Aim To describe optical coherence tomography angiography (OCTA) features of polypoidal choroidal neovascularisation (PCNV) secondary to age-related macular degeneration.
Methods A retrospective consecutive series of 51 patients with a diagnosis of PCNV, based on clinical and multimodal imaging, was analysed. All patients with PCNV underwent a comprehensive ophthalmological examination, including fluorescein and indocyanine green angiography, structural optical coherence tomography (OCT) and OCTA. Two blinded retinal specialists carefully reviewed OCTA slabs in order to assess the morphological patterns of PCNV lesions. Furthermore, fractal analysis of PCNV en face images on OCTA, including vascular perfusion density (VPD), fractal dimension (FD) and lacunarity (LAC), was performed.
Results Fifty-one PCNV eyes were included in the study. In all, the branching vascular network appeared hyper-reflective. Polyps showed two different patterns: in 34/51 (67%) eyes, they corresponded to hypo-reflective structures, whereas in the remaining 17 (33%) eyes, they appeared as hyper-reflective lesions. In all PCNV eyes, mean VPD, FD and LAC were 0.76±0.17%, 1.46±0.12 and 2.4±0.87, respectively. No significant difference was found between PCNVs showing a different OCTA pattern, in terms of quantitative OCTA parameters.
Conclusion Fractal analysis provides quantitative parameters demonstrating that PCNVs with different OCTA patterns share the same neovascular architecture and branching complexity. These new findings improve our ability to interpret OCTA slabs, opening new areas of discussion about this type of neovascular lesion.
This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution Non Commercial (CC BY-NC 4.0) license, which permits others to distribute, remix, adapt, build upon this work non-commercially, and license their derivative works on different terms, provided the original work is properly cited, appropriate credit is given, any changes made indicated, and the use is non-commercial. See: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/.
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Polypoidal choroidal vasculopathy (PCV), first described by Yannuzzi et al,1 is believed to be an acquired abnormal choroidal vasculopathy, characterised by polypoidal dilations (named polyps) arising from terminal ends of a choroidal branching vascular network (BVN) underneath the retinal pigment epithelium (RPE).1 2
Recently, two different types of PCVs have been distinguished: type 1 PCV, also named ‘polypoidal choroidal neovascularisation’ (PCNV), located in the sub-RPE space, and type 2 PCV, also called ‘typical PCV’, showing a choroidal localisation.3
Even though more commonly detected in pigmented individuals, PCV lesions have been described in all ethnic groups as a recurrent cause of acute vision loss secondary to serous and haemorrhagic pigment epithelium detachment (PED).4
Clinically, PCV is characterised by the presence of polypoidal lesions, which usually appear as reddish-orange spheroidal subretinal structures arising from choroidal vessels.1 5
On spectral-domain optical coherence tomography (SD-OCT), polypoidal dilatations appear as dome-like RPE elevations (‘peaked PED’) with moderate internal reflectivity, while the BVN corresponds to the two hyper-reflective lines representing Bruch’s membrane and RPE (‘double-layer sign’).4 6 7
Currently, indocyanine green angiography (ICGA) is still recognised as the gold standard for PCV diagnosis, thanks to its ability to detect different structures located underneath the RPE, such as the BVN and polypoidal dilations.8 However, ICGA is expensive, time-consuming and associated with the rare, but serious, risk of allergic or anaphylactic reaction.9 10
Recently, OCT angiography (OCTA), a relatively novel non-invasive imaging modality that can generate detailed angiographic images without dye administration in a few seconds, has been introduced in the clinical practice.9 11 Thanks to its numerous advantages over ICGA, OCTA is now considered as an important, highly sensitive, non-invasive alternative or adjunct to traditional multimodal imaging in the detection of neovascular lesions secondary to age-related macular degeneration (AMD), PCV included.12–15
In particular, in 32 AMD eyes assessed by traditional multimodal imaging and OCTA, the latter technique confirmed the presence of choroidal neovascularisation (CNV) in 81.3% of cases.12 OCTA is also highly sensitive in the detection of inactive CNV, because OCTA visualisation of neovascular lesions is not affected by their activity level and vascular leakage.14 16 17 Similar data have been shown for PCV secondary to AMD. In fact, Huang et al 15 reported high OCTA sensitivity rates in the detection of both BVN and polyps (90% and 86%, respectively), in a cohort of 50 patients.
