Article Text

Download PDFPDF

In vivo confocal microscopy in fungal keratitis
  1. Emmanuelle Brasnu1,
  2. Tristan Bourcier2,
  3. Bénédicte Dupas1,
  4. Sandrine Degorge3,
  5. Thibault Rodallec4,
  6. Laurent Laroche5,
  7. Vincent Borderie5,
  8. Christophe Baudouin6
  1. 1Department of Ophthalmology III, Quinze-Vingts National Center of Ophthalmology, Paris, France
  2. 2Department of Ophthalmology, Strasbourg Universitary Hospital, Strasbourg, France
  3. 3Quinze-Vingts National Center of Ophthalmology, Laboratory, Paris, France
  4. 4Department of Ophthalmology II, Quinze-Vingts National Center of Ophthalmology, Paris, France
  5. 5Department of Ophthalmology V, Quinze-Vingts National Center of Ophthalmology, Paris, France
  6. 6Quinze-Vingts National Center of Ophthalmology, Department of Ophthalmology III, Paris, France; INSERM, UMR S 872, Cordeliers Biomedical Institute, Paris Descartes and Pierre et Marie Curie Universities, Paris, France
  1. Correspondence to: Professor C Baudouin Hôpital des Quinze-Vingts, Service III, 28 rue de Charenton, 75012 Paris, France; baudouin{at}quinze-vingts.fr

Abstract

Background: Fungal keratitis is a major blinding eye disease found throughout the world, particularly in developing countries. Given the recent increase in Fusarium keratitis infections in contact lens wearers owing to contact lens solutions, a warning was recently issued by the Food and Drug Administration, making it a public health concern in developed countries.

Objective: To show the advantages of in vivo confocal microscopy imaging using the Heidelberg Retina Tomograph II-Rostock Cornea Module (HRTII-RCM) in the early diagnosis of fungal keratitis.

Methods: HRTII-RCM confocal microscopy was performed on five patients presenting with fungal keratitis and on three donor corneas contaminated with Fusarium solani, Aspergillus fumigatus and Candida albicans.

Results: Direct microscopic evaluation of corneal smears and culture revealed the presence of F solani in four cases and C albicans in one case. HRTII-RCM examination of the infected patients and contaminated donor corneas revealed numerous high-contrast elements resembling Fusarium, Aspergillus hyphae or Candida pseudofilaments in the anterior stroma.

Conclusion: HRTII-RCM in vivo confocal microscopy is a new, non-invasive and rapid technique for the early diagnosis of fungal keratitis, showing high-resolution images resembling fungal structures in the early phase of the disease.

  • FK, fungal keratitis
  • HRTII-RCM, Heidelberg Retina Tomograph II-Rostock Cornea Module
View Full Text

Statistics from Altmetric.com

Fungal keratitis (FK) is a severe blinding eye disease as well as a major and increasing cause of ocular morbidity throughout the world. The poor prognosis is linked to clinical and microbiological diagnostic difficulties, severe complications and currently unsatisfactory treatments.1 The clinical features of FK are not specific, and clinically it resembles more common causes of infectious keratitis. As antifungal agents available today are mostly fungistatic, anatomic loss of the eye occurs in 9–26.3% of patients despite a prolonged course of toxic medical treatment.2 According to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, it is now a public health concern in developed countries, with a recent increase in Fusarium keratitis infections associated with contact lens wearers using the ReNu with MoistureLoc contact lens cleaning solution (Rochester, New York, USA).3 Thus, this product was subsequently taken off the market, with the support of the US Food and Drug Administration.4 Our purpose was to show the advantages of in vivo confocal microscopy imaging using the Heidelberg Retina Tomograph II-Rostock Cornea Module (HRTII-RCM) in the early diagnosis of FK, allowing early initiation of treatment.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Five patients presenting with clinical signs and symptoms of FK were examined using a new in vivo confocal microscope, the HRTII-RCM (Heidelberg Engineering, Heidelberg, Germany). With the addition of the Rostock Cornea Module, the HRTII is converted to an in vivo confocal laser scanning microscope. Before microscopy, one drop of topical anaesthetic (oxybuprocaine chlorhydrate 1.6 mg/0.4 ml) and one drop of gel tear substitute (carbomer 0.2%) were instilled in the lower conjunctival fornix. The x–y position of the image and section depth were controlled manually. According to the type of lens used to perform the examination, two sizes of 384×384 pixel images were obtained: 300 μm×300 μm and 400 μm×400 μm.

All patients underwent laboratory investigations after ophthalmic examination and confocal microscopy were completed: direct microscopic evaluation and corneal scraping culture.

