV located within the CWZ in 39 eyes and at the margin in 3 eyes. Extrafoveal CNV was within the CWZ in all 16 affected eyes. At 6 months, visual acuity was significantly worse in patients with subfoveal CNV (p=0.028) or stellate CWZs (p=0.039).
Conclusions The findings of a CWZ were related to the location and functional outcome of idiopathic CNV. Our results suggest that choroidal circulation is a predisposing factor for the development of CNV in young patients.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Choroidal neovascularisation (CNV) may be complicated by various conditions, including age-related macular degeneration (AMD), white dot syndromes, high myopia, presumed ocular histoplasmosis syndrome, angioid streak and traumatic choroidal rupture. Idiopathic CNV refers to CNV that develops without any predisposing abnormalities,1–3 and few studies have suggested mechanisms for idiopathic CNV. Yang et al4 reported that inflammatory cytokines such as vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) and immunoglobulin E were detected at high levels in the serum of patients with idiopathic CNV. Favourable outcomes of anti-VEGF treatments5–8 support this theory. However, no clinical findings have been reported suggesting a possible source of VEGF.
The results of several studies have demonstrated that the human choroid has endarterial systems supplied by various posterior ciliary arteries (PCAs) and that multiple watershed zones may be located in the macula (figure 1).9 ,10 A choroidal watershed zone (CWZ) was demonstrated by fluorescein angiography (FA) to course vertically around the optic nerve head (ONH) typically in normal subjects,11 and shows various patterns with indocyanine green angiography (ICGA).12 The CWZ has a topographical relationship with CNV in exudative AMD and was proposed to be related to the development of CNV with an ischaemic mechanism.13–15
The purpose of this study was to investigate the topographical relationship of CWZs and idiopathic CNV with the objective of suggesting a mechanism for idiopathic CNV development.
The medical records of patients who were diagnosed with idiopathic CNV in five hospitals (Pusan National University Hospital, Gyeongsang National University Hospital, Haeundae Paik Hospital, Busan Paik Hospital and Gospel Hospital) from 2008 to 2013 were reviewed retrospectively. The control cohort, using the same inclusion criteria excluding the presence of idiopathic CNV, was collected in Pusan National University Hospital in 2014. The study conducted adhered to the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki.
The presence of CNV was confirmed using FA and optical coherence tomography (OCT). The inclusion criteria were as follows: age ≤45 years, an axial length of <26 mm and a spherical equivalent refractive error of not more than −5.0 dioptres (D). Patients with polypoidal choroidal vasculopathy, white dot syndromes, presumed ocular histoplasmosis syndrome, high myopia, hereditary dystrophy, angioid streak and other choroidal abnormalities related to CNV were excluded. Eyes with possible predisposing factors such as a choroidal scar, soft drusen, and a history of uveitis or central serous chorioretinopathy were also excluded.
Patients were evaluated using slit-lamp biomicroscopy with a 90 D lens, fundus photography and OCT (Cirrus HD-OCT; Carl Zeiss Meditec, Dublin, California, USA). Visual acuity was measured using the Snellen chart and converted to the logarithm of the minimum angle of resolution. FA and ICGA were performed using a confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscope (Heidelberg Retina Angiograph 2; Heidelberg Engineering, Heidelberg, Germany). For the early phase, the images were immediately obtained after injection of fluorescein or indocyanine green dye at a rate of at least two to three images per second for 30 s.
A CWZ was defined as delayed filling of the choriocapillaris which appeared as a hypofluorescence and then disappeared during the early phase of FA and ICGA.10 ,12–15 However, since assessment in FA was unreliable due to the pigmentation in Asians, CWZ was evaluated in ICGA only. ICGA findings were analysed independently by two readers (JEL and MKS), and the extent of their agreement was calculated. For discrepant assessments, the final decision was made on the basis of a consensus among the two readers.
CWZs were categorised using two classification systems based on prior reports. Hayashi and de Laey12 classified CWZs into four categories: I, nasal filling; II-A, temporal filling; II-B, temporal filling with delayed fluorescence in the foveal area; III, upper or lower temporal quadrant filling; and IV, scattered dye filling (figure 1B). Mendrinos and Pournaras13 classified CWZs into three categories: stellate, vertical and angled. Vertical CWZs were subgrouped as follows: coursing through the ONH and extending to the fovea; coursing through the ONH without extending to the fovea; and coursing through the fovea without extending to the ONH (figure 1C).
Location of CNV was categorised as subfoveal, juxtafoveal and extrafoveal, based on distance of 200 μm from the foveal centre for consistency with AMD.16 The topographical relationship between a CWZ and an area of CNV was analysed as ‘within CWZ’, ‘at the margin of the CWZ’ or ‘out of the CWZ’.13 An isolated area of delayed filling besides the abovementioned CWZ categories were analysed separately. Foveal involvement of a CWZ was also analysed.