There is no general agreement on how polypoidal lesions appear on OCTA. Some authors have described them as hypo-reflective aneurysmatic dilations, whereas according to others, they appear as hyper-reflective lesions.13 18 19
Although some theories have been proposed, the reason why PCV may show different features on OCTA scans remains unclear. Recently, fractal analysis of OCTA images has been reported to provide quantitative parameters that are strongly correlated with the OCTA appearance of neovascular lesions in patients with AMD.20 21 To the best of our knowledge, we are unaware of any former published study investigating the application of fractal analysis to PCV lesions resistant to intravitreal injections of anti-vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) agents, the current gold standard in the treatment of PCV.
Several reports have demonstrated the ability of anti-VEGF therapy to decrease exudation and improve, or at least stabilise, vision in these patients; however, only minimal changes have been noted in PCV regression, resulting in frequent recurrences of the disease.
Actually, PCV is considered a chronic disorder, needing a continuous, long-term follow-up and treatment.22
Therefore, the aim of this study was to report quantitative OCTA parameters of PCNV resistant to anti-VEGF treatment in patients with AMD, in an attempt to better understand the different OCTA presentations of PCNV.
This was a retrospective review of all PCNV cases presented at the Odeon Ophthalmology Center, Paris, France, and the Department of Ophthalmology, University Paris Est, Creteil, France, between 6 January 2015 and 19 April 2017.
This study was conducted in compliance with the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki for research involving human subjects and was approved by the Paris and Creteil Institutional Review Committees. Included patients signed a written informed consent to participate in this observational study.
For each patient, PCNV diagnosis, based on the presence of the typical BVN and polypoidal dilations on ICGA,1 2 8 was confirmed by an expert blinded retinal specialist (FC), who meticulously reviewed all clinical and multimodal imaging data, including best corrected visual acuity (BCVA), fluorescein angiography (FA), ICGA (Heidelberg Engineering, Germany), SD-OCT (Heidelberg Engineering) and OCTA.
Exclusion criteria were the presence of any other concomitant ocular disease potentially affecting imaging interpretation (eg, myopia >6 D), ocular inflammation, angioid streaks, relevant opacities of the optic media and history of laser photocoagulation and photodynamic therapy.
All patients enrolled in the study underwent a comprehensive ophthalmic examination, including BCVA measured using the ETDRS charts, multimodal imaging evaluation (FA, ICGA and SD-OCT), and OCTA examination using either the swept-source OCTA Triton (Topcon, Tokyo, Japan) or AngioVue XRTVue Avanti (Optovue, Fremont, California, USA).
The 3×3 angiocube was centred on the PCNV lesions and their appearance was analysed and compared with ICGA. PCNV lesions not entirely included in the OCTA scans were excluded.
Automatic OCTA segmentation was performed by the software embedded in the computer hardware and carefully adjusted in order to better detect blood flow abnormalities suggestive of PCNV and remove immediately segmentation artefacts.
The automatic segmentation provided by the OCTA software was manually adjusted for correct visualisation of the capillary plexus, outer retinal layers and choriocapillaris, in order to better identify the PCNV plane. Furthermore, manual adjustment of the thickness between the two segmentations was necessary to improve PCNV visualisation on the corresponding en face angiogram and immediately remove potential confounders, such as shadowing or projection artefacts.
Then, the location and appearance of each PCNV lesion were analysed by two blinded retinal specialists (RS and FC) and compared with ICGA.