For comparison with patient findings and validation of images obtained in vivo, confocal microscopy imaging using the HRTII-RCM was separately performed on three donor corneas from the Saint Antoine University Hospital Eye Bank, Paris, France, 2 days after contamination with Fusarium solani, Aspergillus fumigatus and Candida albicans, from three strains cultured in the Quinze-Vingts Hospital Microbiology Laboratory, Paris, France.

As HRTII-RCM confocal microscopy is routinely used for examination of ocular surface disorders, is non-invasive, painless and does not raise any risk of complication,5 the ethics committee of Paris 6 University had stated that exploration of the cornea using this technique did not require specific approval. Informed consent for the purpose of the examination was obtained from all subjects.

RESULTS

Our cohort was composed of four women and one man. Mean age was 45.2 years (range 24–68). All patients were regular bilateral contact lens wearers presenting with unilateral corneal symptoms (ocular pain, blurred vision). Average duration of symptoms was 9 days (range 2–21). In all patients, slit-lamp examination showed a unilateral corneal infectious ulcer (figs 1A and 2A), with stromal reaction associated with conjunctival injection, and anterior chamber reaction up to 2+cells.

Figure 1

 (A) Slit-lamp examination of a Fusarium solani-infected patient’s cornea showing the corneal ulcer. (B) Direct microscopic evaluation of F solani-infected patients’ corneal smears (Gram staining; magnification 400×) showing F solani hyphae (arrow). (C, D) Heidelberg Retina Tomograph II-Rostock Cornea Module images (300 μm ×300 μm) of two Fusarium solani-infected patients’ corneas showing high-contrast lines resembling Fusarium hyphae (white arrows), high-contrast structures consistent with corneal nerves (arrowheads) and round inflammatory cells (black arrows).

Figure 2

 (A) Slit-lamp examination of the Candida albicans-infected patient’s cornea showing the corneal ulcer. (B) Cytological examination of the C albicans-infected patients’ corneal smears (May–Grunwald–Giemsa staining; magnification 1000×) showing C albicans pseudofilaments (arrow). (C,D) HRTII-RCM images (400 μm×400 μm) of the C albicans-infected patient’s cornea showing high-contrast elongated particles resembling Candida pseudofilaments (white arrows) and dendritiform inflammatory cells (black arrows).

Laboratory investigations performed on the patients’ corneal scrapings further confirmed the fungal infection in all cases. Direct microscopic evaluation of corneal smears and culture revealed the presence of Fusarium solani (fig 1B) in four cases and C albicans in one case (fig 2B).

HRTII-RCM examinations were performed before obtaining the microbiological results. The four F solani-infected patients’ corneas revealed numerous high-contrast lines 200–300 μm in length and 3–5 μm in width, with branches at 90° angles in the anterior stroma resembling Fusarium hyphae (fig 1C,D).

HRTII-RCM examination of the C albicans-infected patient’s cornea revealed numerous high-contrast elongated particles measuring 10–40 μm in length and 5–10 μm in width in the anterior stroma, resembling Candida pseudofilaments (fig 2C). In all cases, dendritiform and round inflammatory cells were present at the epithelial level and in the area of stromal infiltrates (figs 1D and 2D). Epithelial and stromal disorganisation was also observed, showing corneal fibroblast activation.

HRTII-RCM examination of the F solani-contaminated donor cornea revealed numerous high-contrast lines 200–300 μm in length and 3–5 μm in width, with branches at 90° angles resembling Fusarium hyphae and consistent with both the in vivo findings in infected patients and the cytological examination of corneal smears (fig 3A,B). HRTII-RCM examination of the A fumigatus-contaminated donor cornea revealed numerous high-contrast lines 200–300 μm in length and 3–5 μm in width, with branches at 45° angles resembling Aspergillus hyphae (fig 4A,B). HRTII examination of the C albicans-contaminated donor cornea revealed numerous characteristic high-contrast elongated particles measuring 10–40 μm in length and 5–10 μm in width, consistent with Candida pseudofilaments (fig 4C,D).

Figure 3

 (A) Cytological examination (no staining, magnification 500×) of the Fusarium solani-contaminated donor cornea showing Fusarium hyphae (arrow). (B) Heidelberg Retina Tomograph II-Rostock Cornea Module image (300 μm ×300 μm) of the F solani-contaminated donor cornea showing high-contrast lines resembling Fusarium hyphae (arrows).

