AIMS To develop appropriate methods of eye muscle surgery in highly myopic patients with esotropia and hypotropia, with respect to the pathological findings in high resolution magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
METHODS 35 patients with unilateral or bilateral high myopia and strabismus—that is, axial length of the globe averaged 29.4 mm. Multiple coronal, transverse, and parasagittal MRI image planes were obtained using a Siemens Magnetom 1.5 tesla MRI scanner. In 15 patients with a pathological plane of recti extraocular muscles found by MRI and confirmed intraoperatively, a new technique of eye muscle surgery was performed to re-establish the physiological muscle plane. This was checked postoperatively in addition to the measurement of alignment and motility by MRI.
RESULTS The new MRI finding of a dislocation of the lateral rectus (LR) into the temporocaudal quadrant by 3.4 mm requires new surgical techniques. Only fixing the LR in the physiological meridian at the equator with a silicone loop (‘guide pulley’) or a non-absorbable suture is a causal therapy. This yields alignment and improves abduction and elevation.
CONCLUSIONS If the described misalignment of the LR is detected by MRI, a common high dosage recess-resect procedure for esotropia may even aggravate the deviation. The most important aim of eye muscle surgery is to normalise the pathological path of the LR. The restoration of the physiological function of the dislocated LR is remarkable.
- esotropia and hypotropia
- magnetic resonance imaging
- eye muscle surgery
Statistics from Altmetric.com
Numerous theories1-4 about the aetiology of acquired esotropia and hypotropia in high myopia have been published. This reflects the difficulties in the surgical treatment of this restrictive motility disorder with limited abduction and elevation.
In 1969 Hugonnier1 described a ‘myositis’ and found a reduced number of muscular fibres included in fibrous tissue in the lateral rectus (LR). Knapp could not verify this and found no histological abnormality in his examinations.
Paufique, among others, attributed its pathology to sixth nerve palsy.
Duke-Elder and Wybar2 suggested structural changes in the oculomotor muscles as well as a shortening of the optic nerve. Other investigations described pathological findings in the tendon of the LR.
In some studies5-8 the deviation, especially the hypotropia, is characterised by the name ‘heavy eye syndrome’. Here, supposedly, the increased weight of the eyeball or the forward movement of the centre of mass of the globe results in a drop of its anterior half (clinical examination without imaging).
Bagolini et al 9 assumed, by echography, myopathic paralysis of the LR by pressure from the lateral orbital wall.
Roth et al 10 observed a limited motility even after severing of the rectus muscles.
For Demer and von Noorden11 (magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) study) the mechanical restriction limiting rotation was due to contact between the posterior aspects of the elongated globe and the bones of the orbital apex.
Kolling12 (examination by computed tomography (CT) and MRI scans) found the superior and inferior rectus muscles transposed medialwards; alternatively the medial rectus (MR) and LR muscles were transposed downwards, depending on the existence of an esotropia or hypotropia. A simultaneous transposition of the horizontal as well as the vertical extraocular recti muscles (EOMs) was also described.13
Herzau and Ioannakis14 observed intraoperatively an abnormal path of the LR. However, they could not confirm this finding preoperatively by CT or MRI. They described good results in seven recess-resect (R&R) procedures with additional supraposition of the LR at the insertion site.
All these existing theories may be confusing and reflect disappointing results in conventional surgical therapy. Therefore, we intended to verify existing theories by means of high resolution MRI. Our aim was to establish a better understanding and a reasonable, effective therapy—eye muscle surgery.