In order to estimate vascular perfusion density (VPD), fractal dimension (FD) and lacunarity (LAC) of the PCNVs, en face OCTA images of the outer retina segmentation were exported into a previously validated custom graphical user interface built in MATLAB (v.r2018a) coding language. Poor quality images with a signal strength index <60 and residual artefacts were excluded from the analysis.
Images were binarised using the Otsu method,23 while filtering of speckle noise was achieved by using a median filter of radius 2 pixels. Small, non-connected pixels <10 were removed. The density map was computed, and the highest density zone was identified. Quantitative OCTA analyses of the blood flow area, VPD, FD and LAC were performed using a graphical interface. The box-counting method at multiple origins was applied to the image of the binary skeleton to estimate the FD and LAC of the vascular network, which are global indices of morphological complexity and structural non-uniformity, respectively. VPD was defined as the total area of perfused vasculature (on the binarised image) per unit area in a region of measurement24 (figure 1).
The results were then automatically exported into a different file for statistical analyses.
Results of descriptive analysis are expressed as counts and percentages for categorical variables and as mean±SD for quantitative variables.
After testing data distribution for normality, paired t-test for continuous variables was performed, as appropriate.
Comparison of mean BCVA between eyes with hypo-reflective and hyper-reflective polyps was performed using the Student’s t-test. A p value <0.05 was considered to be statistically significant.
The study data were analysed using the Statistical Package for Social Sciences version 20.0 for Mac (IBM, Chicago, IL).
A total of 51 patients (31 males, 20 females; mean age 71.73±12.31 years) was included in the study. Eleven patients were enrolled at the Odeon Ophthalmology Center in Paris, France, whereas the remaining 40 were recruited at the Department of Ophthalmology of the University of Paris Est, Creteil, France.
In 33/51 (64.7%) eyes, PCNVs were located in the macular region, while only 18/51 (35.3%) eyes showed PCNVs close to the optic disc.
SD-OCT revealed the presence of subretinal fluid in 40/51 (78.4%) eyes, of whom seven had an associated haemorrhagic component. Intraretinal fluid was observed in 2/51 (4%) eyes; the remaining 9/51 (17.6%) showed both subretinal and intraretinal fluid.
In all cases, early ICGA phase revealed a hyperfluorescent neovascular network corresponding to the BVN with peripheral aneurysmal dilations.
Comparison of mid/late ICGA and OCTA revealed a perfect correspondence in shape and location between the hyperfluorescent BVN on ICGA and the hyper-reflective network on OCTA, appearing as a flat, hyper-reflective PED on simultaneous structural OCT.
Additionally, polypoidal lesions appearing as aneurysmatic hyperfluorescent dilations on ICGA perfectly corresponded to roundish hypo-reflective structures in 34/51 (67%) eyes and hyper-reflective lesions in 17 (33%) eyes, on OCTA slabs of the outer retina.
Representative images of different OCTA patterns of PCNV are shown in figures 2 and 3.
All OCTA findings were matched with the results of multimodal imaging, so as to be sure of the correct location of the PCNV during segmentation analysis.
All eyes were previously treated with intravitreal anti-VEGF agents (mean 5.04±1.56 intravitreal injections).
Mean BCVA was 83.22±14.91 ETDRS letters, and no difference was found in terms of mean BCVA between eyes showing polyps with a different OCTA appearance (hypo-reflective vs hyper-reflective polyps).
In PCNV eyes, mean VPD was 0.76±0.17%, mean FD 1.46±0.12 and mean LAC 2.4±0.87. No statistical difference was found between the two PCNV patterns for all fractal parameters analysed. All demographic characteristics and quantitative OCTA findings are summarised in tables 1 and 2, respectively.
