Article Text


Optic nerve oxygen tension: the effects of timolol and dorzolamide
  1. J F Kiilgaard1,2,
  2. D B Pedersen1,2,
  3. T Eysteinsson3,
  4. M la Cour1,
  5. K Bang4,
  6. P K Jensen1,
  7. E Stefánsson3
  1. 1Department of Ophthalmology, Rigshospitalet, Copenhagen, Denmark
  2. 2University of Copenhagen, Denmark
  3. 3Department of Ophthalmology, University of Iceland, Reykjavik, Iceland
  4. 4Merck, Sharp & Dohme, Glostrup, Denmark
  1. Correspondence to: Jens Folke Kiilgaard MD PhD, Department of Ophthalmology, Rigshospitalet, Blegdamsvej 9, 2100 Copenhagen Ø, Denmark;


Background/aims: The authors have previously reported that carbonic anhydrase inhibitors such as acetazolamide and dorzolamide raise optic nerve oxygen tension (ONPO2) in pigs. The purpose of the present study was to investigate whether timolol, which belongs to another group of glaucoma drugs called β blockers, has a similar effect. In addition, the effect of dorzolamide and timolol in combination was studied.

Methods: Polarographic oxygen electrodes were placed transvitreally over the optic disc in anaesthetised pigs and ONPO2 was recorded continually. Drugs were administered intravenously either as 100 mg timolol followed by 500 mg dorzolamide (n = 5), 500 mg dorzolamide followed by 100 mg timolol (n = 5), or 100 mg timolol and 500 mg dorzolamide given simultaneously (n = 5). Arterial blood pressure, blood gasses, and heart rate were recorded.

Results: ONPO2 was unaffected by administration of 100 mg timolol as an intravenous injection (n = 5). Administration of 500 mg dorzolamide by itself significantly increased ONPO2 from 2.96 (SD 0.62) kPa to 3.69 (SD 0.88) kPa (n = 4, p = 0.035). The dorzolamide induced ONPO2 increase was not significantly different from the ONPO2 increases were seen when dorzolamide was administered simultaneous with (n = 5) or 35 minutes (n = 5) after 100 mg timolol.

Conclusion: Systemic administration of timolol does not affect the optic nerve oxygen tension despite its lowering effect on the intraocular pressure. Additionally, timolol does not affect the ONPO2 increasing effect of dorzolamide.

  • timolol, dorzolamide, optic nerve oxygen tension
  • pig model

Statistics from

Topical β blockers were one of the first effective pressure lowering drugs licensed for the treatment of primary open angle glaucoma. To this day they remain a first line drug for this condition.1 Topical carbonic anhydrase inhibitors (CAIs) are also widely used for lowering intraocular pressure in treating glaucoma, often used in combination with a β blocker.2

At least some forms of glaucoma are considered to have optic nerve ischaemia as an important part of their pathogenesis.3,4 Accordingly, significant research efforts have been devoted to study the effects of β blockers on retinal5–8 and optic nerve blood flow.9,10 Conflicting results have emerged from this; some of the reports have found that β blockers decrease optic nerve head blood flow and others that they increase or do not affect blood flow.

We have previously shown that carbonic anhydrase inhibitors such as acetazolamide and dorzolamide elevate the oxygen tension of the optic nerve in pigs.11 In the present study, we investigated the effects of the β blocker timolol on optic nerve oxygen tension. We also analysed the interactions between timolol and dorzolamide with regard to ONPO2.


Domestic pigs (Danish Landrace) (n = 15), 28–30 kg in weight and brought up in a specific pathogen free environment, were used as experimental animals. Their treatment was supervised by a veterinarian nurse and followed the ARVO resolution for the use of animals in ophthalmic and vision research. Permission for the use of pigs in this study was granted by Dyreforsøgstilsynet (Danish Animal Experiments Inspectorate).

Dorzolamide HCl and timolol eye drops (Timacar) was obtained from Merck, Sharp & Dohme (Glostrup, Denmark). Dorzolamide was dissolved as a 3% solution in 100 mM citrate buffer, pH 5.6.

Anaesthesia and animal preparation

Anaesthesia was induced by an intramuscular injection of 15 mg midazolam (Dumex-Alpharma) followed by 3 ml of a mixture of tiletamin 25 mg/ml and zolazapam 25 mg/ml (Zoletil 50 vet, Boehringer Ingelheim), xylazin 13 mg/ml (Narcoxyl vet, Veterinaria AG), ketalar 15 mg/ml (Ketaminol, Veterinaria AG), and methadone 2.5/ml (Methadon DAK, Nycomed). After induction, the pigs were intubated, and artificially ventilated with air. Catheters were placed in the left femoral artery, left femoral vein, and in the left cranial superficial epigastrical vein. During the experiment, anaesthesia was maintained by infusion of pancuronium bromide 8 mg/hour (Pavulon, Organon) and fentanyl 400 μg/hour (Fentanyl, Dumex-Alpharma) in one vein and pentobarbital 300 mg/hour (mebumal, Den Kongelige Veterinær-og Landbohøjskoles Apotek, Denmark) in the other vein.

