Objective: To evaluate the results on malignant melanomas of the eyelid and palpebral conjunctiva treated with iodine-125 (125I) brachytherapy with shielding of the eye.
Design: Noncomparative case series.
Participants: Fourteen patients treated with 125I brachytherapy at an ocular oncology referral center from 1974 through 1996, all of whom had had previous debulking, incomplete resection, or recurrence after surgery.
Intervention: A stainless steel pericorneal ring eyeshield was attached to the extraocular muscles, over which a lid was fitted to protect the cornea without touching it. Iodine-125 seeds in polythene tubes were inserted into the eyelid and attached to the lid margin for a single plane implant. In five cases additional seeds were glued on to the shield as well for a volume implant. A median dose of 37 Gy (range, 17.3-67.6 Gy) was given over the course of 113 hours (range, 47-190 hours) to the outer surface of target volume.
Main outcome measures: Local control is regarded as freedom from recurrence in those without measurable disease and complete clinical regression in those with measurable disease. Morbidity is assessed in terms of function and cosmesis. Survival is given from the time of the implant.
Results: There was local control in 13 patients maintained from 11 to 227 months (median, 39 months). There were two recurrences at 8 and 13 months in the first patient who received 17.3 Gy. Late complications consisted of mild eyelid telangiectasia, mild eyelid atrophy, and loss of eyelashes in most patients. Five patients, four of whom had upper eyelid tumors, experienced a dry eye, which was managed with tear supplements, and one of these patients developed a cataract. A corneal ulcer developed in one eye, which later perforated after treatment of a subsequent bulbar melanoma and was exenterated. Another eye was enucleated after treatment for a subsequent melanoma in the fornix. Cosmesis was acceptable to patient and doctor in the other 12 patients. Vision was maintained in seven patients, reduced in two, and not recorded in the remaining three patients. Three patients died of hematogenous metastases at 44, 62, and 79 months after implant, one of bronchial carcinoma at 46 months and one of an astrocytoma at 39 months. All patients were clear of local disease. The remainder survived for a median of 45 months (range, 18-227 months).
Conclusions: Iodine-125 brachytherapy can be used as an alternative to wide excision or exenteration of these tumors. There was good local control, reasonable maintenance of vision, and good cosmesis.