Material and methods
We examined 35 patients with unilateral or bilateral high axial myopia—that is, axial length of the globe averaging 29.5 mm (the refractive error being more than −15 D). These patients were referred to our department because of strabismus or diplopia. Routine ophthalmic examinations were performed as well as an A- and B-scan echography. Ocular ductions were measured by the synoptometer. Deviations were measured with the prism and cover test at 5 metres and 0.33 metres and at the tangent screen at 2.5 metres in nine diagnostic positions of gaze. All orbits were imaged using a Siemens Magnetom (SP 63) 1.5 tesla MRI scanner. High resolution coronal, transverse, and sagittal T1 weighted, spin echo images were obtained with repetition time (TR) = 550 ms and echo time (TE) = 15 ms; field of view = 21 × 21 cm, pixel matrix = 256 × 512, three acquisitions, slice thickness 2 mm, distance factor 0.25. In an additional dynamic (motion) MRI the patient had to fixate with the less restricted eye for 50 seconds in different positions of gaze. For these ‘flash sequences’ (T1 weighted, gradient echo), TR was reduced to 140–200 ms and the pixel matrix to 160 × 256, maintaining sufficient spatial resolution.
In all patients, the findings during eye muscle surgery could be compared with the MRI results. Distances between the insertion sites of the EOMs as well as distances of the EOMs from the corneal limb were measured (mm). In the 15 patients with a pathological plane of recti EOMs, found by MRI and confirmed intraoperatively, a new technique of eye muscle surgery was performed. This was checked postoperatively in addition to the measurement of alignment and motility by MRI.
The first step for a more causal eye muscle surgery consisted of high resolution MRI scans of the orbit. This resulted in three groups with different surgical approaches.
In 13 patients (median age 52 years) with typical limitation of elevation and abduction, causing an eso- and hypotropia, the MRI showed a dislocation of the LR in the mid orbital region at a median value of 3.4 mm. The clinical characteristics and the eye muscle surgery performed are described in Table 1. In some cases a V pattern esotropia was present. Mean axial length of the globes was 31.8 (SD 2.1) mm. Measurements of the ocular ductions (for example, synoptometer) averaged a maximum abduction of 30° and maximum elevation of 22.5°. The LR had a dislocated, insignificant curved path, taking its course from the origin, shifting into the temporocaudal quadrant, and proceeding to the insertion. The insertion site itself was either in the physiological meridian, which was the case in all patients without preceding surgery, or between the physiological insertion and that of the inferior rectus (in patients RG and MA (Table 1) it was after previous eye muscle surgery). The MRI also revealed the anatomical reason for this unphysiological pathway. The distension and enlargement of the globe, mostly localised in the temporocranial quadrant, will stretch and shift the LR downwards. The characteristic MRI image of the orbit in a patient of group 1 is shown in Figure 1.
According to our MRI findings, the most important aim of eye muscle surgery in group 1 was to normalise the pathological path of the LR. This could be achieved by a large recession of the MR (approximately 12 (SD 3) mm) and a careful resection or anteropositioning of the LR. The LR was additionally fixed in the physiological meridian with a non-absorbable 4/0 suture (white Suturamid) in the way of a modified retroequatorial myopexia (‘faden operation’). Figure 2 shows the characteristic intraoperative situs of group 1 without previous eye muscle surgery. Photographs are of subject HJ, in whom a common R&R surgery of the right eye, in which no LR dislocation was present, was performed 3 months later. Figure 2exhibits the path of the left LR before and after the described procedure. In no case did problems with the sclera occur by suturing the LR in the way described. Postoperatively, these patients had an improved, or even normalised function of the LR, which resulted in a much better ability to elevate and abduct the myopic eye and with good alignment (Table 1).
The described surgical procedure was performed without complications in all subjects in Table 1 labelled ‘f’. An exception is patient RG (Figure 3): the dislocated LR was fixed at the equator in the physiological meridian with a 3.5 mm wide silicone loop (‘guide pulley’). This was necessary because the ‘downwards pulling force’ of the LR was too high for single 4/0 sutures. The fixation of the silicone loop was possible in the sclera in the 1 o’clock position (Fig 3). Figure 2 displays a coronal MRI of the same patient in Figure1 (RG) 2 weeks after eye muscle surgery of the left eye: the MR was recessed 10 mm and the LR was fixed in its physiological meridian with a silicone loop which is detectable in the mid orbital region of the left LR. Alignment was achieved and stable up to the 1 year follow up examination. In subjects in Table 1 without fixation of the muscle path of the dislocated LR, the sclera was too thin for anchoring sutures.