Heart rate (HR) and mean arterial blood pressure (MAP) was monitored throughout the experiments.

The pig was placed in a sling and the head additionally secured stereotactically. A speculum was placed between the eyelids of the left eye. The pupil of this eye was dilated with 1% atropine eye drops (Atropin SAD, Sygehusapotekerne i DK), 0.4% oxybuprocaine (Oxybuprokain SAD, Sygehusapotekerne i DK), 1% cyclopentolate (Cyclogyl, Alcon), and 2.5% methaoxedrine (methaoxedrine SAD, Sygehusapotekerne i DK). Two 4–0 silk traction sutures were placed in the sclera to immobilise the eye. A sclerotomy was made 2.0 mm behind the limbus in the superior nasal quadrant and a plastic cannula (16 gauge) was placed in the sclerotomy. To avoid contamination of the electrode with blood products, it was advanced through the cannula.

Oxygen tension measurements

The oxygen tension over the optic nerve was measured with a polarographic oxygen electrode with an internal Ag/AgCl reference electrode, embedded in a 20 gauge needle (model 768–20R, Diamond General Development Corporation, Ann Arbor, MI, USA). The electrode was calibrated and the optic nerve oxygen tension measument were performed as previously described.12

Experimental protocol

Frequent arterial blood samples were drawn from the catheter in the femoral artery, and analysed for oxygen and carbon dioxide tensions and pH, using an ABL 605 blood gas analyser (Radiometer, Copenhagen, Denmark). The respirator was adjusted in stroke volume and frequency to ensure normal blood PO2 (apH) (10–14 kPa), PCO2 (aPCO2) (5.5–7.5 kPa) and pH values (apH) (7.38–7.42) according to the blood samples.

To test the oxygen electrode, the pig was initially given 100% oxygen in the inspiratory air for 10 minutes. After having obtained a stable oxygen tension recording, five pigs were given intravenous injections of 100 mg timolol initially and 500 mg dorzolamide 35 minutes later, five pigs were given intravenous injections of 500 mg dorzolamide and 100 mg timolol 35 minutes afterwards, and five pigs were given a combination of 500 mg dorzolamide and 100 mg timolol intravenously simultaneously. Arterial blood samples were drawn at following time points according to the different drug injections: −1 minute, 1 minute, 10 minutes, and 30 minutes.

The mean total duration of the experiments was 4 hours and 47 (SD 88) minutes (n = 15). The electrode recordings lasted 3 hours and 22 (SD 81) minutes. The oxygen electrode drift was less than −0.1 kPa per hour.

Data processing

ONPO2, MAP, and HR values (averaged over 15 seconds in the Axoscope recording) for baseline and time points after injection of the study drugs were used for all the calculations.

The mean and standard deviation of ONPO2, apH, aPCO2, aPO2, MAP, and HR were calculated (table 1).

Table 1

Baseline values and values 30 minutes after drug injection for optic nerve oxygen tension (ONPO2), arterial blood pH (apH), arterial CO2 tension (aPCO2), arterial oxygen tension (aPO2), mean arterial blood pressure (MAP), and heart rate (HR)

Differences in the parameters before and after drug injections in each pig were tested for significance using Student’s paired two tailed t test. Difference between groups was tested for significance using Student’s unpaired two tailed t test. A significance level of 0.05 was used.

All results (table 1) were presented as mean (SD) (n = number of experiments).

Graphic presentations of the tracings were made in SigmaPlot 2001 for Windows (Version 6.00 SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL, USA).


Timolol injection had no effect on ONPO2 (fig 1A). Baseline ONPO2 was 4.33 (0.25) kPa (n = 5, table 1). This decreased insignificantly by 0.11 (0.16) kPa after timolol injection (n = 5, p = 0.194, figs 1A and 2). Injection of dorzolamide increased ONPO2 significantly by 0.72 (0.39) kPa (n = 4, p = 0.035, figs 1B and 2). One experiment with injection of dorzolamide was excluded because of movement of the pig head; however, the measurements during the following injection of timolol could be performed satisfactorily and was included. When timolol was given to the dorzolamide treated pigs, ONPO2 increased insignificantly by 0.19 (0.30) kPa (n = 5, p = 0.303, fig 1B). Dorzolamide and timolol given simultaneously elevated ONPO2 significantly by 0.83 (0.18) kPa (n = 5, p<0.001, figs 1C and 2) and a similar increase was seen when dorzolamide was given to the timolol treated animal (0.86 (0.34) kPa (n = 5, p<0.001, figs 1A and 2)). There was no significant difference between the effects of injection of 500 mg dorzolamide when it was given in control animals, in timolol treated animals, or simultaneously with timolol (fig 2).