Figure 4

 (A) Cytological examination (no staining, magnification 400×) of the Aspergillus fumigatus-contaminated donor cornea showing Aspergillus hyphae (arrows). (B) Heidelberg Retina Tomograph II-Rostock Cornea Module image (300 μm×300 μm) of the A fumigatus-contaminated donor cornea showing high-contrast lines resembling Aspergillus hyphae (arrows). (C) Cytological examination (no staining; magnification 400×) of the Candida albicans-contaminated donor cornea showing Candida pseudofilaments (arrows). (D) HRTII-RCM image (300 μm×300 μm) of the C albicans-contaminated donor cornea showing high-contrast elongated particles resembling Candida pseudofilaments (arrows).

DISCUSSION

Owing to the non-specific clinical features of FK, clinical diagnosis is difficult in the early phase of the disease, even with a high index of suspicion (history of corneal trauma, contact lens wear, topical steroid use). Laboratory diagnostic methods (direct microscopic evaluation, PCR and culture of corneal scrapings or biopsy specimens) are invasive and have a variable degree of sensitivity.1 Furthermore, approximately one-fourth of fungal cultures become positive only after 2 weeks.6 Therefore, FK is frequently misdiagnosed or diagnosed only at a very late stage, after aggressive treatments for bacterial or viral keratitis, or both, have failed. This delay in diagnosis and treatment can result in an irreversible, but possibly avoidable, loss of vision. Non-invasive, reliable and rapid diagnostic tools such as in vivo confocal microscopy may aid in saving useful vision in many eyes with FK.

In vivo first-generation confocal microscopy techniques have already been used in diagnoses of acanthamoeba and fungal keratitis.7,8,9,10,11 Recently, Babu K and Murthy12 reported a case in which the HRTII-RCM new-generation confocal microscope was used in the diagnosis of a combined fungal and acanthamoeba keratitis. Like the first-generation confocal microscopes, HRTII-RCM provides non-invasive, high-contrast, in vivo images of the cornea at different depths from epithelium to endothelium. Images of fungal structures are obtained immediately and allow early treatment to be started, before laboratory investigations conclude on the definitive diagnosis.

Compared with the first-generation confocal microscopes, the HRTII-RCM has the additional advantages of facilitating the study of epithelial tissues and peripheral structures of the cornea and providing images of much higher resolution of the corneal structures. Its magnification (800×) is higher than what was possible with the first-generation confocal microscopes (380×).13 This amount of magnification is high enough to visualise individual cells, including fungal hyphae and yeast, in the cornea. The high resolution of the new-generation confocal microscopes—that is, close to 1 μm—also improves the sensitivity of this technique to include visualisation of yeast, which has never been reported with first-generation microscopes.

In our study, the patients’ images were compared with images of Fusarium hyphae and Candida pseudofilaments on infected donor corneas, with a strong resemblance between them, further validating our in vivo findings.

The advantage of HRTII-RCM in the early diagnosis of infectious corneal disease has already been described in acanthamoeba keratitis, identifying acanthamoeba cyst-like structures in the cornea.14 In studies of human keratitis, roughly one-third of all corneal ulcers are culture negative.15 Thus, the new-generation confocal microscopes now available might be extremely useful in the management and prognosis of many corneal ulcers, helping in the differential diagnosis between keratomycosis and acanthamoeba keratitis in the early phase of these diseases.

FK is a major ophthalmological problem in agriculture-based geographical regions with hot, humid, tropical and subtropical climates. It has a high prevalence in Asia (South India, China, Bangladesh, Nepal) and also in Ghana and South Florida, where filamentous fungi are implicated as major pathogens.16–18 In regions with temperate climates such as Britain, France and the Northern US, the incidence of FK remains low, and yeast, particularly Candida species, are the most common cause.1,19,20 However, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, FK is increasing in frequency in industrialised countries where it is becoming a public health problem.3 HRTII-RCM may be helpful in managing this infection, providing an earlier diagnosis and earlier empirical treatment, which may lead to a better prognosis.

In conclusion, HRTII-RCM in vivo confocal microscopy is a new, non-invasive and rapid technique for the early diagnosis of FK. Showing high-resolution images of the fungal structures at the early phase of the disease, it allows early specific treatment, which may improve the functional outcome in this often severe disease, no longer limited to developing countries.

REFERENCES

View Abstract

Footnotes

  • Published Online First 6 December 2006

  • Competing interests: None.

Request Permissions

If you wish to reuse any or all of this article please use the link below which will take you to the Copyright Clearance Center’s RightsLink service. You will be able to get a quick price and instant permission to reuse the content in many different ways.

Linked Articles

  • BJO at a glance
    Creig Hoyt