Table 1

Results of PCR and immunofluoroscence assay (IFA) versus tissue culture in the tear fluids and corneal scrapings

Tear fluid*Corneal scraping
Tissue cultureTissue culture
PositiveNegativeTotalPositiveNegativeTotal
PCR+ve12 (5.2%)20 (8.7%)32 (14%)17 (11.1%)39 (25.5%)56 (36.6%)
PCR–ve00 (0%)197 (86%)197 (86%)00 (0%)97 (63.4%)97 (63.4%)
Total12 (5.2%)217 (94.8%)22917 (11.1%)136 (88.9%)153
  • Sensitivity=100% (–)

  • Specificity=90.7% (86.1 to 94.3)

  • PPV=37.5% (21.1 to 56.3)

  • NPV=100% (–)

  • Sensitivity=100% (–)

  • Specificity=71.3% (62.9 to 78.7)

  • PPV=30.3% (18.8 to 44.1)

  • NPV=100% (–)

IFA+ve12 (5.2%)19 (8.3%)31 (13.5%)§17 (11.1%)18 (11.8%)35 (22.9%)
IFA–ve00 (0%)198 (86.4%)198 (86.4%)00 (0%)118 (77.1%)118 (77.1%)
Total12 (5.2%)§217 (94.8%)22917 (11.1%)136 (88.9%)153
  • Sensitivity=100% (–)

  • Specificity=91.2% (86.7 to 94.6)

  • PPV=38.7% (21.8 to 57.8)

  • NPV=100% (–)

  • Sensitivity=100% (–)

  • Specificity=86.7% (79.9 to 92.0)

  • PPV=48.5% (31.4 to 66.0)

  • NPV=100% (–)

  • * In the 153 patients from whom both tears and scrapings were collected, PCR in tear fluid was positive in 28, that is 18.3% (vs 56 (36.6%) in the corneal scraping; p=0.003, test of proportion), IFA was positive in 26, that is 17% (vs 35 (22.9%) in the corneal scraping; p=0.19, test of proportion), and tissue culture was positive in 11, that is 7.2% of cases (vs 17 (11.1%) in the corneal scraping; p=0.23, test of proportion).

  • p<0.0005, κ=0.508.

  • p<0.0005, κ=0.356.

  • § p<0.000, κ=0.522.

  • p<0.0005, κ=0.593.

  • NPV, negative predictive value; PPV, positive predictive value.