In one patient (JB) the mislocated, resected LR was suprapositioned 8 mm above the insertion site, according to Herzau and Ioannakis,14 But the surgical outcome without normalisation of the muscle path was poor (Table 1).
The typical deviations in a subject in group 1, in which the right LR was shifted downwards, measured at the tangent screen (distance 2.5 m) in nine positions of gaze are presented in Figure 4.
In two anisometropic patients with exo- and hypotropia, the MR but not the LR showed a caudal dislocation. Thus, the MR had a curved path, taking its course from the insertion to the origin into the lower medial quadrant. The insertion site itself showed normal morphology. In the first subject the right MR showed a caudal dislocation by 4 mm. The preoperative deviation measured 25° exotropia and 15° hypotropia of the right eye. The right eye could be adducted 35° beyond midline. According to the procedure described for the LR in group 1, a recession of the LR of 7 mm and a resection of the MR of 7 mm with an additional fixation in the physiological meridian with a non-absorbable 4/0 suture were performed. Elevation was improved postoperatively from 5° to 15° beyond midline and alignment was achieved.
In the second subject adduction and elevation were not restricted. Exotropia was −28° and hypotropia 6°. In both eyes (axial length right eye 28.8, left eye 24.0 mm) the MR was shifted downwards by 3.5 mm. During intraoperative inspection the sclera appeared too thin for anchoring sutures. In order to shift the dislocated MR upwards, we tried to apply a 6 mm wide silicone loop between the superior rectus and the MR. This unfortunately caused a pathological path of the superior rectus. Therefore, we suprapositioned the MR insertion by 7 mm.
In 20 subjects (median age 44 years) with median axial length of 28.1 (SD 2.3) mm, the plane as well as the insertion site of the rectus EOMs, was normal. In group 3, abduction averaged 40° and elevation 40°. Therefore, the resulting esotropia averaged only 13° (group 1, median 30°). Conventional R&R surgery was performed and alignment was achieved in all 20 patients.
Before surgery, an orbital MRI scan may be useful in patients with high myopia and strabismus, resulting from restricted abduction and elevation. If the scan shows the described pathological course of the LR, a common R&R procedure for esotropia may even aggravate the deviation. The described dislocation of the LR will reduce its abducting torque and create depressing and extorting torques. This will result in increased esotropia and hypotropia in abduction, because the more the eye is abducted, the more the LR becomes a depressor (Figure4).
In view of our new findings, we had good results by suturing the LR to the physiological (3 or 9 o’clock) meridian respiratory muscle path with a non-absorbable suture or silicone loop at the equator as a ‘guide pulley’. An additional, conventional highly dosed recession of the MR in combination with a dosed resection of the LR was also performed. A possible problem in these highly myopic patients may result (compared with retinal detachment surgery) from a potentially thinned sclera. Fortunately, even the highly stressed 4/0 sutures (spatula needles) did not create retinal problems.
A simple supraposition of 8 mm of the insertion site of the LR may be performed because of possible scleral, and consequently retinal, problems. But this procedure has the disadvantage of a persisting pathological muscle path of the LR in the equator region—that is, in the anterior and mid orbital region. Thus, the continuous force of the LR into the non-physiological direction may prevent the normalisation of the motility and alignment. Moreover, the high tension may shift even the resected and sutured tendinous insertion of the LR downwards. Because the sclera may be too thin for anchoring sutures, we discussed the concept of an artificial intermuscular membrane—for example, by a silicone loop between the superior rectus and the LR. Even though this idea is convincing, practical problems resulted from a pathological direction of the superior rectus caused by the generated force.