ICGA findings in the idiopathic CNV group and the control group were compared. The visual acuity, treatments, recurrence and treatment outcomes were evaluated in patients who had been followed up for 6 months or more to determine correlations with the CWZ and CNV.
Categorical variables were compared by χ2 test or Fisher's exact test. Visual acuity was compared using non-parametrical tests (Mann-Whitney U test, Wilcoxon signed-rank test and Kruskal-Wallis test). Statistical analysis was performed using IBM SPSS Statistics V.21 (International Business Machines Corporation, Armonk, New York, USA).
Fifty-six eyes of 56 consecutive patients were reviewed, and 12 eyes were excluded because of poor-quality ICGA images or possible correlations with other predisposing conditions listed in the exclusion criteria. Thus, 44 eyes were included in this study, and their baseline profiles are summarised in table 1. The average age was 33.7 years (range 18–45 years at diagnosis). The control group was composed of a cohort of 30 normal controls (20–44 years old), who showed no significant difference from the idiopathic CNV group in sex, age and refractive error.
Classification of CWZs
A CWZ began to show just after appearance of choroidal artery between 6 s and 16 s after injection of indocyanine green solution, depending on the injection site. A CWZ was discernible for 5.9 s (±1.8, range 3–12 s) in idiopathic CNV group, and 5.1 s (±1.3, range 3–8 s) in control group. The difference was not statistically significant (p=0.071, Mann-Whitney U test).
The agreement was 77.3% for Mendrinos’ classification, 73.3% for Hayashi's classification and 90.7% for foveal involvement of a CWZ. Table 2 shows the results of the CWZ classification in ICGA. According to Hayashi's classification, type IV was most common (23 eyes, 52.3%). Type II-A was seen in seven eyes (15.9%), type II-B in five eyes (11.4%) and type III in nine eyes (20.5%). Using Mendrinos’ classification, stellate CWZs were most common and were found in 23 eyes (52.3%, figure 2). Vertically oriented CWZs (figures 3⇓⇓–6) were seen in 19 eyes (43.2%) and angled CWZs in 2 eyes (4.5%). In the control group, the distribution did not differ from that of the patients with idiopathic CNV in both CWZ classifications (p=0.150 and 0.261, χ2 test).
CWZs involving the fovea were seen in more patients with idiopathic CNV (37 eyes, 84.1%) than in the control group (11 eyes, 36.7%, p<0.001). The foveal area in the control group was commonly spared even in eyes with stellate CWZs (7 of 13 eyes, figure 7). In addition to the abovementioned CWZ classifications, 11 eyes (25.0%) had isolated areas of delayed filling (figures 5 and 6). Some of these areas appeared to correlate with the distribution of short PCAs rather than with the CWZ (figure 5).
Topographical relationship between CWZ and CNV
CNV location was subfoveal in 16 eyes (36.4%), juxtafoveal in 12 eyes (27.3%) and extrafoveal in 16 eyes (36.4%, table 1). CNV was located within an area of delayed filling in 39 eyes (88.6%, figures 3⇑–5) and at the margin in 3 eyes (6.8%, figure 2). Two eyes (4.5%), one with subfoveal CNV and the other with juxtafoveal CNV, had CNV outside the areas of a vertical CWZ coursing through the disc (figure 6). Extrafoveal CNV was located within an area of delayed filling in all eyes (figures 3⇑–5). Six eyes (13.6%) had a CNV located within the isolated areas of delayed filling (figure 5).
No relationship was found between CNV location and CWZ classification (p=0.342–0.510, χ2 test, table 3).
The primary treatment was intravitreal ranibizumab for 10 patients, intravitreal bevacizumab for 31 patients and photodynamic therapy for 1 patient. Two patients received no treatment. Thirty-six patients were followed up for ≥6 months; 19 patients were followed up for ≥12 months. The mean follow-up duration was 16.0 months.
In patients followed up for ≥6 months, the median visual acuity significantly improved from 20/60 at baseline to 20/20 at 6 months (p=0.002) and 20/25 at 12 months (p=0.003, Wilcoxon signed-rank test). Patients received photodynamic therapy or an intravitreal injection 2.7 times by 6 months and 3.1 times by 1 year in average. Better baseline visual acuity was related to better visual outcomes (p<0.001). At 6 months, visual acuity was better for the eyes with non-subfoveal CNV than for the eyes with subfoveal CNV (p=0.028, Mann-Whitney U test, table 4). A stellate CWZ or type IV CWZ was related to significantly worse visual acuity than the other types (p=0.039, Mann-Whitney U test, table 4). No other correlation was found (p=0.058–0.746, Mann-Whitney U test and Kruskal-Wallis test).
There was a recurrence of CNV activity in 8 of the 36 patients (22.2%) by 6 months and in 7 of the 19 patients (36.8%) by 12 months. A vertical CWZ extending to the fovea was the most common type among the patients showing recurrence by 6 months (4 eyes, 50.0%) and 12 months (5 eyes, 71.4%), but recurrence was not statistically significant with regards to classification of CWZ (p=0.334–0.694, Fisher's exact test and χ2 test).