Figure 1

Optic nerve oxygen tension in kPa over time during different kinds of manipulations. (A) The effect of 100 mg timolol injection at time 0 and a subsequent 500 mg dorzolamide injection at 35 minutes. (B) The effect of 500 mg dorzolamide injection at time 0 and a subsequent 100 mg timolol injection at 35 minutes. (C) The effect of a combined injection of 100 mg timolol and 500 mg dorzolamide.

Figure 2

The changes in optic nerve oxygen tension induced by injections of timolol, dorzolamide, dorzolamide after timolol, and a combination of dorzolamide and timolol. *Indicates that the changes in ONPO2 from baseline are significant (Student’s paired t test). Changes in ONPO2 in the treatment groups were compared using Student’s unpaired t tests (p<0.05 = significant difference).

MAP and HR did not change after the injections of timolol, but decreased slightly in some of the groups when dorzolamide was injected (table 1).

Injection of timolol did not affect apH and aPCO2. However, an injection of dorzolamide created a metabolic acidosis, decreasing apH and increasing aPCO2 (table 1). Arterial PO2 did not change in any of the experiments.


There were two new findings in this study. Firstly, timolol injected intravenously had no significant effect on ONPO2. Secondly, the effect of dorzolamide on ONPO2 was not affected by timolol injection given neither before, in combination, nor after dorzolamide.

Carbonic anhydrase inhibitors may increase ONPO2 either through a lowering of the intraocular pressure (IOP), a vasodilatory effect on the vessels in the optic nerve, a decrease in the cellular oxygen metabolism, or a combination of these three factors. In this study we used two commonly used glaucoma drugs known to lower the IOP in glaucoma patients.

Pilot experiments have shown that intravenous injections of 100 mg timolol as well as 500 mg dorzolamide in healthy pigs induce similar decreases in IOP of 5–6 mm Hg (data not shown). However, only dorzolamide was able to induce an increase in ONPO2, demonstrating that not all glaucoma drugs have an effect on the ONPO2 and indicating that decreasing IOP may not be an important factor for the dorzolamide induced increase in ONPO2. This is in line with previous experiments in pigs where the effect of dorzolamide on ONPO2 was shown to be similar in experiments with unclamped and clamped IOP.12 Unfortunately, a direct correlation between IOP and ONPO2 is difficult to show in these types of experiments. Because the oxygen measurements are invasive, the IOP measurements most likely are affected.

It has been shown that carbonic anhydrase inhibitors do not affect the metabolic rate of oxygen in brain tissue.13 Therefore, neither the oxygen metabolism nor the IOP lowering effect of CAI seem to have a role in the effect of CAI on ONPO2. Thus, we believe that the effect of dorzolamide on ONPO2 is caused by a vasodilatation of the optic nerve vasculature through carbon dioxide accumulation, metabolic acidosis, direct myogenic effect, or a combination of these three factors.

The effect of timolol and other β blockers on ocular blood flow has been the subject of much interest. Many of these reports give conflicting results. This may to some degree be because of the use of different techniques, investigations in different vasculature, and also different study subjects. Additionally, most of the techniques measuring blood flow have difficulties in detecting small and moderate differences. The reports find either no effect or a small increase or decrease in ocular blood flow following timolol application.5–10,14–16 In vitro experiments of the diameters of retinal arterioles also show small, but diverging effects.17,18

The only previous study of the effect of timolol on ocular oxygen tension is that of Pakalnis et al19 who studied anterior chamber oxygen tension in the cat and found this to be slightly decreased following timolol application.

MAP and HR decreased slightly in some of the groups where dorzolamide was injected. Dorzolamide is a vasodilatory drug that not only affects the cerebral vessels, but also may affect the systemic arterioles, thereby decreasing the systemic arterial blood pressure. Also the systemic acidosis that dorzolamide induces may lower MAP. β Blockers block the adrenergic effect on the vessels and the heart,20 but timolol affected neither the heart rate nor the mean arterial blood pressure in the pigs in our experiments. However, it is known that β blockers do not cause hypotension in healthy individuals with normal blood pressure.20 It has been shown that intravenous injections of 0.2 mg timolol in healthy awake humans do not affect mean arterial pressure but do decrease heart rate.21 In humans the adrenergic positive chronotropic stimulation of the heart is lowered during sleep.22 We think this is why timolol does not affect the heart rate significantly in the anaesthetised pigs in our experiments.

These experiments were performed with intravenous injections of glaucoma drugs. Dorzolamide was used in a saturating dose of 500 mg and timolol in a comparatively large systemic dose of 100 mg. This application is of course different from the typical topical application of these glaucoma drugs in the human. The aim was to discover the principal pharmacological effects of these drugs on the pig optic nerve and later to proceed to studies with smaller clinical doses in the human glaucoma patient. Having said that, it is of interest that the pharmacological effect of dorzolamide on the optic nerve was present with or without timolol application, before, after, or at the same time as the dorzolamide injection. This suggests that the combination of β blockers and CAIs may be an effective method of affecting optic nerve oxygen tension and blood flow and, at the same time, lowering IOP.


View Abstract

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.