In the last few years, the spread of OCTA in the clinical practice has improved our ability to study PCNV, increasing the understanding of this neovascular disorder.11 13 15 18 19 25
Indeed, some investigations have assessed the three-dimensional structure of PCNV, in an attempt to establish the exact retinal location of the different PCNV components.25 26
These OCTA studies have suggested that polyps and BVN are situated in the compartment space between the RPE and Bruch membrane, rather than in the inner choroid, as previously hypothesised on the basis of traditional clinical findings and angiographic interpretations.26 27 Other reports have detailed the morphological appearance of PCNV secondary to AMD but showed conflicting results. Actually, although en face angiograms clearly show BVN as a hyper-reflective lesion corresponding to a flat PED in structural OCT, the OCTA appearance of polyps remains still debatable.13 18 19
Kim et al 18 evaluated a cohort of 24 eyes with PCNV and rated them as hypo-reflective aneurysmatic dilatations in 50% of cases. Similarly, in a study on 12 PCNV eyes, Srour et al 13 described the polyps as roundish hypo-reflective structures at the edge of the BVN in nine eyes and as hyper-reflective lesions in the remaining three. Conversely, in a cohort of 20 Asiatic patients assessed with swept-source OCTA, Bo et al 19 observed that all polyps appeared as densely or loosely tangled vessels before and after treatment, respectively, rather than aneurysmatic structures.
Some disagreement on how the polypoidal lesions appear on OCTA was also found in our survey. Although the BVN appeared as a hyper-reflective network on the outer retina OCTA segmentation in all the affected eyes, polyps appeared as hypo-reflective aneurysmatic structures in 34/51 (67%) eyes and as hyper-reflective lesions in the remaining 17 (33%).
The reason why polyps show different features on OCTA is still a matter of debate. It is important to note that the ability of OCTA to visualise the blood flow within retinal vessels is limited to a certain range of flow velocities (minimum: 0.5–2 mm/s, saturation: 9 mm/s estimated for current devices). Theoretically, some neovascular networks or parts of them may have a flow speed below the OCTA detection limit.28 In such a condition, polyps may appear as hypo-reflective lesions.
Rebhun et al,29 using a novel OCTA algorithm termed Variable Interscan Time Analysis, have recently demonstrated the presence of variable flow speeds in the different PCNV components and also within the single polyp. In particular, a range of fast/moderate blood flow speeds was found in the BVN, whereas polyps were characterised by slow flow speeds. Interestingly, some polyps showed two different flow speeds within the same lesion, one with a faster and another with a slower flow, thus suggesting a turbulent flow within the polyp, which may account for the absence of OCTA signal in most of them.12 This theory has also been used to explain the OCTA appearance of diabetic retinopathy microaneurysms, which shares several features with PCNV, including the turbulent flow within the lesion and the hypo-reflectivity on OCTA.30
Traditionally, the belief that polyps have a turbulent blood flow comes from the phenomenon of dye washout and pulsatile blood flow observed on ICGA.31 32 However, this ICGA feature is not detectable in all PCNV eyes. On the basis of OCTA analysis, it has been hypothesised that the turbulent blood flow observed in polyps may be caused by the presence of vascular dilations and changes in vascular calibre and direction within the lesion.19
Recently, some authors have postulated that quantitative OCTA parameters obtained by fractal analysis of en face angiograms, such as VPD, FD and LAC, could be reliable biomarkers for an objective assessment of the clinical activity, natural history and prognosis of neovascular lesions secondary to AMD.20 21 Serra et al 20 have demonstrated that FD and LAC are useful biomarkers to distinguish type 1 CNVs with different natural history and prognosis. Similarly, Al-Sheik et al 21 claimed that FD may be a potential biomarker to assess type 1 CNV clinical activity. However, in both studies,20 21 there was no evidence of fractal analysis of OCTA slabs performed in eyes showing PCNV secondary to AMD.