Our study revealed that idiopathic CNV had topographical relationships with CWZs, suggesting that delayed perfusion of the choriocapillaris may predispose patients to idiopathic CNV development. Hayreh suggested a pathological role of a CWZ in development of CNV for the first time in 1974.17 However, because of the unique features of the choroidal vasculature the debate regarding a hypoxic role for CWZs continues. For example, angiography in vivo shows that the choroidal lobule is supplied by a terminal arteriole not anastomosing with the adjacent lobule,18 but a corrosion cast study demonstrated that the submacular choroidal vessels anastomose at various levels of capillaries, arterioles and venules.19
Many studies have substantiated that CWZs play a pathological role. In vivo studies using FA have indicated that the choroid has an endarterial system along with segmental blood flow from the PCAs.9 ,17 Laser-targeted angiography has demonstrated that cross-flow from lobule to lobule does not occur in the normal choroid.20 The segmental distribution of choroidal perfusion from the various PCAs has been studied in eyes with ischaemic optic neuropathy or choroidal infarction.21 ,22 CWZs, representing boundaries situated between the segmental perfusions,10 are important in various clinical situations because of their relatively poor blood flow.23
Several studies have shown that AMD has a relationship with choroidal filling patterns.13 ,15 ,24 In these studies, the most common CWZ was the stellate type, with a topographical relationship rate from 71% to 100%. Choroidal thinning and elevated intraocular VEGF levels in patients with AMD also suggest that choroidal ischaemia may lead to CNV.25–27 Decreased choroidal circulatory parameters were associated with AMD development and progression.28 Moreover, eyes with delayed patchy choroidal filling seen on FA had worse functional outcomes following anti-VEGF treatment.29
In our study, idiopathic CNV was related to the presence of a CWZ. A stellate or type IV CWZ was found most frequently, concordant with previous reports involving patients with AMD.13 ,14 The topographical relationship between idiopathic CNV and CWZs was found in 42 eyes (95.5%). We also found isolated areas of delayed filling that could not be categorised as typical CWZ in 11 eyes, and 6 of these eyes (54.5%) had CNV located in those areas. It is noteworthy that extrafoveal CNV was found more frequently in our patients than in those with AMD, and it always had a topographical relationship with a CWZ. These results indicate that the development of idiopathic CNV is closely associated with delayed choroidal filling, particularly when a CWZ involves the fovea.
The most pathological type of CWZ in our study was the stellate or type IV CWZ, which was associated with significantly worse visual acuity at 6 months follow-up. The stellate shape suggests that multiple CWZs exist among choroidal perfusions, and the choroidal filling is delayed more broadly than the other types. The specific type of CWZ appears to relate more to prognosis than development because, in our study and others, the frequency of a stellate CWZ was only slightly higher (44–60%) in pathological conditions than in the control groups (35–48%).12 ,13
Subfoveal choroidal thickness was reported thicker in the eye with idiopathic CNV than the fellow eye, and the thickness decreased after anti-VEGF therapy.30 Although the choroid is thickest at the fovea and would have high blood flow, these do not necessarily mean that the choroid is non-ischaemic, because larger choroidal vessels occupy most of the thickness and flow. Choroidal thickening would be a sign of congestion of the choroid and stasis in the venous drainage,27 and these may cause hypoxia of the choriocapillaris and outer retina.
Choroidal ischaemia would not be the only mechanism for idiopathic CNV. A CWZ was found in all eyes in the control group, and there were two eyes in which CNV developed outside the CWZ. However, none of them was extrafoveal (figure 6). It is known that the fovea is the area most vulnerable to ischaemia, because several sectors of segmental perfusion meet in the foveal area in a wedge shape that forms multiple CWZs (figure 1).17 Moreover, the fovea is the most active area demanding oxygen, and predisposing to relative hypoxia than the other area. Accordingly, even when CNV and CWZs are not matched topographically, a possible relationship with the choroidal circulation cannot be excluded.
Our study has several limitations. It was a retrospective study, and the follow-up period was short. Various treatment guidelines and follow-up intervals were applied. OCT images of the choroid were not evaluated using enhanced depth imaging or swept-source OCT. These aspects should be evaluated in future studies.
In conclusion, CWZs were found to be related to idiopathic CNV topographically, and CWZ classification was a predictor of functional outcomes. These results suggest that choroidal perfusion is an important mechanism predisposing young to middle-aged patients to the development of CNV.
Contributors Study concept and design: JEL; acquisition of data: all authors; analysis and interpretation of data, and preparation of manuscript: JEL, MKS; review of manuscript: all authors. All authors had full access to all the data in the study and take responsibility for the integrity of the data and accuracy of the data analysis.
Competing interests None declared.
Patient consent Obtained.
Ethics approval Institutional Review Board of Pusan National University Hospital.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.