Conflicting surgical concepts may appear in cases with bilateral LR shifting and symmetrically limited elevation but no vertical deviation. If the new technique of fixing the LR in its path in the physiological meridian is substantiated then a bilateral procedure is necessary to improve elevation and to avoid the induction of a vertical deviation.
The pathophysiology can be explained by the increased stretching of the LR as the length of the globe increases and a staphyloma as well as a scleral ectasia develops. The best evaluation of the mainly temporocranial distension of the globe in high myopia is possible in transverse and coronal MRI (or CT) scans. While the side slip of normal rectus muscles is approximately zero,16 in these cases of high myopia the structures normally stabilising the path of LR are not able to fulfil their task. These structures are the check ligaments, intermuscular membranes, and the pulleys.17-19 The LR is highly stretched by the mostly temporosuperior distension of the globe and will gradually assume the shortest distance. The reasons for the localisation of the distension mostly in the temporosuperior quadrant of the globe, are very probably histological changes in fibre bundles and fibrils of the posterior sclera, possibly being hereditary, together with antagonistic pull of the superior and inferior oblique muscles.20 This fits in with the accumulation of retinal degenerations in myopia in this quadrant between the insertion of the superior and inferior oblique muscles, where the sclera is stretched and thinned (up to 0.1 mm, normal =1.0 mm). Thus, the globe develops a bubble-like distension in the middle and posterior segment, sparing the anterior segment with the insertion site. It is well known that the anterior scleral ring, into which the recti EOMs insert, fails to show the histopathological light and electron microscopic fibre bundle and fibril changes.20 Therefore, the insertion site of the LR in group 1 and the distances between the insertion sites of the recti EOMs muscles were in the normal range.21
Measurements were performed with a caliper during eye muscle surgery. An increased distance between the insertion of the superior and lateral rectus—that is, a simultaneous shifting of the insertion site of the LR between the physiological insertion site and that of the inferior rectus in the anterior orbit, was observable only in patients 1 (RG) and 2 (MA) (Table 1). This was probably a consequence of preceding eye muscle surgery, in which the LR was cut off and the insertion site adhered further below because of the ‘downwards pulling force’ of the LR. The findings in group 2 show the potential variability of the high myopic globes. In group 3 it was evident in some globes that the elongation was not only present along the anterior-posterior axis, but also along the x axis. This resulted in a ‘large sphere’, typically described for buphthalmos. In these cases, the missing distension decreases the probability of LR shifting.
The other theories mentioned could either not be validated by MRI scans or did not yield these clinically found deviations. Especially, the (motion) MRI ‘flash sequence’ scans in our patients could not detect a mechanical restriction by the bony orbit comparable with the case report of Demer and van Noorden.11 An anatomical objection to the assumption of restricting contact between the enlarged globe and the bony orbit would be that the eyeballs are expected to adapt to the position of least friction, which is in exotropia, with the ocular axis aligned with the orbital axis. In MRI scans or during eye muscle surgery a simultaneous transposition of the superior and inferior rectus medialwards or a transposition of the MR and LR downwards was never detected. Kolling12 and Kommerell13described this finding and explained it by the increased stretching of all rectus muscles. This theory is not convincing, because the increasing stretch would change the insertion site along the y axis in a cartesian coordinate system. Finally, the theory or expression of the ‘heavy eye syndrome’, which was still being published in 19955: of course, a myopic eye with too much weight would have to rotate around the x axis of the orbit to produce a hypotropia without any esodeviation. A lot of anatomical and physiological imagination is needed to envisage such a mechanism. None of the authors supporting this theory5-8 ever determined the actual weight and, more importantly—the shape of highly myopic eyeballs—for example, post mortem in cadavers.
Supported in part by Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft DFG 477/61/96
Presented in part at the annual meeting of the Association for Research in Vision and Ophthalmology, Ft Lauderdale, Florida, April 1996.
If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.