In our investigation, VPD, FD and LAC were 0.76±0.17%, 1.46±0.12 and 2.4±0.87, respectively. Comparing our results with previously published data,21 active PCNVs seem to show higher VPD and lower FD values than those found in active type 1 CNV, a finding suggesting that the neovascular architecture in PCNVs is different from that in type 1 CNV.
PCNV and type 1 CNV share many similarities in terms of therapy and prognosis; therefore, according to the latest research and classification, PCNV has been included in the type I CNV group.33 Conversely, our fractal analysis data seem to support the idea that PCNVs are separate entities, rather than variants of occult CNVs.33
Although the first description of PCNV dates back to more than 30 years ago,1 whether PCNV is a variant of CNV secondary to AMD, or a distinct entity, is still a matter of debate.34 The aim of our study was simply to report quantitative OCTA parameters in PCNV and not to compare PCNV with type 1 CNV. Therefore, future studies are necessary to resolve this actual controversy in clinical retinal research.
After comparing BCVA and quantitative parameters of eyes with different OCTA patterns of PCNV, we failed to find any statistical difference. This result suggests that PCNVs with different OCTA patterns are likely to share the same neovascular organisation and branching complexity. However, we cannot rule out that the different OCTA appearance of polyps might be somehow related to shadowing artefacts. Noteworthy, the more superficial retinal layers and vessels may be falsely detected in the deeper layers because of OCTA projection artefacts. Indeed, since transmitted light diffuses through flowing blood, the deeper layers are reached by fluctuating light, which can create a decorrelation between two successive B-scans at the same location.35 Furthermore, RPE and Bruch membrane alterations, relatively common in patients treated with anti-VEGF agents, may contribute to the hyper-reflective polyp appearance on OCTA scans, due to lower blockade of the light source by RPE. Spaide et al 36 have clarified that the signal from the choroid is low, in comparison to the retina, as light is lost because of scattering and attenuation by RPE and the dense microvasculature in the choriocapillaris. In fact, it is well known that choroidal vessels appear white in areas of RPE atrophy, but they are black in areas with normal RPE.37
Therefore, this raises the interesting questions as to whether treatment-naïve PCNVs show similar features on OCTA.
Our study has several limitations, mainly due to its retrospective nature and the relatively small number of eyes analysed. Furthermore, it is important to acknowledge that the presence of a large serosanguinous PED, haemorrhage or extensive exudation, typically seen in eyes with active PCNV,1 might have somehow influenced fractal analysis results. Last, but not least, we used two different OCTA devices to evaluate PCNV eyes.
As far as we know, this is the first investigation performing fractal analysis on en face angiograms of PCNV secondary to AMD and reporting quantitative OCTA features of PCNV eyes. Furthermore, on the basis of OCTA fractal analysis results, we have demonstrated that PCNVs showing a different appearance on OCTA share the same neovascular organisation and branching complexity and cause equal visual loss. These new findings improve our understanding of PCNV appearance on OCTA, potentially increasing our ability to interpret OCTA slabs and opening new areas of discussion about this type of neovascular lesion.
The authors are sincerely grateful to Dr Sergio Pilia for his assistance in images processing.
Correction notice This paper has been amended since it was published online. The first author's name was incorrectly transposed.
Contributors RS: research design, data acquisition, data analysis, manuscript preparation. FC: data acquisition, data analysis, research design, manuscript preparation. AP: data analysis, manuscript preparation. DC: data acquisition, data analysis. GC and EHS: research design, manuscript preparation.
Funding The authors have not declared a specific grant for this research from any funding agency in the public, commercial or not-for-profit sectors.
Competing interests None declared.
Ethics approval This study was conducted in compliance with the tenets of the Declaration of Helsinki for research involving human subjects and was approved by the Paris and Creteil Institutional Review Committees (IRCs). No number/ID of the approval is provided because this was a retrospective study conducted on already available data. Included patients signed a written informed consent to participate in this observational study.
Provenance and peer review Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data availability statement All data relevant to the study are included in the article or uploaded as supplemental information.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.